Jeffrey Bardzell
Shaowen Bardzell
Erik Stolterman
ABSTRACT
Critical Design has emerged as an important concept in HCI research and practice. Yet researchers have noted that its uptake has been limited by certain lacks of intellectual infrastructure theories, methodologies, canons and exemplars, and a community of practice. We argue that one way to create this infrastructure is to cultivate a community adept at reading that is, critically interpreting and making reasoned judgments about critical designs. We propose an approach to developing close readings of critical designs, which are both evidence-based and carefully reasoned. The approach highlights analytical units of analysis, the relevance of design languages and social norms, and the analytical contemplation of critical aspects of a design. It is intended to be relatively easy to learn, to try out, and to teach, in the hopes of inviting more members of the HCI community to engage in this practice. We exemplify the approach with readings of two critical designs and reflect on different ways that a design might serve a critical purpose or offer a critical argument about design, society, and the future.
- Bardzell, J. (2011). Interaction criticism: An introduc-tion to the practice. Interacting with Computers 23(2011), 604--62 Oxford University Press. Google Scholar
Digital Library
- Bardzell, J., and Bardzell, S. (2013). What is critical about critical design? Proc. of CHI'13. ACM Press. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Bardzell, J., and Bardzell, S. (2013). "A great and trou-bling beauty": Cognitive speculation and ubiquitous computing. Personal and Ubiquitous Computing Google ScholarDigital Library
- Bardzell, S., Bardzell, J., Forlizzi, J., Zimmerman, J., and Antanitis, J. (2012). Critical design and critical the-ory. Proc. of DIS2012. ACM Press. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Barnard, M. (2001). Approaches to Understanding Vis-ual Culture. Palgrave.Google Scholar
- Blevis, E. (2012). The PRInCiPleS design framework. In J. Carroll (ed.). Human-Computer Interaction Series (1)20, 143--169. Springer.Google Scholar
- Bogost, I. (2008). Unit Operations: An Approach to Videogame Criticism. MIT Press. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Bowers, J. (2012). The logic of annotated portfolios: Communicating the value of "research through design." Proc. of DIS2012. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Carroll, N. (2009). On Criticism. Routledge.Google Scholar
- Cross, N. (2006). Designerly Ways of Knowing. Birkhäuser.Google Scholar
- 1Coyne, R. (1995). Designing Information Technology in the Postmodern Age: From Method to Metaphor. MIT Press. Google ScholarDigital Library
- DiSalvo, C. (2009). Design and the construction of pub-lics. Design Issues 25(1), 48--63.Google ScholarCross Ref
- DiSalvo, C. (2012). Adversarial Design. MIT Press. Google ScholarDigital Library
- DiSalvo, C. (2012). Spectacles and Tropes: Speculative Design and Contemporary Food Cultures. The Fibercul-ture Journal 2012 (20), 109--122.Google Scholar
- Dunne, A. (2006). Hertzian Tales: Electronic Products, Aesthetic Experience, and Critical Design. MIT Press. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Dunne, A. & Raby, F. Design for Debate. Convivio Web-Zone 203: http://daisy.cti.gr/webzine/Issues/Issue-%203/Art%20and%20Design/Google Scholar
- Dunne, A., and Raby, F. (2001). Design Noir: The Se-cret Life of Electronic Objects. Birkhäuser.Google Scholar
- Dunne, A., and Raby, F. (2013). Speculative Everything. MIT Press.Google Scholar
- Eagleton, T. (2008). Literary Theory: An Introduction. University of Minnesota Press.Google Scholar
- Gadani, A. (2010). Porcupine Dress. http://amishagadani.com/Work/porcupine/Google Scholar
- 2Gaver, W., Bowers, J., Boucher, A., Gellerson, H., Pen-nington, S., Schmidt, A., Steed, A., Villars, N., Walker, B. (2004). The drift table: Designing for ludic engage-ment. CHI EA'04. ACM Press. Google ScholarDigital Library
- 2Gaver, W. (2012). What should we expect from research through design? Proc. of CHI'12. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Greenberg, S. and Buxton, B. Usability considered harmful (some of the time). Proc. of CHI'08. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Kael, P. (2005 {1965}). The idea of film criticism. In Wartenberg & Curran (eds.), The Philosophy of Film. Malden, MA: Blackwell, 108--17.Google Scholar
- Kant, I. Critique of Judgment. (1987 {1790}). Indianapo-lis: Hackett.Google Scholar
- Koskinen, I., Zimmerman, J., Binder, T., Redstrom, J. and Wensveen, S. (2011). Design Research through Practice. Burlington, MA: Morgan Kaufmann. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Kuutti, K. (2009). HCI and design: Uncomfortable bed-fellows? In Binder, Löwgren & Malmborg (eds.) (Re)searching the Digital Bauhaus. Springer, 43--59.Google Scholar
- Lee, Y. & Lee, K. (2010). Design research and the com-plexity encountered in people's critical thoughts. Proc. of DRS'10.Google Scholar
- Malpass, M. (2010). Perspectives on critical design: A conversation with Ralph Ball and Maxine Naylor. Proc. of DRS'10.Google Scholar
- Mazé, R., & Redström, J. (2007). Difficult forms: Critical practices of design and research. Proc. of IASDR'07.Google Scholar
- 3Nelson, H. and Stolterman, E. (2012). The Design Way. MIT Press.Google Scholar
- 3Schön, D. (1984). Reflective Practitioner. Basic Books.Google Scholar
- 3Taylor, C. Interpretation and the sciences of man. The Review of Metaphysics 25(1), 3--51.Google Scholar
- Zimmerman, J., Forlizzi, J., and Evanson, S. (2007). Research through design as a method for interaction de-sign research in HCI. In Proc. of CHI'07. ACM Press. Google ScholarDigital Library
Index Terms
- Reading critical designs: supporting reasoned interpretations of critical design
Recommendations
In Tension with Progression: Grasping the Frictional Tendencies of Speculative, Critical, and other Alternative Designs
CHI '21: Proceedings of the 2021 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing SystemsSpeculative design, critical design, and other alternative designs have emerged as popular approaches and burgeoning traditions within HCI and design research. While examples of this work abound, comparatively little theory exists for grasping ...
Expanding and Refining Design and Criticality in HCI
CHI '15: Proceedings of the 33rd Annual ACM Conference on Human Factors in Computing SystemsThe term 'critical design' is on the upswing in HCI. We analyze how discourses around 'critical design' are diverging in Design and HCI. We argue that this divergence undermines HCI's ability to learn from and appropriate the design approaches signaled ...
What is "critical" about critical design?
CHI '13: Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing SystemsCritical design is a research through design methodology that foregrounds the ethics of design practice, reveals potentially hidden agendas and values, and explores alternative design values. While it seems to be a timely fit for today's socially, ...
Comments