Title: The four ages of early prestressed concrete structures
Date: Fall 2014
Volume: 59
Issue: 4
Page number: 93-121
Author(s): Marc Sanabra-Loewe, Joaquin Capellà-Llovera
https://doi.org/10.15554/pcij.09012014.93.121
Click here to access the full journal article
Abstract
Unlike that of reinforced concrete, the history of prestressed concrete has been insufficiently studied. Little progress has been made since the first classical texts appeared in England, the United States, and Germany soon after the Second World War, and after the publicaiton of the classical biography of Fressinet following Spain's return to democracy. Some evidence of this gap is that some well reputed textbooks on prestressed concrete, as well as recent and updated papers, still repeat the old erroneous chronologies. However, in recent decades some researchers have been making interesting and noteworthy advances in the history of prestressed concrete. Some of these advances are discussed here, along with new data from the study of early patents on prestressed structures, and these resources are looked at from a new historical perspective: the four ages of prestressed concrete structures. Beyond application to concrete structures, this “four ages” perspective can also be useful for studying the history of prestressed structures made of other materials.
References
1. Guyon, Yves, and Eugène Freyssinet. 1965. Hormigón Pretensado: Estudio Teorético y Experimental. Translated by Manuel Osset and Renato Bardin. Madrid, Spain: Dossat. Originally published as Béton Précontraint. Étude Théorique et Expérimentale (Paris: Editions Eryolles, 1951).
2. Bažant, Zden k P., Mija H. Hubler, and Qiang Yu. 2011. “Pervasiveness of Excessive Segmental Bridge Deflections: Wake-Up Call for Creep.” Structural Journal 108 (6): 766–774.
3. Fernández Ordóñez, José A. 1978. Eugène Freyssinet. Barcelona, Spain: Xarait.
4. Dobell, Curzon. 1950. “Patents and Codes Relating to Prestressed Concrete.” Journal of the American Concrete Institute 46 (5): 713–722.
5. Billig, Kurt. 1952. Prestressed Concrete. London, UK: Macmillan.
6. Ritter, Max, and Pierre Lardy. 1946. Vorgespannter Beton. Zurich, Switzerland: Leeman.
7. Leonhardt, Fritz. 1967. Hormigón Pretensado. Translated by Alberto Corral, Juan Batanero. Madrid: Instituto Eduardo Torroja de la Construcción y el Cemento. Originally published as Spannbeton für die Praxis, 2nd ed. (München: Wilhelm Ernst & Sohn, 1962.
8. Griggs, Francis E. Jr., and A. J. DeLuzio. 1995. “Stephen H. Long and Squire Whipple: The First American Structural Engineers.” Journal of Structural Engineering 121 (9): 1352–1361.
9. Gasparini, Dario, and David Simmons. 1997. “American Truss Bridge Connections in the 19th Century. I:1829–1850.” Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities 11 (3): 119–129.
10. Long, Stephen H. Truss bridge. US Patent X5862, issued March 6, 1830.
11. Finsterwalder, Ulrich. Truss girder and method of producing the same. US Patent 2151267, filed June 10, 1937, and issued March 21, 1939.
12. Bailey, Michael R. 2003.Robert Stephenson: The Eminent Engineer. Farnham, UK: Ashgate.
13. Sutherland, James. 2009. “The Birth of Prestressing? Iron Bridges for Railways 1830 to 1850.” International Journal for the History of Engineering and Technology 79 (1): 113–130.
14. Her Majesty’s Stationery Office. 1849. Report of the Commissioners Appointed to Inquire into the Application of Iron to Railway Structures. London, UK: Her Majesty’s Stationery Office.
15. Whipple, Squire. Bridge. US Patent 2064, issued April 24, 1841.
16. Griggs, Francis E. Jr. 2002. “Squire Whipple—Father of Iron Bridges.” Journal of Bridge Engineering 7 (3): 146–155.
17. 1908. New York Times. http://newspaperarchive.com. June 18, p. 14.
18. Wermiel, Sara E. 2009. “California Concrete, 1876– 1906: Jackson, Percy, and the Beginnings of Reinforced Concrete Construction in the United States.” In Proceedings of the Third International Congress on Construction History. Cottbus, Germany: Brandenburg University of Technology.
19. Simonnet, Cyrille. 2005. Le Béton: Histoire d’un Matériau: Économie, Technique, Architecture. Marseille, France: Parenthèses.
20. Jackson, Peter H. Construction of metallic side pavements. US Patent 21834, filed February 2, 1858, and issued October 19, 1858.
21. Nawy, Edward G. 2009. Prestressed Concrete: A Fundamental Approach. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson.
22. Jackson, Peter H. Improvement in girders. US Patent 126396, issued May 7, 1872.
23. Jackson, Peter H. Arched girder. US Patent 265321, filed April 11, 1882, and issued October 3, 1882.
24. Jackson, Peter H. Building or bridge construction. US Patent 366839, filed January 7, 1886, and issued July 19, 1887.
25. Jackson, Peter H. Construction of artificial-stone or concrete pavements. US Patent 375999, filed October 27, 1886, and issued January 3, 1888.
26. Billington, David P. 2004. “Historical Perspective on Prestressed Concrete.” PCI Journal 49 (1):14–30.
27. Lee, Thomas A. Artificial fire-proof joist for floors or roofs. US Patent 461028, filed December 20, 1890, and issued October 13, 1891.
28. Lee, Thomas A. Tension-rod. US Patent 513794, filed April 30, 1892, and issued January 30, 1894.
29. Vander Heyden, Bernard A. Cementitious plank and method of constructing it. US Patent 2696729, filed June 19, 1944, and issued December 14, 1954.
30. Dolhon, Anthony M. 2008. “Performance Evaluation of Dox Plank.” In AEI 2008: Building Integration Solutions. Denver, CO: ASCE Publications.
31. Doehring, C. F. Einrichtung zur Herstellung von mit Draht durchzogenen, zu dem unter No. 49024 patenretirten Abschluss für Balkenlangen zu verwendenden Latten. Prussian Patent 53548, filed October 23, 1888, and issued October 2, 1890.
32. Zilch, K., and H. Weiher. 2008. “120 Jahre Spannbetonbau—von Doehring und Jackson bis heute.” Beton- und Stahlbetonbau 103 (6): 422–430.
33. Doehring, C. F. Feuersichrer und wasserdichter Abschluss für Stockwerksbalkenlagen. Prussian Patent 49024, filed June 3, 1888, and issued October 15, 1889.
34. Iori, Tullia. 2003. “Prestressed Concrete: First Developments in Italy.” In Proceedings of the First International Congress on Construction History, 1167–1176. Madrid, Spain: Reverte.
35. Chaudy, François. 1894. “Sur le Calcul des Plaques Élastiques Minces et le Rôle de Tirants Dans les Poutres en Ciment Armées.” In Mémoires et Compte Rendus des Travaux de la Société de Ingénieurs Civils de France, 2ème Semestre, 545–550. Paris, France: Société des Ingénieurs Civils de France.
36. Mandl, Julius. 1896. “Zur Theorie der Cementeisen- Constructionen.” Zeitschrift des Österreichischen Ingenieur- und Architekten-Vereines XLVIII (45): 593–596.
37. Mandl, Julius. 1896. “Zur Theorie der Cementeisen- Constructionen.” Zeitschrift des Österreichischen Ingenieur- und Architekten-Vereines XLVIII (45): 593–596 and XLVIII (46): 605–609.
38. Lund, Jens Gabriel. Straight vault. US Patent 1028578, filed February 10, 1908, and issued June 4, 1912. 39. Wilson, Walter. Improvements relating to reinforced concrete blocks, slabs and beams and the like. UK Patent 103681, filed January 31, 1916, and issued January 31, 1917.
40. Bolton, Frederick. Improvements in the manufacture of reinforced concrete structures. UK Patent 123100, filed March 28, 1918, and issued April 28, 1919.
41. Mezzetti, Ernesto. Innovazione nei sistemi di armatura del cemento. Italian Patent 166844, filed May 20, 1918, and issued September 5, 1918.
42. Wettstein, Karl. Verfahren zur Herstellung von Dielen, Schwellen, Brettern, Latten, Reigeln u. dgl. Aus Zement. Austrian Patent 95934, filed November 30, 1921, and issued September 15, 1923.
43. Hoyer, Ewald. Procedé pour faire du béton armé. French Patent 837141, filed November 3, 1938 (with German priority of April 28, 1937), and issued February 2, 1939.
44. Dischinger, Franz. Système porteur, en particulier pour ponts à poutres. French Patent 798928, filed December 7, 1935, and issued March 14, 1936.
45. Finsterwalder, Ulrich. Ferro-concrete beam.US Patent 2155121, filed June10, 1937, and issued April 18, 1939.
46. Xercavins, Pierre, David Demarthe, and Ken Shushkewich. 2010. “Eugène Freyssinet - His Incredible Journey to Invent and Revolutionize Prestressed Concrete Construction.” In Proceedings of the Third fib International Congress. Washington DC: Curran Associates Inc.
47. Considère, Armand. 1899. “Variations de Volume de Mortiers de Ciment de Portland, Résultant de la Prise et l’etat Hygrometrique.” Comptes Rendus des Séances de l’Académie des Sciences 129 (July–December): 467–472.
48. Koenen, Mathias. 1907. “Wie Kann die Anwendung des Eisenbetons in der Eisenbahnverwaltung Wesentlich Gefördert Werden?” Zentralblatt der Bauverwaltung XXVII 79): 520–522.
49. Koenen, Mathias. Verfahren zur Erzeugung einer Anfangsdruckspannung in der Zugzone von Eisenbetonbalken oder–platten. German Patent 249007, filed January 18, 1912, and issued July 9, 1912.
50. Steiner, Charles R. Reinforced concrete construction. US Patent 903909, filed February 10, 1908, and issued November 17, 1908.
51. Woolson, Ira H. 1905. “Some Remarkable Tests Indicating ‘Flow’ of Concrete under Pressure.” Engineering News 18 (54):459.
52. Hatt, W. K. 1907. “A Note on the Effect of Time Element in Loading Reinforced Concrete Beams.” Engineering News 58(17): 438–439.
53. McMillan, Franklin R. 1915. Shrinkage and Time Effects in Reinforced Concrete. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota.
54. Smith, E. B. 1916. “Concrete Flows under Sustained Load.” Engineering Record 73(10): 329–330.
55. Espion, Bernard. 2012. “L’Invention du Béton Précontraint par Eugène Freyssinet et Premières Applications de Ses Brevets.” http://difusion.ulb.ac.be/vufind/reAucord/ulb-dipot:oai:dipot.ulb.ec.be:2013/115846/holdings. Paper presented at Connaissez-vous les Bétons Armés et Précontraints? Université Libre de Bruxelles, Moulins de Beez, Belguim.
56. Grote, Jupp, and Bernard Marrey. 2000. Freyssinet, la Précontrainte et l’Europe. Der Spannbeton und Europa. Prestressing and Europe. 1930–1945. Paris, France: Éditions du Linteau.
57. Lévy, Maurice. 1907. “Circulaire du 20 Octobre 1906, Concernant les Instructions Relatives à l’Emploi du Béton Armé.” La Houille Blanche (7): 148–152.
58. Balcom, Thomas W. 1984. “A Tale of Two Towers. Washburn Park and Its Water Supply.” Minnesota History 49 (Spring): 19–28.
59. Faber, Oscar. 1927. “Plastic Yield, Shrinkage and Other Problems of Concrete and Their Effect on Design.” In Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers, 27–73. London, UK: Institution of Civil Engineers.
60. Freyssinet, Eugène. 1930. “Études sur les Déformations Lentes des Ciments ou Retraits.” In Premier Congrès International du Béton et du Béton Armé, 520–532. Liège, Belgium: La Technique des Travaux
61. Freyssinet, Eugène. 1966. “Relations Entre les Deformations et la Constitution des Ciments et des Matériaux de Structure Colloïdale (Résultats de Recherché Faites par Eugène Freyssinet entre 1926 et 1929).” Travaux 376 (Numéro spécial – Un demi-sciècle de technique française de la précontrainte – Tome II): 921–936.
62. Glanville, W. H. 1930. Studies in Reinforced Concrete III: The Creep or Flow of Concrete under Load. Building research technical paper n. 12. London: UK: Her Majesty’s Stationery Office.
63. Dischinger, Franz. 1937. “Untersuchungen über die Knicksicherheit, die Elastische Verformung und das Kriechen des Betons bei Bogenbrücken.” Der Bauingenieur 18 (33/34): 487–520.
64. Dischinger, Franz. 1937. “Untersuchungen über die Knicksicherheit, die Elastische Verformung und das Kriechen des Betons bei Bogenbrücken.” Der Bauingenieur 18 (35/36): 539–552.
65. Dischinger, Franz. 1937. “Untersuchungen über die Knicksicherheit, die Elastische Verformung und das Kriechen des Betons bei Bogenbrücken.” Der Bauingenieur 18 (39/40): 595–621.
66. Dischinger, Franz. 1939. “Elastische und PlastischeVerformungen bei Eisenbetontragwerke.” Der Bauingenieur 20 (5/6): 53–63.
67. Dischinger, Franz. 1939. “Elastische und Plastische Verformungen bei Eisenbetontragwerke.” Der Bauingenieur 20 (21/22): 286–294.
68. Dischinger, Franz. 1939. “Elastische und Plastische Verformungen bei Eisenbetontragwerke.” Der Bauingenieur 20 (31/32): 426–437.
69. Dischinger, Franz. 1939. “Elastische und Plastische Verformungen bei Eisenbetontragwerke.” Der Bauingenieur 20 (47/48): 563–572.
70. Melan, Joseph. Vault for ceilings, bridges, etc. US Patent 505054, filed May 17, 1893, and issued September 12, 1893.
71. Hewett, William S. Reinforced concrete structure. US Patent 1413404, filed March 5, 1921, and issued April 18, 1922.
72. Dill, Richard E. Manufacture of reinforced concrete. US Patent 1684663, filed February 7, 1925, and issued September 18, 1928.
73. Färber, Richard. Verfahren zur Herstellung von Verbundträgern aus Eisenbeton. German Patent 557331, filed May 29, 1927, and issued August 22, 1932.
74. Hewett, William S. Method and means for tying concrete. US Patent 1818254, filed September 10, 1927, and issued August 11, 1931.
75. Hewett, William S. Building structure reinforcement. US Patent 2091444, filed December 9, 1935, and issued August 31, 1937.
76. Freyssinet, Eugène. 1928. “L’Amélioration des Constructions en Béton Armé par L’Introduction de Déformations Élastiques Systématiques.” Génie Civil 11 (93): 254–257.
77. Freyssinet, Eugène, and Jean Seailles. Procédé de fabrication de pièces en béton armé. French Patent 680547, filed October 2, 1928, and issued May 1, 1930.
78. Freyssinet, Eugène. 1933. “Idées et Voies Nouvelles.” Science et Industrie 1 (1): 3–17.
79. Freyssinet, Eugène. 1936. Une Revolution dans la Technique du Béton. Paris, France: Eyrolles.
80. Freyssinet, Eugène. Système d’ancrage de câbles sous tension destines à la réalisation de constructions en béton précontraint. French Patent 926505, filed August 26, 1939, and issued October 3, 1947.
81. Gueritte, Alfred T. Improvements in or relating to the Construction of Prestressed Concrete. UK Patent 541437, filed August 13, 1940, and issued November 26, 1941.
82. Kirkwood, Archibald, and The Prestressed Concrete Company. Improvements in or relating to the stretching and anchorage of cables or bundles of hard steel wires for prestressed reinforced concrete. K Patent 541160, filed August 27, 1940, and issued November 14, 1941.
83. Freyssinet, Eugène. Improvements in processes and devices for anchoring wires reinforcing pre-stressed concrete structures. UK Patent 591218, filed February 21, 1941, and issued August 12, 1947.
84. Freyssinet, Eugène. Dispositif de mise en tension et d’ancrage de cables convenant en particulier à la réalisation de constructions en béton précontraint. French Patent 870070, filed October 28, 1940, and issued 2, March, 1942.
85. Freyssinet, Eugène. Dispositif de vérin et ses applications. French Patent 859903, filed June 3, 1939, and issued January 2, 1941.
86. Emperger, Fritz. Reinforced concrete. US Patent 2255022, filed February 3, 1940 (with German priority of January 23, 1939), and issued September 2, 1941.
87. Magnel, Gustav. 1945. “Le Fluage des Aciers et son Importance en Béton Précontraint.” Science et Technique 1945 (2): 4–8.
88. Magnel, Gustav. 1944. “Le Flambage en Béton Précontraint.” Science et Technique 1944 (10): 1–4.
89. Schorer, Herman. Mode de construction en béton, dans lequel les pieces soumises en fonctionnement normal à des efforts de traction et de cisaillement, reçoivent une tension initiale, et dispositif pour cette mise en tension. French Patent 870671, filed February 20, 1941, and issued March 20, 1942].
90. Lesage, Gilbert. Procédé de mise en tension d’armatures pour béton précontraint, et dispositif pour se mise en oeuvre. French Patent 954204, filed October 13, 1947, and issued December 21, 1949.