Smart meters for power grid: Challenges, issues, advantages and status

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2011.02.039Get rights and content

Abstract

Smart meter is an advanced energy meter that measures consumption of electrical energy providing additional information compared to a conventional energy meter. Integration of smart meters into electricity grid involves implementation of a variety of techniques and software, depending on the features that the situation demands. Design of a smart meter depends on the requirements of the utility company as well as the customer. This paper discusses various features and technologies that can be integrated with a smart meter. In fact, deployment of smart meters needs proper selection and implementation of a communication network satisfying the security standards of smart grid communication. This paper outlines various issues and challenges involved in design, deployment, utilization, and maintenance of the smart meter infrastructure. In addition, several applications and advantages of smart meter, in the view of future electricity market are discussed in detail. This paper explains the importance of introducing smart meters in developing countries. In addition, the status of smart metering in various countries is also illustrated.

Introduction

Smart meter is an advanced energy meter that measures the energy consumption of a consumer and provides added information to the utility company compared to a regular energy meter. Smart meters can read real-time energy consumption information including the values of voltage, phase angle and the frequency and securely communicates that data. The ability of smart meters for bidirectional communication of data enables the ability to collect information regarding the electricity fed back to the power grid from customer premises. A smart meter system includes a smart meter, communication infrastructure, and control devices. Smart meters can communicate and execute control commands remotely as well as locally. Smart meters can be used to monitor and also to control all home appliances and devices at the customer's premises. They can also collect diagnostic information about the distribution grid, home appliances, and can communicate with other meters in their reach. They can measure electricity consumption from the grid, support decentralized generation sources and energy storage devices, and bill the customer accordingly. Data collected by smart meters is a combination of parameters such as a unique meter identifier, timestamp of the data, and electricity consumption values. Smart meters can be programmed such that, only power consumed from the utility grid is billed while the power consumed from the distributed generation sources or storage devices owned by the customers is not billed. Smart meters can limit the maximum electricity consumption, and can terminate or re-connect electricity supply to any customer remotely [1], [2]. Fig. 1 shows an architectural model of a conventional energy meter and a smart meter.

A smart meter system employs several control devices, various sensors to identify parameters and devices to transfer the data and command signals. In future electricity distribution grids, smart meters would play an important role in monitoring the performance and the energy usage characteristics of the load on the grid. Collection of energy consumption data from all customers on a regular basis allows the utility companies to manage electricity demand more efficiently and also to advise the customers about the cost efficient ways to use their appliances. In light of this, smart meters can be used to control light, heat, air conditioning and other appliances [3]. Smart meters can be programmed to maintain a schedule for operation of the home appliances and control operation of other devices accordingly. In addition, integration of smart meters helps utility companies in detecting unauthorized consumption and electricity theft in view of improving the distribution efficiency and power quality [4].

Design of future electricity markets is aimed at providing their consumers with highly reliable, flexible, readily accessible and cost-effective energy services by exploiting advantages of both large centralized generators as well as small distributed power generation devices [5]. In addition, distributed generation would be an essential integral part of future household energy systems. Utility companies try to identify more profitable customers to provide optional value added services, as smart meters can identify such customers based on the distributed generation sources and overall power consumption. With all these services and other demand side management techniques require utility companies to collect large quantity of real-time data.

Rest of the paper is organized in the following way: Section 2 details various communication network technologies to date; Section 3 discusses various issues and challenges in developing, deploying and maintaining the smart meters; Section 4 outlines the applications and advantages of introducing the smart meters replacing the existing metering and billing system; Section 5 illustrates the need for implementation of smart meters in developing countries; and Section 6 summarizes the status of implementation of smart meters.

Section snippets

Communication technologies

Of all design considerations, selection of the communication network and design of the communication devices are very important and must satisfy multiple complex requirements. As discussed earlier, utilization of the smart meter system involves a huge amount of data transfer between the utility company, smart meter, and home appliances in the network. This data is sensitive, confidential and access to this data should be restricted to a few personnel. With these restrictions on data, security

Issues and challenges

In general view, efficient management of the grid can be an alternative solution instead of revamping the existing grid. But, in view of technical advantages and enhancements to operation capability, integration of the smart grid stands as a valuable solution in managing the existing grid. However, the design, deployment and maintenance of the smart meter system involve many issues and challenges. Implementation of smart meter system in the distribution system involves several billion dollars

Applications and advantages

Smart Grid System determines the need of aspects such as daily workflow, workforce management, asset management, call center philosophy, and billing systematic. Smart meters can enhance the operation of SCADA system. As smart meter system provides several benefits such as efficient power system control and monitoring, operational decisions those are taken timely to minimize outages and losses [30]. Particularly in micro-grids, smart meters can perform energy cost allocation, fault analysis,

Smart meters for developing countries

In many developing countries, conventional energy meters are used for billing the energy consumed by customers. For ease of operation of the home appliances, monitoring the grid, improving the power quality, improved load sharing, detecting non-technical losses, and other implied advantages, smart meters are to be introduced in developing countries. Power utility companies worldwide lose about 20 billion dollars each year because of non-technical losses [4]. In addition, growing non-technical

Status of smart metering

In view of the advantages and applications, smart meter systems are being under large scale deployment worldwide. For instance, Austin Energy, one of the largest electric utility companies in the US with about 400,000 customers, has begun deploying smart meters to about 260,000 residential customers in 2008 [46]. Centerpoint Energy, a Houston based utility company will have deployed smart meters to about 2 million customers by the year 2012 in the Houston-Metro and Galveston service locations.

Conclusion

This paper reviews several important aspects of smart metering. It explains advantages of smart meter system from utility company as well as in customer point of view. Various potential communication networks for smart meter communication are presented in detail. In addition, several challenges, requirements and issues in design, development, deployment, and maintenance of the smart meter systems are discussed. Finally, need for smart meters in developing countries and status of worldwide

References (50)

  • P.K. Lee et al.

    A practical approach of smart metering in remote monitoring of renewable energy applications

  • A. Vojdani

    Smart integration

    IEEE Power & Energy Magazine

    (November 2008)
  • D.G. Hart

    Using AMI to realize the smart grid

  • Gerwen R, Jaarsma S, Wilhite R. Smart metering. Available from:...
  • S.S. Depuru et al.

    A conceptual design using harmonics to reduce pilfering of electricity

  • M. Chebbo

    EU smart grids framework: electricity networks of the future 2020 and beyond

  • F.M. Cleveland

    Cyber security issues for advanced metering infrastructure

  • V.V. Das

    Wireless communication system for energy meter reading

  • Gunther EW. NIST conceptual model: overview and evolution. Available from:...
  • Smart grids. Carbonmetrics. Available online...
  • B.S. Koay et al.

    Design and implementation of bluetooth energy meter

  • Y.S. Son et al.

    Home energy management system based on power line communication

    IEEE Transactions on Consumer Electronics

    (August 2010)
  • M. Huczala et al.

    Capturing energy meter data over secured power line

  • M. Bauer et al.

    Packet-oriented communication protocols for smart grid services over low-speed PLC

  • Press release: Cisco outlines strategy for highly secure. Smart Grid Infrastructure. Available from:...
  • DiAdamo J. SIP: the clear choice for smart grid communications. Available from:...
  • T. Mander et al.

    New network cyber-security architecture for smart distribution system operations

  • S. Rusitschka et al.

    A low-cost alternative to smart metering infrastructure based on peer-to-peer technologies

  • D.M. Han et al.

    Smart home energy management system using IEEE 802.15.4 and zigbee communication

    IEEE Transactions on Consumer Electronics

    (August 2010)
  • C. Bennett et al.

    Networking AMI smart meters

  • J. Kim et al.

    Power-efficient architecture of zigbee security processing

  • P. Cuvelier et al.

    Proof of concept smart metering

  • A. Hafner et al.

    An electric energy quality meter using hardware reconfigurable computing

  • Hallberg P. Smart grids and networks of the future – eurelectric views. Available from:...
  • Silva D. New ‘smart’ electrical meters raise privacy issues. Available from:...
  • Cited by (400)

    • IoT approach towards smart water usage

      2022, Journal of Cleaner Production
    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text