Abstract
This article surveys studies of the occurrence, in the haptic modality, of three geometrical illusions well known in vision, and it discusses the nature of the processes underlying these haptic illusions.We argue that the apparently contradictory results found in the literature concerning them may be explained, at least partially, by the characteristics of manual exploratory movements. The Müller-Lyer illusion is present in vision and in haptics and seems to be the result of similar processes in the two modalities. The vertical-horizontal illusion also exists in vision and haptics but is due partly to similar processes (bisection) and partly to processes specific to each modality (anisotropy of the visual field and overestimation of radial vs. tangential manual exploratory movements). The Delboeuf illusion seems to occur only in vision, probably because exploration by the index finger may exclude the misleading context from tactile perception. The role of these haptic exploratory movements may explain why haptics is as sensitive as vision to certain illusions and less sensitive to others.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bean, C. (1938). The blind have “optical” illusions.Journal of Experimental Psychology,22, 283–289.
Casla, M., Blanco, F., &Travieso, D. (1999). Haptic perception of geometric illusions by persons who are totally congenitally blind.Journal of Visual Impairment & Blindness,93, 583–588.
Cheng, M. (1968). Tactile-kinesthetic perception of length.American Journal of Psychology,81, 74–82.
Coren, S., &Girgus, J. (1978).Seeing is deceiving: The psychology of visual illusions. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Cornoldi, C., Bertuccelli, B., Rocchi, P., &Sbrana, B. (1993). Processing capacity limitations in pictorial and spatial representations in the totally congenitally blind.Cortex,29, 675–689.
Day, R., &Avery, G. (1970). Absence of the horizontal-vertical illusion in haptic space.Journal of Experimental Psychology,83, 172–173.
Day, R., &Wong, T. (1971). Radial and tangential movement directions as determinants of the haptic illusion in an L figure.Journal of Experimental Psychology,87, 19–22.
Deregowski, J., &Ellis, H. D. (1972). Effect of stimulus orientation upon haptic perception of the horizontal-vertical illusion.Journal of Experimental Psychology,95, 14–19.
Eagleman, D. M. (2001). Visual illusion and neurobiology.Nature Neuroscience Review,2, 920–926.
Faineteau, H., Gentaz, E., &Viviani, P. (2003). The kinaesthetic perception of Euclidean distance: A study of the detour effect.Experimental Brain Research,152, 166–172.
Fisher, G. H. (1966). A tactual Poggendorff illusion.Nature,212, 105–106.
Gentaz, E. Camos, V., Hatwell, Y., & Jacquet, A.-Y. (2004).The visual and haptic Müller-Lyer illusions. Manuscript submitted for publication.
Gentaz, E., &Hatwell, Y. (1996). Role of gravitational cues in the haptic perception of orientation.Perception & Psychophysics,58, 1278–1292.
Gentaz, E., &Hatwell, Y.v (1998). The haptic oblique effect in the perception of rod orientation by blind adults.Perception & Psychophysics,60, 157–167.
Gentaz, E., &Hatwell, Y. (1999). Role of memorisation conditions in the haptic processing of orientations and the “oblique effect”.British Journal of Psychologyv,90, 377–388.
Gentaz, E., &Hatwell, Y. (2002). Le toucher, un sens trompeur?Pour La Science,293, 78–83.
Gibson, J. J. (1962). Observations on active touch.Psychological Review,69, 477–490.
Gibson, J. J. (1966).The senses considered as perceptual systems. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Gregory, R. L. (1998).Eye and brain: The psychology of seeing (5th ed.). London: Oxford University Press.
Gregory, R. L., &Harris, J. (1975). Illusion-destruction by appropriate scaling.Perception,4, 203–220.
Hatwell, Y. (1960). étude de quelques illusions géométriques tactiles chez les aveugles.L’Année Psychologique,1, 11–27.
Hatwell, Y. (1978). Form perception and related issues in blind humans. In R. Held, H. Leibowitz, & H. Teuber (Eds.),Handbook of sensory physiology: VII. Perception (pp. 488–519). New York: Springer-Verlag.
Hatwell, Y. (1985).Piagetian reasoning and the blind (Pierre Verdet, Trans.). New York: American Foundation for the Blind. (Original work published 1966)
Hatwell, Y. (2003).Psychologie cognitive de la cécité précoce. Paris: Dunod.
Hatwell, Y., Orliaguet, J.-P., &Brouty, G. (1990). Effects of object properties, attentional constraints and manual exploratory procedures on haptic perceptual organization: A developmental study. In H. Bloch & B. I. Bertenthal (Eds.),Sensory-motor organizations and development in infancy and early childhood (pp. 315–335). Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Hatwell, Y., Streri, A., &Gentaz, E. (Eds.) (2000).Toucher pour connaître: Psychologie cognitive de la perception tactile manuelle. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.
Hatwell, Y., Streri, A., &Gentaz, E. (Eds.) (2003).Touching for knowing. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Heller, M. A. (Ed.) (2000).Touch, representation and blindness. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Heller, M. A., Brackett, D. D., Wilson, K., Yoneyama, K., &Boyer, A. (2002). Visual experience and the haptic horizontal-vertical illusion.British Journal of Visual Impairment,20, 105–109.
Heller, M. A., Brackett, D. D., Wilson, K., Yoneyama, K., Boyer, A., &Steffen, H. (2002). The haptic Müller-Lyer illusion in sighted and blind people.Perception,31, 1263–1274.
Heller, M. A., Calcaterra, J. A., Burson, L. L., &Green, S. L. (1997). The tactual horizontal-vertical illusion depends on radial motion of the entire arm.Perception & Psychophysics,59, 1297–1311.
Heller, M. A., &Joyner, T. D. (1993). Mechanisms in the haptic horizontal-vertical illusion: Evidence from sighted and blind subjects.Perception & Psychophysics,53, 422–428.
Klatzky, R. L. (1999). Path completion after haptic exploration without vision: Implications for haptic spatial representations.Perception & Psychophysics,61, 220–235.
Künnapas, T. M.v (1955). An analysis of the “vertical-horizontal illusion”.Journal of Experimental Psychology,49, 134–140.
Künnapas, T. M. (1957a). Interocular differences in the vertical-horizontal illusion.Acta Psychologica,13, 253–259.
Kÿ nnapas, T. M. (1957b). Vertical-horizontal illusions and surrounding field.Acta Psychologica,13, 35–42.
Künnapas, T. M. (1957c). The vertical-horizontal illusion and the visual field.Journal of Experimental Psychology,53, 405–407.
Lederman, S. J., &Klatzky, R. L. (1987). Hand movements: A window into haptic object recognition.Cognitive Psychology,19, 342–368.
Lederman, S. J., &Klatzky, R. L. (1993). Extracting object properties through haptic exploration.Acta Psychologica,84, 29–40.
Lederman, S. J., Klatzky, R. L., &Barber, P. O. (1985). Spatial and movement-based heuristics for encoding pattern information through touch.Journal of Experimental Psychology: General,114, 33–49.
Lederman, S. J., Klatzky, R. L., Collins, A., &Wardell, J. (1987). Exploring environments by hand or foot: Time-based heuristics for encoding distance in movement space.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Memory & Language,16, 606–614.
Loomis, J. M., Klatzky, R. L., &Lederman, S. J. (1991). Similarity of tactual and visual picture recognition with limited field of view.Perception,20, 167–177.
Lucca, A., Dellantonio, A., &Riggio, L. (1986). Some observations on the Poggendorff and Müller-Lyer tactual illusions.Perception & Psychophysics,39, 374–380.
Millar, S. (1994).Understanding and representing space: Theory and evidence from studies with blind and sighted children. Oxford: Oxford University Press, Clarendon Press.
Millar, S. (2001). Illusions in reading maps by touch: Reducing distance errors.British Journal of Psychology,92, 643–657.
Millar, S., &Al-Attar, Z. (2000). Vertical and bisection bias in active touch.Perception,29, 481–500.
Millar, S., &Al-Attar, Z. (2002). The Müller-Lyer illusion in touch and vision: Implications for multisensory processes.Perception & Psychophysics,64, 353–365.
Over, R. (1966a). A comparison of haptic and visual judgments of some illusions.American Journal of Psychology,79, 590–595.
Over, R. (1966b). Context and movement as factors influencing haptic illusions.Australian Journal of Psychology,3, 262–265.
Over, R. (1967). Intermanual transfer of practice decrements with a haptic illusion.Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology,19, 215–218.
Patterson, J., &Deffenbacher, K. (1972). Haptic perception of the Müller-Lyer illusion by the blind.Perceptual & Motor Skills,35, 819–824.
Piaget, J. (1957).Les mécanismes perceptifs. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.
Pick, H. (1974). Visual coding of non-visual spatial information. In R. MacLeod & H. Pick (Eds.),Perception (pp. 153–165). Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Prinzmetal, W., &Gettleman, L. (1993). Vertical-horizontal illusion: One eye is better than two.Perception & Psychophysics,53, 81–88.
Revesz, G. (1934). System der optischen und haptischen Raumtäuschungen.Zeitschrift für Physiologie,131, 296–375.
Revesz, G. (1950).Psychology and art of the blind. London: Longmans Green.
Rudel, R., &Teuber, H.-L. (1963). Decrement of visual and haptic Müller-Lyer illusion on repeated trials: A study of cross-modal transfer.Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology,15, 125–131.
Suzuki, K., &Arashida, R. (1992). Geometrical haptic illusions revisited: Haptic illusions compared with visual illusions.Perception & Psychophysics,52 329–335.
Thinus-Blanc, C., &Gaunet, F. (1997). Representation of space in the blind: Vision as a spatial sense?Psychological Bulletin,121, 20–42.
Tsai, L. S. (1967). Müller-Lyer illusion by the blind.Perceptual & Motor Skills,25, 641–644.
Von Collani, G. (1979). An analysis of illusion components with L and perpendicular figures in active touch.Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology,31, 241–248.
Wenderoth, P., &Alais, D. (1990). Lack of evidence for a tactual Poggendorff illusion.Perception & Psychophysics,48, 234–242.
Wong, T. S. (1975). The respective role of limb and eye movements in the haptic and visual Müller-Lyer illusion.Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology,27, 659–666.
Wong, T. S. (1977). Dynamic properties of radial and tangential movements as determinants of the haptic horizontal-vertical illusion with an L figure.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception & Performance,3, 151–164.
Worchel, P. (1951). Space perception and orientation in the blind.Psychological Monographs:General & Applied,65, (15, Whole No. 332), 1–28.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gentaz, E., Hatwell, Y. Geometrical haptic illusions: The role of exploration in the Müller-Lyer, vertical-horizontal, and Delboeuf illusions. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 11, 31–40 (2004). https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03206457
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03206457