Abstract
Patients increasingly see physicians not as humane caregivers but as unfeeling technicians. The study of philosophy in medical school has been proposed to foster critical thinking about one's assumptions, perspectives and biases, encourage greater tolerance toward the ideas of others, and cultivate empathy. I suggest that the study of ethics and philosophy by medical students has failed to produce the humane physicians we seek because of the way the subject matter is quarantined in American medical education. First, the liberal arts are seen as the province of undergraduate education, and not medical school. Second, philosophy, when taught in medical school, is seen by students as just one subject to be mastered along with many other more important ones, and not as a way to foster critical thinking and empathy. What is needed is a new pedagogy that combines both cognitive and affective elements to implant and nourish the liberal arts in students. Removing the quarantine of philosophy from other facets of medical education is an important first step.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bickel, J.: 1991, ‘Medical students’ professional ethics: Defining the problems and developing resources’, Academic Medicine 66, 726–729.
Caplan, A.L.: 1992, ‘Does the philosophy of medicine exist?’, Theoretical Medicine 13, 67–77.
Coombs, R.H. and M.J. Paulson: 1990, ‘Is premedical education dehumanizing? A literature review’, Journal of Medical Humanities 11, 13–22.
Gilligan, C.: 1993, In a Different Voice: Psychological Theory and Women's Development. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Gorovitz, S.: 1998, ‘Healthcare under siege’, Health Decisions 5(4), 1–2.
Jonassen, J.A., C.A. Cardasis and M.A. Clay: 1997, ‘Integrating clinical ethical concepts and patient-centered problem solving into the basic science curriculum’, Academic Medicine 72, 426.
Kay, J.: 1990, ‘Traumatic deidealization and the future of medicine’, Journal of the American Medical Association 263, 572–573.
Kopelman, L.M.: 1983, ‘Cynicism among medical students’, Journal of the American Medical Association 250, 2006–2010.
Kopelman, L.M.: 1995, ‘Philosophy and medical education’, Academic Medicine 70, 795–805.
Patrick, J.: 1991, ‘Meaning and purpose in medicine: The physician in a disenchanted world’, Humane Medicine 7, 195–201.
Pellegrino, E.D.: 1984, ‘The humanities in medical education: Entering the post-evangelical era’, Theoretical Medicine 5, 253–266.
Robinson, J.: 1985, ‘Are we teaching students that patients don't matter?’, Journal of Medical Ethics 11, 19–21.
Self, D.: 1988, ‘The pedagogy of two different approaches to humanistic medical education: Cognitive vs. affective’, Theoretical Medicine 9, 227–236.
Self, D.J., D.E. Schrader, D.C. Baldwin Jr. and F.D. Wolinsky: 1993, ‘The moral development of medical students: A pilot study of the possible influence of medical education’, Medical Education 27, 26–34.
Sheehan, K.H., D.V. Sheehan, K. White, A. Leibowitz and D.C. Baldwin Jr.: 1990, ‘A pilot study of medical student ‘abuse': Student perceptions of mistreatment and misconduct in medical school’, Journal of the American Medical Association 263, 533–537.
Silver, H.K.: 1982, ‘Medical students and medical school’, Journal of the American Medical Association 247, 309–310.
Silver, H.K. and A.D. Glicken: 1990, ‘Medical student abuse: Incidence, severity, and significance’, Journal of the American Medical Association 263, 527–532.
Spike, J.: 1991, ‘The need for teaching philosophy in medical education’, Theoretical Medicine 12, 359–365.
Thomas, L.: 1978, ‘How to fix the premedical curriculum’, New England Journal of Medicine 298, 1180–1181.
Wulff, H.R.: 1992, ‘Philosophy of medicine - from a medical perspective’, Theoretical Medicine 13, 79–85.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Stempsey, W.E. The quarantine of philosophy in medical education: Why teaching the humanities may not produce humane physicians. Med Health Care Philos 2, 3–9 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009936630946
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009936630946