Protesters’ Reactions to Video Surveillance of Demonstrations: Counter-Moves, Security Cultures, and the Spiral of Surveillance and Counter-Surveillance
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
This article analyses protesters’ reactions to police video surveillance of demonstrations in Germany. Theoretically, we draw on the concept of a “spiral of surveillance and counter-surveillance” to understand the interaction processes which—intentionally or not—contribute to the deepening of the “surveillant assemblage” in the field of protest policing. After introducing video surveillance and its importance for selective protest policing, we discuss concepts of counter-surveillance. Widening the individualist scope of former research on “neutralisation techniques,” collective and interactive dimensions are added to cover the full counter-surveillance repertoire. We identified six basic categories of counter-surveillance moves: consider cameras, disguise, attack, hide, sousveillance, and cooperation. They can be classified along the axes of (a) degree of cooperation with the police, and (b) directedness (inwards/outward). It becomes obvious that activists are not predominantly deterred by video surveillance but adapt to the situation. If and how certain counter-surveillance moves are applied depends on the degree of exposure, perceptions of conflict dynamics, political interpretations, and on how these factors are processed in the respective security cultures. Security cultures, which are grounded in the respective relations between protest groups and police, are collective sets of practices and interpretive patterns aimed at securing safety and/or anonymity of activists as well as making their claims visible. Thus, they are productive power effects, resulting from the very conditions under which protest takes place in contemporary surveillance societies. This article elaborates on these ambiguities and unintended effects with regard to sousveillance and disguise techniques, such as masking or uniform clothing. The analysis is based on qualitative data collected between 2011 and 2016 consisting of group discussions and interviews with activists from different political spectra, journalists, politicians, and police officers, as well as observations of demonstrations and document analyses of movement literature.
Article Details
Surveillance & Society uses a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 4.0 License.
- The author. The author licenses the article to the Surveillance Studies Network (SSN) for inclusion in Surveillance & Society (S&S), right of first publication. The copyright to the article remains with the author and any subsequent commercial reuse must be agreed by both parties.
- Non-commercial Users. SSN authorises all persons to use material published in S&S in any manner that is not primarily intended for or directed to commerical advantage or private monetary compensation, also provided that it is not modified and retains all attribution notices.
- Commercial Users. SSN retains the right to benefit from commerical reuse, in each specific case subject to the agreement of the author, and payment to SSN of a standard per-page fee (set by a vote of the Network and Editorial Board) by the Commercial User.
- Surveillance & Society supports open access archives and the free distribution of the results of academic work. Authors are encouraged to place copies of the final published version of their article in their university and / or other open access archives. We only ask that you make sure to include a link to the original published version on the Surveillance & Society website.
References
Aden, Hartmut, ed. 2015. Police Cooperation in the European Union under the Treaty of Lisbon: Opportunities and Limitations. Baden-Baden: Nomos.
Allan, Stuart, and Einar Thorsen, eds. 2009. Citizen Journalism. Global Perspectives. New York: Peter Lang.
Andén-Papadopoulos, Kari. 2014. Citizen Camera-Witnessing: Embodied Political Dissent in the Age of “Mediated Mass Self- Communication.” New Media & Society 16 (5): 753–69.
Andrejevic, Mark. 2005. The Work of Watching One Another: Lateral Surveillance, Risk, and Governance. Surveillance 2 (4): 479–97.
Backes, Otto, Rainer Dollase, and Wilhelm Heitmeyer. 1998. Wie groß ist die Fremdenfeindlichkeit in der Polizei? Eine Analyse zu Risikokonstellationen im Polizeialltag, ed Institut für interdisziplinäre Konflikt-und Gewaltforschung. IKG Newsletter 9 (1): 4–11.
Bartlau, Christian. 2015. Offen, transparent, verfassungswidrig. Die Zeit, July 6. http://www.zeit.de/politik/deutschland/2015-07/polizei-twitter-verstoss-gegen-recht/komplettansicht.
Bauman, Zygmunt, and David Lyon. 2013. Liquid Surveillance: A Conversation. Hoboken: Wiley.
Baumgarten, Britta, and Peter Ullrich. 2016. Discourse, Power, and Governmentality: Social Movement Research with and beyond Foucault. In Social Theory and Social Movements: Mutual Inspirations, eds Jochen Roose and Hella Dietz, 13– 38. Wiesbaden: Springer Fachmedien.
Becker, Howard S. 1967. Whose Side Are We On? Social Problems 14 (3): 239–47.
Berthel, Ralph, ed. 2016. Polizei im digitalen Zeitalter. Teil III. Rothenburg/Oberlausitz: Hochschule der Sächsischen Polizei (FH).
Bigo, Didier. 2006. Globalized (In)Security: The Field and the Ban-Opticon. In Translation, Biopolitics, Colonial Difference, eds Naoki Sakai and Jon Solomon, 109–55. Hong Kong: Hong Kong University Press.
Boyne, Roy. 2000. Post-Panopticism. Economy and Society 29 (2): 285–307.
Brackel, Benjamin von. 2012. Bitte recht freundlich. Der Freitag, June 6. 7
Brighenti, Andrea Mubi. 2009. Artveillance: At the Crossroads of Art and Surveillance. Surveillance & Society 7 (2): 175–86.
Bröckling, Ulrich, Susanne Krasmann, and Thomas Lemke, eds. 2000. Gouvernementalität Der Gegenwart. Studien Zur Ökonomisierung Des Sozialen. Frankfurt/Main: Suhrkamp.
Brusten, Manfred. 1971. Determinanten selektiver Sanktionierung durch die Polizei. In Die Polizei. Soziologische Studien und Forschungsberichte, eds Johannes Feest and Rüdiger Lautmann, 31–70. Opladen: Westdeutscher Verlag.
Cammaerts, Bart, Alice Mattoni, and Patrick McCurdy, eds. 2013. Mediation and Protest Movements. Bristol, UK: Intellect.
Council of the European Union. 2007. Council Recommendation Concerning a Handbook for Police and Security Authorities Concerning Cooperation at Major Events with an International Dimension. Brüssel. [Accessed July 20, 2017]. http://www.statewatch.org/news/2009/dec/eu-troublemakers-handbook-2007.pdf.
Daphi, Priska, Anja Lê, and Peter Ullrich. 2013. Images of Surveillance: The Contested and Embedded Visual Language of Anti- Surveillance Protests. In Advances in the Visual Analysis of Social Movements, eds Nicole Doerr, Alice Mattoni, and Simon Teune, 35:55–80. Bingley, UK: Emerald.
Death, Carl. 2010. Counter-Conducts: A Foucauldian Analytics of Protest. Social Movement Studies: Journal of Social, Cultural and Political Protest 9 (3): 235–51.
Deleuze, Gilles, and Félix Guattari. 1987. A Thousand Plateaus: Capitalism and Schizophrenia. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
della Porta, Donatella, and Herbert Reiter. 1998. Introduction: The Policing of Protest in Western Democracies. In Policing Protest. The Control of Mass Demonstrations in Western Democracies, eds Donatella della Porta and Herbert Reiter, 1– 32. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
della Porta, Donatella, and Sidney Tarrow. 2012. Interactive Diffusion. The Coevolution of Police and Protest Behavior with an Application to Transnational Contention. Comparative Political Studies 45 (1): 119–52.
Dießelmann, Anna-Lena. 2015. Ausnahmezustand im Sicherheits- und Krisendiskurs. Eine diskurstheoretische Studie mit Fallanalysen. Siegen: Universitätsverlag Siegen.
Eijkman, Quirine. 2011. Police Technology and Human Rights: A New Quest for Accountability? Journal of Police Studies 20: 195–204.
Feest, Johannes, and Erhard Blankenburg. 1972. Die Definitionsmacht der Polizei. Strategien der Strafverfolgung und soziale Selektion. Studienbücher zur Sozialwissenschaft 1. Düsseldorf: Bertelsmann Univ.-Verl.
Fernandez, Luis A, and Laura Huey. 2009. Is Resistance Futile? Thoughts on Resisting Surveillance. Surveillance & Society 6 (3): 199–202.
Foucault, Michel. 1979. Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison. New York: Vintage Books.
Freudenschuß, Magdalena. 2015. Paradoxe Dynamik. Aktivismus zwischen Anonymität und Sichtbarkeit. Forschungsjournal Soziale Bewegungen 28 (3): 55–62.
Galdon Clavell, Gemma. 2014. Surveillance by Any Other Name? Understanding Counter-Surveillance as Critical Discourse and Practice. Teknokultura. Revista de Cultura Digital y Movimientos Sociales 11 (2): 329–48.
Gillham, Patrick F., and John A. Noakes. 2007. “More than a March in a Circle”: Transgressive Protests and the Limits of Negotiated Management. Mobilization: An International Journal 12: 341–57.
Goldsmith, Andrew. 2010. Policing’s New Visibility. British Journal of Criminology 50 (5): 914–34.
Greer, Chris, and Eugene McLaughlin. 2010. We Predict a Riot? Public Order Policing, New Media Environments, and the Rise of the Citizen Journalist. British Journal of Criminology 50 (6): 1041–1059.
Haggerty, Kevin D., and Richard V. Ericson. 2000. The Surveillant Assemblage. British Journal of Sociology 51 (4): 605–22.
Hellmann, Kai-Uwe. 1996. Systemtheorie und neue soziale Bewegungen. Identitätsprobleme in der Risikogesellschaft. Opladen: Westdeutscher Verlag.
Hempel, Leon, and Eric Töpfer. 2009. The Surveillance Consensus. European Journal of Criminology 6 (2): 157–77.
Hermida, Alberto, and Víctor Hernández-Santaolalla. 2017. Twitter and Video Activism as Tools for Counter-Surveillance: The Case of Social Protests in Spain. Information, Communication & Society: 1–18.
Hier, Sean P. 2003. Probing the Surveillant Assemblage: On the Dialectics of Surveillance Practices as Processes of Social Control. Surveillance & Society 1 (3): 399–411.
Hirsch, Joachim. 1986. Der Sicherheitsstaat. Das ‘Modell Deutschland’, seine Krise und die neuen sozialen Bewegungen. Rev. Reprint. Frankfurt/Main: Athenäum Verlag.
Kääriäinen, Juha, Pekka Isotalus, and Gunnar Thomassen. 2016. Does Public Criticism Erode Trust in the Police? The Case of Jari Aarnio in the Finnish News Media and Its Effects on the Public’s Attitudes towards the Police. Journal of Scandinavian Studies in Criminology and Crime Prevention, 1–16.
Kammerer, Dietmar. 2011. Bilder der Ãœberwachung. Frankfurt/Main: Suhrkamp.
Kammerer, Dietmar. 2016. Kampf um die Bilder. Videoüberwachung und Gegenüberwachung von Demonstrationen in Österreich. Juridikum, (4): 527–37.
Knopp and Ullrich. 2016. ‘Kampf um die Bilder. Videoüberwachung und Gegenüberwachung von Demonstrationen in Österreich’. Juridikum 4: 527–37.
Knopp, Philipp, and Peter Ullrich. submitted. Abschreckung im Konjunktiv. Macht- und Subjektivierungseffekte von Videoüberwachung auf Demonstrationen.
Knopp, Philipp, und Frederike Müller-Späth. 2017. Protestereignisse und Videoüberwachung in Berlin: Eine ethnografische Studie. IPB Working Papers. Institut für Protest- und Bewegungsforschung. https://protestinstitut.eu/ipb-working-papers/.
Lamnek, Siegfried. 1998. Gruppendiskussion. Theorie und Praxis. Weinheim: Beltz.
Luhmann, Niklas. 1996. Protest. Systemtheorie und soziale Bewegungen. Frankfurt/Main: Suhrkamp.
Lyon, David. 2001. Surveillance Society. Monitoring Everyday Life. Philadelphia: Open University Press.
Mann, Steve, Jason Nolan, and Barry Wellman. 2003. Sousveillance: Inventing and Using Wearable Computing Devices for Data Collection in Surveillance Environments. Surveillance 1 (3): 331–55.
Marquez, Xavier. 2012. Spaces of Appearance and Spaces of Surveillance. Polity 44 (1): 6–31.
Marx, Gary T. 1999. What’s in a Name? Some Reflections on the Sociology of Anonymity. Information Society 15: 99–112.
Marx, Gary T. 2003. A Tack in the Shoe. Neutralizing and Resisting the New Surveillance. Journal of Social Issues 59 (2): 369– 90.
Mathiesen, Thomas. 1997. The Viewer Society. Michel Foucault’s Panopticon Revisited. Theoretical Criminology 1 (2): 215–34.
Mayring, Philipp. 2000. Qualitative Inhaltsanalyse. Forum Qualitative Sozialforschung 1 (2): Art. 20.
Monahan, Torin. 2006. Counter-Surveillance as Political Intervention. Social Semiotics 16 (4): 515–34.
Neumayer, Christina, and Gitte Stald. 2014. The Mobile Phone in Street Protest: Texting, Tweeting, Tracking, and Tracing. Mobile Media & Communication 2 (2): 117–33.
Poster, Mark. 1990. The Mode of Information: Poststructuralism and Social Context. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.
Ragnedda, Massimo. 2011. Social Control and Surveillance in the Society of Consumers. International Journal of Sociology and Anthropology 3 (6): 180–88.
Reicher, Stephen, Clifford Stott, John Drury, Otto Adang, Patrick Cronin, and Andrew Livingstone. 2007. Knowledge-Based Public Order Policing. Principles and Practice. Policing - A Journal of Policy and Practice 1 (4): 403–15.
Rikspolisstyrelsen, ed. 2013. The Anthology. GODIAC – Good Practice for Dialogue and Communication as Strategic Principles for Policing Political Manifestations in Europe. Uppsala: GODIAC-projektet..
Rucht, Dieter. 2004. The Quadruple A: Media Strategies of Protest Movements since the 1960s. In Cyberprotest: New Media, Citizens and Social Movements, eds Wim van den Donk, Brian D. Loader, Paul G. Nixon, and Dieter Rucht, 25–48. New York: Routledge.
Rucht, Dieter, and Friedhelm Neidhardt. 2002. Towards a “Movement Society?” On the Possibilities of Institutionalizing Social Movements. Social Movement Studies 1 (1): 7–30.
Schaefer, Brian P., and Kevin F. Steinmetz. 2014. Watching the Watchers and McLuhan’s Tetrad: The Limits of Cop-Watching in the Internet Age. Surveillance & Society 12 (4): 502–15.
Schmitt-Beck, Rüdiger. 1990. Über die Bedeutung der Massenmedien für soziale Bewegungen. Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie 42 (4): 642–62.
Scholl, Christian. 2010. Two Sides of a Barricade. (Dis)Order and Summit Protest in Europe. Selbstverlag.
Schreiber, Martina. 2011. Germany. May Day in Berlin. In Managing Collective Violence around Public Events. An International Comparison, eds Otto Mathieu and Joseph Adang, 21–44. Apeldoorn: Politie & Wetenschap.
Schug, Caroline. 2012. Broadcast Yourself: Eine qualitative Untersuchung zur Darstellung der Polizei bei Großereignissen auf der Internetplattform YouTube und ihrer Wirkung auf die Nutzer. Neue Kriminalpolitik 24 (1): 11–16.
Schug, Caroline, and Joachim Kersten. 2013. Social Media Images of Police Use of Force during Protest Demonstrations. In The Anthology. GODIAC – Good Practice for Dialogue and Communication as Strategic Principles for Policing Political Manifestations in Europe, edited by Rikspolisstyrelsen, 218–25. Uppsala: GODIAC-projektet.
Singelnstein, Tobias. 2014. Körperverletzung im Amt durch Polizisten und die Erledigungspraxis der Staatsanwaltschaften - aus empirischer und strafprozessualer Sicht. Neue Kriminalpolitik 25 (1): 15–27.
Skolnick, Jerome H. 1966. Justice Without Trial. Law Enforcement in Democratic Society. New Orleans, LA: Quid Pro, LLC.
Starr, Amory, Luis A. Fernandez, Randall Amster, Lesley J. Wood, and Manuel J. Caro. 2008. The Impacts of State Surveillance on Political Assembly and Association: A Socio-Legal Analysis. Qualitative Sociology 31 (3): 251–70.
Steven, Elke. 2015. Blockupy. Demonstrationsbeobachtung am 18. März 2015, eds Komitee für Grundrechte und Demokratie e.V. Köln. [accessed July 20, 2017]. http://www.grundrechtekomitee.de/sites/default/files/BerichtBlockupy2015.pdf.
Stott, Clifford. 2009. Crowd Psychology & Public Order Policing. An Overview of Scientific Theory and Evidence. Submission to the HMIC Policing of Public Protest Review Team.
Strauss, Anselm L., and Juliet M Corbin. 1998. Basics of Qualitative Research. Techniques and Procedures for Developing Grounded Theory. 2nd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Teune, Simon. 2012. Corridors of Action. Protest Rationalities and the Channeling of Anti-Summit Repertoires. PhD diss., Berlin: Freie Universität Berlin.
Tuma, René. 2017. Videoprofis im Alltag. Die kommunikative Vielfalt der Videoanalyse. Wiesbaden: Springer Fachmedien.
Ullmann, Karen. 2008. Das Ampelsystem. Polizeiliche Gefahrenprognosen während des G8-Gipfels. In Feindbild Demonstrant. Polizeigewalt, Militäreinsatz, Medienmanipulation; der G8-Gipfel aus Sicht des Anwaltlichen Notdienstes, eds Republikanischer Anwältinnen- und Anwälteverein, 33–44. Berlin: Assoziation A.
Ullrich, Peter. 2014. Protest und technische Überwachung. Das Beispiel Videoüberwachung. Forschungsjournal Soziale Bewegungen 27 (4): 40–50.
Ullrich, Peter. 2017. Normalbürger“ versus „Krawalltouristen: Polizeiliche Kategorisierungen von Demonstrationen zwischen Recht und Soziologischem Ermessen. In Empirische Polizeiforschung XX. Polizei und Minderheiten, ed Karlhans Liebl, 61–97. Frankfurt/Main: Verlag für Polizeiwissenschaft.
Ullrich, Peter. 2018a. Researching Police in/under Protest. Police Research as a Journey of Discovery with Obstacles. ipb working papers 1. Berlin: Institut für Protest- und Bewegungsforschung. https://protestinstitut.eu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/Researching-Police_ipb-working-paper_1-18.pdf.
Ullrich, Peter. 2018b. Videoüberwachung von Demonstrationen und die Definitionsmacht der Polizei. Zwischen Objektivitätsfiktion und selektiver Sanktionierung. Technical University Technology Studies Working Papers 2. Berlin: Technische Universität. http://www.ts.tu-berlin.de/fileadmin/i62_tstypo3/TUTS-WP- 22018_Video%C3%BCberwachungVonDemonstrationen.pdf
Ullrich, and Gina Rosa Wollinger. 2011. A Surveillance Studies Perspective on Protest Policing: The Case of Video Surveillance of Demonstrations in Germany. Interface Journal 3 (1): 13–33.
Ullrich, Peter, Priska Daphi, and Britta Baumgarten. 2014. Protest and Culture. Concepts and Approaches in Social Movement Research: An Introduction. In Conceptualizing Culture in Social Movement Research, eds Britta Baumgarten, Priska Daphi, and Peter Ullrich, 1–20. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Wahlström, Mattias. 2011. The Making of Protest and Protest Policing: Negotiation, Knowledge, Space, and Narrative. Gothenburg: University of Gothenburg.
Wilson, Dean. 2012. Counter-Surveillance: Protest and Policing. Plymouth Law and Criminal Justice Review 4: 33–42.
Wilson, Dean Jonathon, and Tanya Serisier. 2010. Video Activism and the Ambiguities of Counter-Surveillance. Surveillance & Society 8 (2): 166–80.
Wood, Lesley J. 2014. Crisis and Control. The Militarization of Protest Policing. New York: Pluto Press.