Abstract
By examining only dysfunctional conflict and ignoring functional conflict, empirical research in marketing has presented only part of the story. This research offers the first systematic look at the antecedents and consequences of both functionaland dysfunctional conflict in intraorganiational relationships. The authors develop and empirically test a causal model for key organizational antecedents of new product strategy quality and market performance. They find that dysfunctional conflict in the decision-making process has deleterious consequences for quality of strategy and market performance, whereas functional conflict improves both quality of strategy and performance. Specifically, organizational design characteristics such as formalization, interdepartmental interconnectedness, low communication barriers, and team spirit improve new product performance by enhancing functional conflict, whereas centralization and high communication barriers lower new product performance by increasing dysfunctional conflict. A post hoc test for common method bias or variance suggests that bias or variance alone cannot explain these findings.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anderson, Erin, Leonard Lodish, and Barton Weitz. 1987. “Resource Allocation Behavior in Conventional Channels.”Journal of Marketing Research 24 (February): 254–262.
————— and Barton Weitz. 1992. “The Use of Pledges to Build and Sustain Commitment in Distribution Channels.”Journal of Marketing Research 29 (February): 18–34.
Anderson, James C. 1987. “An Approach for Confirmatory Measurement and Structural Equation Modeling of Organizational Properties.”Management Science 33 (April): 525–541.
————— and David W. Gerbing. 1988. “Structural Equation Modeling in Practice: A Review and Recommended Two-Step Approach.”Psychological Bulletin 103 (May): 411–423.
————— and James A. Narus. 1990. “A Model of the Distributor Firm and Manufacturer Firm Working Partnerships.”Journal of Marketing 54 (January): 42–58.
Anderson, Paul F. and Terry Chambers. 1985. “A Reward/Measurement Model of Organizational Buying Behavior.”Journal of Marketing 49 (Spring): 7–23.
Armstrong, J. Scott and Terry S. Overton. 1977. “Estimating Nonresponse Bias in Mail Surveys.”Journal of Marketing Research 14 (August): 396–402.
Assael, Henry. 1969. “Constructive Role of Interorganizational Conflict.”Administrative Science Quarterly 14 (December): 573–575.
Bagozzi, Richard P. and Lynn W. Phillips. 1982. “Representing and Testing Organizational Theories: A Holistic Construal.”Administrative Science Quarterly 27 (September): 459–489.
Barabba, Vincent P. and Gerald Zaltman. 1991.Hearing the Voice of the Market: Competitive Advantage Through Creative Use of Market Information. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
Barclay, Donald. 1991. “Interdepartmental Conflict in Organizational Buying: The Impact of the Organizational Context.”Journal of Marketing Research 2 (May): 145–159.
Baron, Robert. 1985. “Reducing Organizational Conflict: The Role of Attributions.”Journal of Applied Psychology 70 (August): 434–441.
—————. 1991. “Positive Effects of Conflict: A Cognitive Perspective.”Employee Responsibilities and Rights Journal 4 (1): 25–36.
Bentler, Peter M. 1990. “Comparative Fit Indexes in Structural Models.”Psychological Bulletin 107: 238–246.
Bharadwaj, Sundar G., P. Rajan Varadarajan, and John Fahy. 1993. “Sustainable Competitive Advantage in Service Industries: A Conceptual Model and Research Propositions.”Journal of Marketing 57 (October): 83–99.
Blalock, Hubert M. 1961.Causal Inferences in Nonexperimental Research. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
Bollen, Kenneth A. 1989.Structural Equations With Latent Variables. New York: Free Press.
————— and Richard Lennox. 1991. “Conventional Wisdom on Measurement: A Structural Equation Perspective.”Psychological Bulletin 110 (2): 305–314.
Bonoma, Thomas. 1985.The Marketing Edge: Making Strategies Work. New York: Free Press.
————— and Bruce Clark. 1988.Marketing Performance Assessment. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
Bourgeois, L. J., III. 1980. “Strategy and Environment: A Conceptual Integration.”Academy of Management Review 5 (January): 25–39.
————— and Kathleen Eisenhardt. 1988. “Strategic Decision Processes in High-Velocity Environments: Four Cases in the Microcomputer Industry.”Management Science 14: 816–835.
Boyd, Brian K. 1991. “Strategic Planning and Financial Performance.”Journal of Management Studies 28 (July): 353–374.
Browne, M. W. and R. Cudeck. 1993. “Alternative Ways of Assessing Model Fit.” InTesting Structural Equation Models. Eds. K. A. Bollen and J. S. Long. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
Bucklin, Louis P. and Sanjit Sengupta. 1993. “Organizing Successful Co-Marketing Alliances.”Journal of Marketing 57 (April): 32–46.
Burns, T. and G. Stalker. 1961.The Management of Innovation. London: Tavistock.
Capon, Noel, John U. Farley, and James M. Hulbert. 1994. “Strategic Planning and Financial Performance: More Evidence.”Journal of Management Studies 31 (January): 105–110.
Cohen, Jacob. 1988.Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Corwin, Ronald. 1969. “Patterns of Organizational Conflict.”Administrative Science Quarterly 14 (December): 507–522.
Cosier, R. A. 1978. “The Effects of Three Potential Aids for Making Strategic Decisions on Predictions Accuracy.”Organizational Behavior and Human Performance 22: 295–306.
————— and D. Dalton. 1990. “Positive Effects of Conflict: A Field Assessment.”International Journal of Conflict Management 1: 81–92.
————— and Charles Schwenk. 1990. “Agreement and Thinking Alike: Ingredients for Poor Decisions.”Academy of Management Executive 4: 69–74.
Curren, Mary, Valerie Folkes, and Joel Steckel. 1992. “Explanations for Successful and Unsuccessful Marketing Decisions: The Decision Maker’s Perspective.”Journal of Marketing 56 (April): 18–31.
Day, George and Robin Wensley. 1983. “Marketing Theory With a Strategic Orientation.”Journal of Marketing 47 (Fall): 69–89.
Day, Ralph L., Ronald E. Michaels, and Barbara C. Perdue. 1988. “How Buyers Handle Conflicts.”Industrial Marketing Management 17 (May): 153–160.
Dearborn, D. C. and H. A. Simon. 1958. “Selective Perception: A Note on the Departmental Identification of Executives.”Sociometry 21: 140–144.
Deshpande, Rohit. 1982. “The Organizational Context of Market Research Use.”Journal of Marketing 46 (Fall): 91–101.
Dess, Gregory and R. Robinson. 1984. “Measuring Organizational Performance in the Absence of Objective Measures: The Case of the Privately-Held Firm and Conglomerate Business Unit.”Strategic Management Journal 5 (July–September): 265–273.
Dewar, Robert and James Werbel. 1979. “Universalistic and Contingency Predictions of Employee Satisfaction and Conflict.”Administrative Science Quarterly 24 (September): 426–448.
Dwyer, R. Robert, Paul H. Schurr, and Sejo Oh. 1987. “Developing Buyer-Seller Relations.”Journal of Marketing 51 (April): 11–28.
Dyson, R. G. and M. J. Foster. 1980. “Effectiveness in Strategic Planning.”European Journal of Operational Research 5: 163–170.
Eisenhardt, Kathleen and L. J. Bourgeois. 1988. “Politics of Strategic Decision Making in High-Velocity Environments: Towards a Mid-Range Theory.”Academy of Management Journal 31: 737–770.
————— and Mark Zbaracki. 1992. “Strategic Decision Making.”Strategic Management Journal 13 (Winter): 17–37.
Eliashberg, Jehoshua and Donald A. Michie. 1984. “Multiple Business Goal Sets as Determinants of Marketing Channel Conflict: An Empirical Study.”Journal of Marketing Research 21 (February): 75–88.
Fiol, Marlene C. 1994. “Consensus, Diversity, and Learning in Organizations.”Organization Science 5 (August): 403–420.
Frazier, Gary and Raymond Rody. 1991. “The Use of Influence Strategies in Interfirm Relationships in Industrial Product Channels.”Journal of Marketing 55 (January): 52–69.
Fredrickson, J. W. 1984. “The Comprehensiveness of Strategic Decision Processes: Extensions, Observations, Future Directions.”Academy of Management Journal 27: 445–466.
Ganesan, Shanker. 1994. “Determinants of Long-Term Orientation in Buyer-Seller Relationships.”Journal of Marketing 58 (April): 1–19.
Gaski, John F. 1984. “The Theory of Power and Conflict in Channels of Distribution.”Journal of Marketing 48 (Summer): 9–29.
————— and John R. Nevin. 1985. “The Differential Effects of Exercised and Unexercised Power Sources in a Marketing Channel.”Journal of Marketing Research 22 (May): 130–142.
Golden, Brian. 1992. “The Past Is the Past—Or Is It? The Use of Retrospective Accounts as Indicators of Past.”Academy of Management Journal 35 (4): 848–861.
Govindarajan, Vijay. 1986. “Decentralization, Strategy, and the Effectiveness of Strategic Business Units in Multi-Business Organizations.”Academy of Management Review 11 (October): 844–856.
Guth, William and Ian C. Macmillan. 1986. “Strategy Implementation Versus Middle Management Self-Interest.”Strategic Management Journal 7 (July–August): 313–327.
Hage, Jerald and Michael Aiken. 1967. “Relationship of Centralization to Other Structural Properties.”Administrative Science Quarterly 12 (June): 72–92.
Hart, S. and C. Banbury. 1994. “How Strategy-Making Process Can Make a Difference.”Strategy Management Journal 15 (May): 251–270.
Hickson, David J., C. R. Hinings, C. A. Lee, R. E. Schneck, and J. M. Pennings. 1971. “A Strategic Contingencies Theory of Intraorganizational Power.”Administrative Science Quarterly 16: 216–229.
Hise, Richard, Larry O’Neal, A. Parasuraman, and James McNeil. 1990. “Marketing/R&D Interaction in New Product Development: Implications for New Product Success Rates.”Journal of Product and Innovation Management 7 (June): 142–155.
Huber, G. P. and R. Power. 1985. “Retrospective Reports of Strategic-Level Managers: Guidelines for Increasing Their Accuracy.”Strategic Management Journal 6 (April–June): 171–180.
Hunt, Shelby and Jack Nevin. 1974. “Power in a Channel of Distribution: Sources and Consequences.”Journal of Marketing Research 11 (May): 186–193.
Isen, A. M. and R. A. Baron. 1991. “Positive Affect as a Factor in Organizational Behavior.” InResearch in Organizational Behavior. Eds. B. M. Staw and L. L. Cummings. Greewich, CT: JAI.
Jaworski, Bernard J. and Ajay K. Kohli. 1993. “Market Orientation: Antecedents and Consequences.”Journal of Marketing 57 (July): 53–70.
————— and Deborah H. MacInnis. 1989. “Marketing Jobs and Management Controls: Toward a Framework.”Journal of Marketing Research 4 (November): 406–419.
John, George and John Martin. 1984. “Effects of Organizational Structure of Marketing Planning on Credibility and Utilization of Plan Output.”Journal of Marketing Research 21 (May): 170–183.
————— and Torger Reve. 1982. “Reliability and Validity of Key Informant Data From Dyadic Relationships in Marketing Channels.”Journal of Marketing Research 19 (November): 517–524.
Joreskog, Karl and Dag Sorbom. 1993.LISREL 8. Chicago: Scientific Software Inc.
Kohli, Ajay K. and Bernard J. Jaworski. 1990. “Market Orientation: The Construct, Research Propositions, and Managerial Implications.”Journal of Marketing 54 (April): 1–18.
Kumar, Nirmalya, Louis W. Stern, and James C. Anderson. 1993. “Conducting Interorganizational Research Using Key Informants.”Academy of Management Journal 36 (December): 1633–1651.
Lawrence, L. and J. Lorsch. 1967.Organization and Environment. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
Lewicki, Roy, Stephen Weiss, and David Lewin. 1992. “Models of Conflict, Negotiation and Third Party Intervention: A Review and Synthesis.”Journal of Organizational Behavior 13: 209–252.
Lusch, Robert F. 1976. “Channel Conflict: Its Impact on Retailer Operating Performance.”Journal of Retailing 52 (Summer): 3–12.
Lyles, Marjorie A. and R. T. Lenz. 1982. “Managing the Planning Process: A Field Study of the Human Side of Planning.”Strategic Management Journal 3 (January–February): 105–118.
McAllister, Daniel J. 1995. “Affect- and Cognition-Based Trust as Foundations for Interpersonal Cooperation in Organizations.”Academy of Management Journal 38 (February): 24–59.
Menon, Anil and P. Rajan Varadarajan. 1992. “A Model of Marketing Knowledge Use Within Firms.”Journal of Marketing 56 (October): 53–71.
Michaels, Ronald, William Cron, Alan Dubinsky, and Erich Joachimsthaler. 1988. “The Influence of Formalization on the Organizational Commitment and Work Alienation of Salespeople and Industrial Buyers.”Journal of Marketing Research 4 (November): 376–383.
Morgan, Robert M. and Shelby D. Hunt. 1994. “The Commitment-Trust Theory of Relationship Marketing.”Journal of Marketing 58 (July): 20–38.
Morrison, Donald. 1976.Multivariate Statistics. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Naman, J. L. and D. P. Slevin. 1993. “Entrepreneurship and the Concept of Fit: A Model and Empirical Tests.”Strategic Management Journal 14 (February): 137–154.
Narver, John and Stanley Slater. 1990. “The Effect of Market Orientation on Business Profitability.”Journal of Marketing 54 (October): 20–35.
Nelson, Reed. 1989. “The Strength of Strong Ties: Social Networks and Intergroup Conflict in Organizations.”Academy of Management Journal 32 (June): 377–401.
Pascale, Richard. 1990. “The Renewal Factor: Constructive Contention.”Planning Review (July–August): 47–48.
Peterson, Robert. 1975. “An Experimental Investigation of Mail Survey Responses.”Journal of Business Research (July): 199–210.
Pfeffer, Jeffrey. 1981.Power and Organizations. Marshfield, MA: Pittman.
Pfeffer, Jeffrey and Gerald R. Salancik. 1978.The External Control of Organizations. New York: Harper & Row.
Phillips, Lynn W. 1981. “Assessing Measurement Error in Key Informant Reports: A Methodological Note on Organizational Analysis in Marketing.”Journal of Marketing Research 17 (November): 395–415.
Piercy, Nigel I. 1987. “The Marketing Budgeting Process: Marketing Management Implications.”Journal of Marketing 51 (October): 45–59.
————— 1989a. “Information Control and the Power and Politics of Marketing.”Journal of Business Research 18: 229–243.
————— 1989b. “The Power and Politics of Sales Forecasting: Uncertainty Absorption and the Power of the Marketing Department.”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 17 (2): 109–120.
————— 1995. “Customer Satisfaction and the Internal Market: Marketing Our Customer to Our Employees.”Journal of Marketing Practice 1 (1): 22–44.
————— and Neil A. Morgan. 1994. “The Marketing Planning Process: Behavioral Problems Compared to Analytical Techniques in Explaining Marketing Plan Credibility.”Journal of Business Research 29: 167–178.
Podsakoff, Philip M. and Dennis W. Organ. 1986. “Self-reports in Organizational Research: Problems and Prospects.”Journal of Management 12 (December): 531–544.
Pondy, Louis R. 1967. “Organizational Conflict: Concepts and Models.”Administrative Science Quarterly 12 (September): 296–320.
————— 1992. “Reflections on Organizational Conflict.”Journal of Organizational Behavior 13: 257–261.
Powell, Thomas C. 1992. “Organizational Alignment as Competitive Advantage.”Strategic Management Journal 13 (February): 119–134.
Pugh, Derek, David Hickson, C. Hinnings, and C. Turner. 1968. “Dimensions of Organizational Structure.”Administrative Science Quarterly 13 (June): 65–105.
Purdue, Barbara C. and John O. Summers. 1991. “Purchasing Agents’ Use of Negotiation Strategies.”Journal of Marketing Research 28 (May): 175–189.
Ramanujam, V., N. Venkatraman, and J. C. Camillus. 1986. “Multi-Objective Assessment of Effectiveness of Strategic Planning: A Discriminant Analysis Approach.”Academy of Management Journal 29: 347–372.
Rosenberg, Larry J. and Louis W. Stern. 1970. “Towards the Analysis of Conflict in Distribution Channels: A Descriptive Model.”Journal of Marketing 34 (October): 40–46.
Rosenbloom, Bert. 1973. “Conflict and Channel Efficiency: Some Conceptual Model for the Decision Maker.”Journal of Marketing 37 (July): 26–30.
Ruekert, Robert W. and Orville C. Walker, Jr. 1987a. “Interactions Between Marketing and R&D Departments in Implementing Different Business Strategies.”Strategic Management Journal 8 (May–June): 233–248.
————— 1987b. “Marketing’s Interaction With Other Functional Units: A Conceptual Framework and Empirical Evidence.”Journal of Marketing 51 (January): 1–19.
Schwenk, Charles. 1989. “A Meta-Analysis on the Comparative Effectiveness of Devil’s Advocacy and Dialectical Inquiry.”Strategic Management Journal 10 (May–June): 303–306.
—————. 1990. “Conflict in Organizational Decision Making: An Exploratory Study of Its Effects in For-Profit and Not-For-Profit Organizations.”Management Science 36 (April): 436–448.
Seidler, John. 1974. “On Using Informants: A Technique for Collecting Quantitative Data and Controlling for Measurement Error in Organizational Analysis.”American Sociological Review 39 (November): 816–831.
Sheth, Jagdish. 1973. “A Model of Industrial Buyer Behavior.”Journal of Marketing 37 (October): 50–56.
Smith, Ken G., Stephen J. Carroll, and Susan J. Ashford. 1995. “Intra- and Interorganizational Cooperation: Toward a Research Agenda.”Academy of Management Journal 38 (February): 7–23.
Stern, Louis W. and Adel I. El-Ansary. 1977.Marketing Channels. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
————— and Ronald H. Gorman. 1969. “Conflict in Distribution Channels: An Exploration.” InDistribution Channels. Ed. Louis Stern. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Strauss, George. 1962. “Tactics of Lateral Relationships: The Purchasing Agent.”Administrative Science Quarterly 7 (September): 161–186.
Tan, Justin J. and R. J. Litschert. 1994. “Environment-Strategy Relationship and Its Performance Implications: An Empirical Study of the Chinese Electronics Industry.”Strategic Management Journal 15 (January): 1–20.
Thomas, Kenneth. 1990. “Conflict and Negotiation Processes in Organizations.” InHandbook of Industrial and Organizational Psychology. Ed. M. D. Dunnette. Palo Alto, CA: Consulting Psychological Press.
————— and W. H. Schmidt. 1976. “A Survey of Managerial Interests With Respect to Conflict.”Academy of Management Journal 19 (December): 315–318.
—————, Richard Walton, and John Dutton. 1972. “Determinants of Interdepartmental Conflict.” InInter-Organizational Decision Making. Eds. M. Tuite, R. Chisholm, and M. Radnor. Chicago: Aldine, 45–69.
Tjosvold, D. 1982. “Effects of Approach to Controversy on Superiors’ Incorporation of Subordinates’ Information in Decision Making.”Journal of Applied Psychology 67: 189–193.
————— 1985. “Implications of Controversy Research for Management.”Journal of Management 11 (Fall–Winter): 21–37.
—————, D. Johnson, and J. Lerner. 1981. “The Effects of Affirmation and Acceptance on Incorporation of an Opposing Opinion in Problem Solving.”Journal of Social Psychology 114: 103–110.
Tootelian, Dennis H. and Ralph M. Gaedeke. 1987. “Fortune 500 List Revised 12 Years Later: Still an Endangered Species for Academic Research?”Journal of Business Research 15 (August): 359–363.
Venkatraman, N. and V. Ramanujam. 1986. “Measurement of Business Performance in Strategy Research: A Comparison of Approaches.”Academy of Management Review 11 (October): 801–814.
Wall, James A. and Ronda Roberts Callister. 1995. “Conflict and Its Management.”Journal of Management 21 (3): 515–558.
Walsh, James P. 1988. “Selectivity and Selective Perception: An Investigation of Managers’ Belief Structures and Information Processing.”Academy of Management Journal 31 (December): 873–896.
Walton, Richard and John Dutton. 1969. “The Management of Interdepartmental Conflict: A Model and Review.”Administrative Science Quarterly 14 (December): 73–84.
—————, —————, and Thomas Cafferty. 1969. “Organizational Context and Interdepartmental Conflict.”Administrative Science Quarterly 14 (December): 522–542.
—————, —————, and H. Fitch. 1966. “A Study of Conflict in the Process, Structure and Attitudes of Lateral Relationships.” InSome Theories of Organization. Eds. Albert Rubenstein and Chadwick Haberstroh. Homewood, IL: Irwin, 444–465.
Webster, Fredrick E. and Yoram Wind. 1972. “A General Model for Understanding Organizational Buying Behavior.”Journal of Marketing 36 (April): 12–19.
Whitney, John C. and Ruth A. Smith. 1983. “Effects of Group Cohesiveness on Attitude Polarization and the Acquisition of Knowledge in a Strategic Planning Context.”Journal of Marketing Research 20 (May): 167–176.
Wiseman, Fredrick and Maryann Bilington. 1984. “Comment on a Standard Definition of Response Rates.”Journal of Marketing Research 3 (August): 336–338.
Young, Louise and Ian Wilkinson. 1989. “The Role of Trust and Cooperation in Marketing Channels: A Preliminary Study.”European Journal of Marketing 23 (2): 109–122.
Zahra, S. A. and J. G. Covin. 1993. “Business Strategy, Technology Policy and Firm Performance.”Strategic Management Journal 14 (September): 451–478.
Zaltman, Gerald, Robert Duncan, and Jonny Holbek. 1973.Innovations and Organizations. New York: John Wiley.
Zeithaml, Valerie A., Leonard L. Berry, and A. Parasuraman. 1988. “Communication and Control Processes in the Delivery of Service Quality.”Journal of Marketing 52 (April): 35–48.
Zillmann, D. 1988. “Cognition-Excitation Interdependencies and Aggressive Behavior.”Aggressive Behavior 14: 51–64.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
His general research interests focus on strategic issues relating to internal relationships, market learning, and organizational context of marketing strategy. His research has been published in theJournal of Marketing, Journal of Business Research, Journal of Advertising Research, Journal of Advertising, andJournal of Services Marketing, among others.
His general research interests focus on strategic issues relating to relationship marketing, firm performance, sustainable competitive advantage, timing of market entry, and information technology. His past research has been published in theJournal of Marketing, Journal of Business Research, Journal of Services Marketing, andMarketing Education Review, among others.
His research interests are in the areas of marketing research methods, structural equations modeling, cellular automata theories and methods, and Taoist methodologies for marketing strategy. His research has been published in theJournal of Marketing, Journal of Marketing Research, andJournal of the Academy of Marketing Science, among others.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Menon, A., Bharadwaj, S.G. & Howell, R. The quality and effectiveness of marketing strategy: Effects of functional and dysfunctional conflict in intraorganizational relationships. JAMS 24, 299–313 (1996). https://doi.org/10.1177/0092070396244002
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0092070396244002