Feasibility of a handheld near infrared device for the qualitative analysis of bloodstains
Graphical abstract
Introduction
According to the Office for National Statistics, over 1.1 million violent offences occurred within the UK in 2016 [1]. Forensic investigation of these types of offences is likely to involve the identification and analysis of stains from biological fluids, such as blood, semen or saliva, which may be present on a variety of surfaces (both porous and non-porous). The presence or absence of these stains can have a significant effect on the outcome of an investigation, both by elucidating the sequence of events involved in the offence and by linking individuals to an offence via the analysis of DNA. The availability of quick, inexpensive, facile and non-destructive tests that can be carried out at the scene of crime is thus of crucial importance for the timely and accurate identification of body fluids.
Currently, there is a wide range of ‘in-field’ techniques that help forensic investigators determine the identity of crime scene stains. However, most of these techniques are presumptive and may only be used to indicate what the possible identity of a stain may be. A confirmatory test is often required to avoid the risk of false positive or negative results [2]. One well-known example of a presumptive technique is the use of alternate light sources (ALS) to enhance body fluid stains. This technique is particularly useful in visualising stains invisible to the naked eye (or those deposited on dark surfaces) and is based on the fluorescence emission of certain molecules within these fluids after excitation at a particular wavelength [3], [4]. Although fast and simple, this technique is largely non-specific, as many and background substrates can fluoresce at the same wavelength [2]. In addition, blood does not fluoresce upon light source illumination and is therefore incompatible with ALS testing [3], [4]. Another disadvantage of this technique is that certain types of radiation (i.e. ultra-violet) may cause damage to DNA present within the sample [5], [6].
Other presumptive tests for body fluids include various chemical reagents, such as the Kastle-Meyer (KM) test or luminol for blood [7], [8], [9], [10], the acid phosphatase (AP) test for semen [11], [12], or the Phadebas® test for saliva. Most of these are based on specific chemical properties of molecules present in the target body fluid, such as the peroxidase-like activity of haemoglobin (KM test), or the action of salivary amylase on starch (the Phadebas® test) [13], [14]. Such activity is then used to generate a change of colour or luminescence (as in the case of luminol) to indicate a positive result. While in some cases a surface stain will be analysed by first rubbing a piece of filter paper on it and then applying the chosen reagent to the paper, when the amount of sample is limited the reagent will be applied directly to the stain on its original surface. This in turn may prevent the stain from being used for subsequent DNA testing. In addition, some chemical presumptive tests require total darkness for proper visualisation (i.e. Luminol) [9], [10] and most of such reagents may only identify one type of body fluid per test.
More recently, body fluid identification has been performed using immunological chromatographic testing cartridges, which exploit specific antibody-antigen interactions to differentiate between different fluids. One commercially available example of this technology is the Hematrace® device used for the identification of bloodstains [15]. Although quick and specific, the main disadvantage of such devices is that they are sample destructive (i.e. fluid samples cannot be recovered from the cartridge after testing), an important issue in situations where the amount of sample available is small.
In view of these challenges, it has become necessary to develop new techniques that can be used to identify biological fluid stains directly at the scene of a crime. Recent technological progress has allowed manufacturers to miniaturize a number of analytical instrumentation, resulting in the production of portable and handheld devices that enable scientists to carry out analysis at any location [16], [17], [18], [19], [20]. The development of devices for the examination of evidence at crime scenes, without the need for transportation to a specialist laboratory (which is often costly and time-consuming) is therefore of great interest to the forensic body fluid identification community.
Current efforts to achieve this goal have largely focused on spectroscopic techniques, widely used in many other analytical disciplines [21], [22]. A number of studies have already been performed to determine the effectiveness of various spectroscopic techniques for the identification of biological fluids, including ultraviolet-visible (UV–vis) [21], infrared (IR) [23], [24], [25] and Raman spectroscopy [26], [27], [28], [29]. While UV radiation may damage DNA contained within a fluid sample [5], [6], IR spectroscopy has proven to be an interesting means to ‘fingerprint’ body fluids as this technique can determine the presence of specific classes of molecules in body fluids with sample volumes as small as 10–20 µL [23], [24], [25]. Nevertheless, most of the IR studies carried out so far employ benchtop instruments that cannot be taken to the crime scene. There is also the additional disadvantage that the presence of any water in the sample could interfere with the detection of certain types of analytes [25]. There have been successful attempts to identify the signature of different body fluids using Raman spectroscopy, coupled with near-infrared (NIR) excitation [26], [27], [28]. However, when not coupled to NIR, Raman spectroscopy presents some drawbacks, such as the strong fluorescence generated by some substrates (such as glass), which can mask signals produced from body fluid samples [26], [27].
Within the context of forensic analysis, NIR spectroscopy can offer several advantages including:
- •
Little or no sample preparation, which may allow users to analyse evidence in situ i.e. at the scene of crime [30].
- •
Rapid sample scanning time (completed within a few seconds), which could significantly reduce the amount of time spent on a case [30].
- •
Non-destructive analysis, preventing the loss of samples needed for downstream DNA processing [30].
- •
Ability to scan samples inside glass or plastic containers, which may be potentially useful in applications such as the analysis of seized drugs of abuse, or the analysis of evidence at the scene of crime without unwrapping it or taking it out of its container [31], [32], [33], [34].
- •
Minimal masking of analytes bands due to the presence of water molecules are well known and localised [35], [36].
- •
No issues with fluorescence from background substrates, which could potentially mask the presence of biological samples [26], [27], [28].
This study therefore investigates the use of a handheld NIR device, the SCiO® made by Consumer Physics®, for the identification of body fluid stains. SCiO® is a handheld NIR spectrometer, able to scan solid and liquid samples in the range of 700–1100 nm, the region of the third overtone in the NIR spectrum [30]. The detector of this device measures attenuated reflectance from the sample scanned, which means the device allows the user to scan samples on opaque surfaces. The device is connected to a mobile phone by Bluetooth and controlled through the mobile app SCiO® Lab. Through this app the device sends the data obtained from the sample and displays it in a user-friendly format while, at the same time, uploads the data to an online ‘cloud’ database so it can be studied on any other device.
As blood is one of the body fluids most commonly found at the scene of crime, bloodstains were selected as the focus of this investigation. First, a number of classification models were created using online software tools provided by Consumer Physics® (https://www.consumerphysics.com/, Israel) after scanning samples of blood deposited on different surfaces. Although full details are proprietary, these tools utilise a “powerful cloud-based machine learning” method which is based on Partial Least Square Regression (PLSR), a multivariate often used as an alternative to Principal Component Analysis (PCA) [37]. After data processing, the performance of each model was tested by using them to identify new samples on glass. Only a few studies have investigated the use of NIR spectroscopy for the characterization of biological evidence in a forensic context [38], [39]. Edelman et al. [38] showed that NIR spectroscopy has the potential to be employed not only for the identification of body fluids but also to estimate the time since deposition of a stain. The study however employed a benchtop instrument.
Pereira et al. [38] recently sought to identify bloodstains for forensic purposes utilising the MicroNIR™ handheld NIR spectrometer produced by US company Viavi. Whilst successfully able to differentiate human blood from several animal blood and non-blood samples, this specific device is unlikely to be amenable to current crime scene testing processes. First, it may be challenging for scenes of crime officers and police responders (who are likely to have limited spectroscopy training) to operate the specialized chemometric software required for data analysis. Conversely, SCiO® Lab software allows the development of dedicated applications for the testing of specific sample types, which allow personnel with no background in NIR analysis to use the device “as is” with minimal user input. Second, unlike the SCiO® device which is currently priced at around £225, the MicroNIR™ may cost between £16–20,000 depending upon application. Purchasing an array of such devices for crime scene deployment is likely to be unfavourable with forensic service providers in a time where analysis budgets are increasingly restricted. Lastly, the MicroNIR™ device does not support wireless operation of ‘cloud’-based data storage.
All this considered, the success of this study would mean that a handheld device might have the potential to be used as a fluid identification technique directly at the scene of crime with no need of sample preparation, thus, reducing the cost and time needed for forensic examinations.
Section snippets
Device and software
All scans were carried out using the SCiO® NIR scanner from Consumer Physics (Tel Aviv, Israel) as illustrated in Fig. 1. Samples were scanned on a flat benchtop, with the device placed over the sample using the shade provided in order to protect the sample from any external source of light. All samples on glass slides or thin surface materials were kept at a height of 5 cm, preventing the device from inadvertently scanning any surface below the samples. Data collection was controlled via the
Data collection
First (for baseline offset differences removal) and Second Derivative (for baseline offset and slope differences removal) and SNV (as a scatter-corrective pre-processing) were initially investigated as potential pre-processing methods [41], [43], [44]. Furthermore, NIR spectra can display peaks that are characteristic of water molecules; within the range scanned by the SCiO device there are two water bands, at 760 nm and 970 nm [36]. Therefore, in addition to using the data from the full
Conclusions
The goal of this study was to determine if the SCiO® NIR device may be able to differentiate bloodstains from blood-like substances that may also be present at the scene of a crime. The results showed that it was possible to create a model with which the device was able to identify blood correctly in 94% of the cases with a rate of false positives of 14% of the blood-like samples. This means that SCiO® has the potential to become a rapid (with analysis taking less than a minute per sample) and
Acknowledgements
We would like to gratefully acknowledge all the donors that selflessly provided samples for this study. Additional thanks are given to Dr. Arundhuti Sen for her valuable input and advice.
References (55)
Detection of semen and blood stains using polilight as a light source
Forensic Sci. Int.
(1991)- et al.
Using the new Phadebas® Forensic Press test to find crime scene saliva stains suitable for DNA analysis
Forensic Sci. Int. Genet. Suppl. Ser.
(2008) - et al.
Recent developments in handheld and portable optosensing-a review
Anal. Chim. Acta
(2011) - et al.
Portable X-ray fluorescence spectroscopy as a rapid screening technique for analysis of TiO2 and ZnO in sunscreens
Spectrochim. Acta Part B At. Spectrosc.
(2016) - et al.
Evaluation of portable Raman spectroscopy and handheld X-ray fluorescence analysis (hXRF) for the direct analysis of glyptics
Spectrochim. Acta A Mol. Biomol. Spectrosc.
(2016) - et al.
Emerging spectrometric techniques for the forensic analysis of body fluids
Trends Anal. Chem.
(2015) The detection and discrimination of human body fluids using ATR FT-IR spectroscopy
Forensic Sci. Int.
(2015)- et al.
Comparison of different infrared measurement techniques in the clinical analysis of biofluids
Trends Anal. Chem.
(1996) - et al.
Raman spectroscopy offers great potential for the nondestructive confirmatory identification of body fluids
Forensic Sci. Int.
(2008) - et al.
Analysis of body fluids for forensic purposes: from laboratory testing to non-destructive rapid confirmatory identification at a crime scene
Forensic Sci. Int.
(2009)
Forensic body fluid identification and differentiation by Raman spectroscopy
Forensic Chem.
Near-infrared spectroscopy and imaging: basic principles and pharmaceutical applications
Adv. Drug Deliv. Rev.
Noninvasive determination of protein conformation in the solid state using near infrared (NIR) spectroscopy
J. Pharm. Sci.
Discriminant analysis of high-dimensional data: a comparison of principal components analysis and partial least squares data reduction methods
Chemom. Intell. Lab. Syst.
Identification and age estimation of blood stains on colored backgrounds by near infrared spectroscopy
Forensic Sci. Int.
Evaluation and identification of blood stains with handheld NIR spectrometer
Microchem. J.
Blood drop size in passive dripping from weapons
Forensic Sci. Int.
Comparison of classification approaches applied to NIR-spectra of clinical study lots
J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal.
Application of NIR reflectance spectroscopy for the identification of pharmaceutical excipients
Anal. Chim. Acta
Validation of chemometric models - a tutorial
Anal. Chim. Acta
The use and misuse of chemometrics for treating classification problems
Trends Anal. Chem.
Characterising the performance of qualitative analytical methods: statistics and terminology
Trends Anal. Chem.
Analytical features in qualitative analysis
Trends Anal. Chem.
Near infrared spectroscopy for qualitative comparison of pharmaceutical batches
J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal.
Implementation of a simple semi-quantitative near-infrared method for the classification of clinical trial tablets
J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal.
Cited by (35)
Enhancing forensic investigations: Identifying bloodstains on various substrates through ATR-FTIR spectroscopy combined with machine learning algorithms
2024, Spectrochimica Acta - Part A: Molecular and Biomolecular SpectroscopyPocket-size near-IR spectrometers for rapid examination of contaminated textile fibres at the crime-scene
2022, Vibrational SpectroscopyCitation Excerpt :This has included the use of miniature NIR instruments for differentiation of authentic and counterfeit banknotes [14], and instant identification of body fluid stains (blood) at the crime scene [21]. Applications for textile analysis are also rising as miniature NIR instruments are low-cost, compact, end-user friendly, small in size and have decent performance [21-23]. In a previous study, we investigated the use of the pocket-size NIR spectrometers (SCIO and NIRscan Nano) for identification of clean textile fibres in-situ but that work did not consider the kind of fibre contamination that would be expected at crime scenes [22].
Unravelling error sources in miniaturized NIR spectroscopic measurements: The case study of forages
2022, Analytica Chimica ActaCitation Excerpt :Indeed, by removing this region no improvement in models capabilities was found. It has already been shown that the use of the complete spectral region is not always the case when considering miniaturized NIR spectrometers [10,42–44], and so a complete evaluation is always recommended. As suggested by literature [10,11], it is possible that, when acquiring spectra with miniaturized NIR spectrometers, some deviations from the theoretical bands may appear.
Unlocking the potential of forensic traces: Analytical approaches to generate investigative leads
2022, Science and JusticeCitation Excerpt :Furthermore, the ease of miniaturisation of NIR detectors makes it a suitable technique for in situ analysis, which could substantially reduce the amount of time required for sample reception and analysis. To date, three studies on the use of NIR spectrometers for forensic body fluid analysis have been reported, with promising results obtained in the identification of blood stains [41–43]. FT-IR gathers structural information from the vibrational data, displaying peaks corresponding to the different molecular bonds.
Hierarchical classification models and Handheld NIR spectrometer to human blood stains identification on different floor tiles
2022, Spectrochimica Acta - Part A: Molecular and Biomolecular SpectroscopyCitation Excerpt :For the identification of blood traces, the advantages mentioned are of great interest, since blood is a complex material and after the sample has been identified, it may be necessary to perform further analyses, such as DNA. The popularization of portable equipment makes the application of these techniques even more manageable for forensic purposes, since the instruments are lightweight, have a relatively low cost, do not require unnecessary reagents, and can be carried to the site of a field analysis, allowing the investigator to save time [20–22]. In addition to the natural complexity involving the interpretation of spectra obtained in the near infrared region, the use of portable instruments at crime scenes makes the analysis even more complex as the traces may be found in different substrates, contexts, and conditions.