Abstract
This historical study utilizes annual insured bank data from 1936 through 1989 to empirically evaluate the impact of bank regulation on bank risk taking in a cross-country comparison of the United States and Canada. Risk is hypothesized to be determined, in part, by the regulatory environment in which a bank operates. The findings of this analysis contributes to the contemporary deregulation policy debate, since both branch banking restrictions and deposit insurance variables are found to be detrimental to bank stability. More specifically, these results support the 1994 Riegle–Neal Interstate Banking and Branching Efficiency Act, which removed legislative barriers to interstate branching. These results also confirm expectations that deposit insurance increases risk taking and supports the 1991 mandate by regulators that risk-based deposit insurance be created. Further, these findings support the 1988 Basel Accord to standardize bank capital requirements internationally and to link these standards to bank risk taking.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Avery, Robert B. and Gerald A. Hanweck. (1984). “A Dynamic Analysis of Bank Failures.” In Bank Structure and Competition, Proceedings of a Conference Sponsored by the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, 380–401.
Benston, George J. (1991). “Does Bank Regulation Produce Stability? Lessons from the United States.” In Forrest Capie and Goeffrey E. Wood (eds.), Unregulated Banking: Chaos or Order? New York: St. Martins Press, 207–232.
Benston, George J. and George G. Kaufman. (1986). “Risks and Failures in Banking: Overview, History and Evaluation.” In George G. Kaufman and Roger C. Kormendi (eds.), Deregulating Financial Services: Public Policy in Flux. Ballinger Cambridge, MA: Ballinger, 49–77.
Bhattacharya, Sudipto, Arnoud W.A. Boot and Anjan V. Thakor. (1998). The Economics of Bank Regulation.” Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking 30(4), 745–770.
Boot, Arnoud W.A., Silva Dezelan and Todd T. Milbourn. (1999). “Regulatory Distortions in a Competitive Financial Services Industry.” Journal of Financial Services Research 16(2–3), 249–259.
Bordo, Michael, D., Hugh Rockoff and Angela Redish. (1994). “The U.S. Banking System from a Northern Exposure: Stability Versus Efficiency.” The Journal of Economic History 54, 325–341.
Calomiris, CharlesW. and Joseph R. Mason. (1997). “Contagion and Bank Failures During the Great Depression: The 1932 Chicago Banking Panic.” American Economic Review 87(5), 863–883.
Cole, Rebel A. and Jeffrey W. Gunther. (1995). “Separating the Likelihood and Timing of Bank Failure.” Journal of Banking & Finance 19, 1073–1089.
Demirguc-Kunt, Ash. (1989). “Deposit-Institution Failures: A Review of Empirical Literature.” Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland Economic Review, 2–18.
Edwards, Franklin R. and James Scott. (1979). “Regulating the Solvency of Depository Institutions: A Perspective for Deregulation.” In Franklin R. Edwards (ed.), Issues in Financial Regulation. New York: McGraw-Hill, 65–105.
Garrison, Roger W., Eugene D. Short and Gerald O. O'Driscoll, Jr. (1988). “Financial Stability and FDIC Insurance.” In Catherine England, and Thomas Huertas (eds.), The Financial Services Revolution: Policy Direction for the Future, Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers, Chapter 8.
Gilbert, R. Alton. (1975). “Bank Failures and Public Policy.” Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review, November, 7–15.
Granger, Clive W.J. (1981). “Some Properties of Time Series Data and Their Use in Econometric Model Specification.” Journal of Econometrics, May, 121–130.
Horwitz, Steven. (1993). “Government Intervention: Source or Scourge of Monetary Order?” Critical Review 7, 237–257.
Johansen, Sören. (1988). “Statistical Analysis of Cointegration Vectors.” Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, Septmber, 231–254.
Kane, Edward J. (May 1996). “De Jure Interstate Banking: Why Only Now?” Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking 28, 141–161.
Kaufman, George G. (1985). “The Securities Activities of Commercial Banks.” In Handbook for Banking Strategy. New York: Wiley, 661–702.
Kaufman, George G. (1988). “Securities Activities of Commercial Banks: Recent Changes in Economic and Legal Environments.” Journal of Financial Services Research, January, 183–199.
Keeley, Michael. (1992). “Bank Capital Regulation in the 2980s: Effective or Ineffective?” In Anthony Saunders, Gregory F. Udell, and Lawrence J. White (eds.), Bank Management and Regulation. Mountain View, CA: Mayfield, 147–164.
Kelly, Edward J., III. (1985). “Legislative History of the Glass-Steagall Act.” In Ingo Walter (ed.), DeregulatingWall Street: Commercial Bank Penetration of the Corporate Securities Market. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 41–65.
Kryzanowski, Lawrence and Gordon S. Roberts. (1992). “Bank Structure in Canada.” In George G. Kaufman (ed.), Banking Structures in Major Countries. Bostom: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1–57.
Litan, Robert and William Nordhaus. (1983). Reforming Federal Regulation. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Litan, Robert E. (1987). What Should Banks Do? Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.
Litan, Robert E. (1997). “Institutions and Policies for Maintaining Financial Stability.” In Maintaining Financial Stability in a Global Economy. The Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, August, 257–297.
McDonald, John and Robert Moffit. (1980). “The Uses of Tobit Analysis.” The Review of Economics and Statistics, May, 318–321.
McKenzie, George. (1990). “Capital Adequacy Requirements, Deposit Insurance and Bank Behaviour.” The Economic and Social Review 21, 363–375.
Nathan, Alli and Edwin Neave. (1992). “Operating Efficiency of Canadian Banks.” Journal of Financial Services Research 6, 265–276.
Maggs, Gary and David Pate. (1995). “The New Federal Stance on Bank Expansion: The Riegle-Neal Interstate Banking and Branching Efficiency Act of 1994.” Durell Journal of Money and Banking, Fall, 17–22.
Moore, Robert M. (1995). “Does Geographic Liberalization Really Hurt Small Banks?” Financial Industry Studies, Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas, December, 1–12.
O'Driscoll, Gerald P. Jr. (1988). “Bank Failures: The Deposit Insurance Connection.” Contemporary Policy Issues 6, 1–12.
Pantalone, Colleen C. and Marjorie B. Platt. (1987). “Predicting Commercial Bank Failure Since Deregulation.” New England Economic Review, July/August, 37–47.
Peltzman, Sam. (1976). “Toward a More General Theory of Regulation.” Journal of Law and Economics 19, 211–240.
Pierce, James L. (1991). The Future of Banking. The Twentieth Century Fund, Inc.
Rolnick, Arthur J. (1987). “The Benefits of Bank Deposit Rate Ceilings: New Evidence on Bank Rates and Risk in the 1920s.” Quarterly Review, Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, Summer, 2–18.
Salsman, Richard M. (1993). “Bankers as Scapegoats for Government-Created Banking, Crises in U.S. History.” In Lawrence H. White (ed.), The Crisis in American Banking, New York: New York University Press, 81–118.
Shiers, Alden F. (1994). “Deposit Insurance and Banking System Risk: Some Empirical Evidence.” Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance 34, 347–361.
Spong, Kenneth. (1990). Banking Regulation: Its Purposes, Implementation and Effects. Kansas city: Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City.
Stilger, George. (1971). “The Theory of Economic Regulation.” The Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science 2, 3–21.
Swary, Itzhak and Barry Topf. (1992). Global Financial Deregulation: Commercial Banking at the Crossroads. Blackwell, Chapters 7, 8, and 13.
Wheelock, David C. (1992). “Regulation and Bank Failures: New Evidence from the Agricultural Collapse of the 1920s.” Journal of Economic History 52, 806–825.
White, Eugene Nelson. (1986). “Before the Glass-Steagall Act: An Analysis of the Investment Banking Activities of National Banks.” Explorations in Economic History 23, 33–55.
White, Lawrence H. (1993). “Why is the U.S. Banking Industry in Trouble? Business Cycles, Loan Losses, and Deposit Insurance.” In Lawrence H. White (ed.), The Crisis in American Banking, New York: New York University Press, 7–28.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hendrickson, J.M., Nichols, M.W. How Does Regulation Affect the Risk Taking of Banks? A U.S. and Canadian Perspective. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis 3, 59–83 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1011434825287
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1011434825287