Comparison of segmentation tools for structural analysis of bone tissues by finite elements

Medical image segmentation is one of the bases of development in the field of personalized medicine, which allows the reconstruction of parts of the human body to produce virtual models by classifying pixels to create a surface or volume with similar properties. This work is focused on image segmentation through open-source software for bone structure analysis using the finite element method. According to this approach, the aim of this study is to investigate the sequential process, based on the features and requirements of the reconstruction software, to assess the segmentation tools and provide a comparative analysis. The methodology focuses on the software that has been documented for the anatomical reconstruction of organs and tissues, accounting for algorithms of manual, semi-automatic and automatic handling. Three segmentation packages are analyzed: 3D Slicer with a semi-automatic process called Region Growing, ITK-Snap with its interactive mechanism Active Contour segmentation mode, and, finally, In Vesalius with its automatic segmentation technique that identifies types of tissues and a simplified user-machine interface. A comparison is proposed based on the ease of the workflow, time for completion, the robustness of the tool, and precision of the semi-automatic and automatic methods, as opposed to the manual process, by statistic deviations and volume error obtained with Cloud Compare. The segmentation of a vertebra obtained from a DICOM© file in a computerized axial tomography was completed, and performance indicators were evaluated. The results showed that 3D Slicer - Grow from seeds is the best option to make the segmentation with a 9.59% of volume error and the fastest process among others.