Skip to main content

2016 | OriginalPaper | Buchkapitel

28. Reinventing Clinical Legal Education: Taiwanese Adaptation of an American Model

verfasst von : Serge A. Martinez

Erschienen in: Legal Thoughts between the East and the West in the Multilevel Legal Order

Verlag: Springer Singapore

Aktivieren Sie unsere intelligente Suche, um passende Fachinhalte oder Patente zu finden.

search-config
loading …

Abstract

The clinical legal education movement began in earnest in the United States in the 1960s in response to student demands that their legal education serve marginalized communities. As clinical legal education became a mainstream element of American legal education, the focus moved from its service-based roots to an emphasis on education, particularly practical lawyering skills and professional values for lawyers. Law clinics in the United States have developed a standard model that works to achieve these objectives within the framework of the American legal system. The global spread of clinical legal education originated in the United States and has led to clinical programs around the world. The most successful exports are tailored to the local context. It is the concept of clinical legal education that travels best, not any particular model. Taiwan’s legal educators have resisted clinical education for a very long time, and there are several practical obstacles to implementing an American-style clinic. However, some existing models that have been created within the existing system would require only slight modification to be viable options for clinical education in Taiwan. The inchoate clinical movement in Taiwan will continue moving forward by developing models that, while reflecting the core objectives and concepts of the global clinical legal education movement, are absolutely Taiwanese.

Sie haben noch keine Lizenz? Dann Informieren Sie sich jetzt über unsere Produkte:

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 102.000 Bücher
  • über 537 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Automobil + Motoren
  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Elektrotechnik + Elektronik
  • Energie + Nachhaltigkeit
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Maschinenbau + Werkstoffe
  • Versicherung + Risiko

Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 67.000 Bücher
  • über 340 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Versicherung + Risiko




Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Fußnoten
1
See generally Martinez (2012).
 
2
Phan (2005), p. 136.
 
3
Wortham (2006), p. 633.
 
4
Dubin (1998), p. 1492.
 
5
Aiken and Wizner (2004), p. 998.
 
6
Id. at p. 1010.
 
7
Wilson (2004), p. 431. Claims about creating justice-minded lawyers can go too far, however. A recent review of data on the effect of participation in a law school clinic found no correlation between clinic participation and likelihood to engage in public interest after graduation. The review did, however, find “a strong relationship between clinical training experiences and public service employment” among new lawyers who came to law school with hopes of making a positive contribution to society. See Sandefur and Selbin (2009), p. 102.
 
8
Joy (2004), p. 820.
 
9
Packer and Ehrlich (1972), p. 37.
 
10
Id.
 
11
See National Archive of Clinical Legal Education (2000), p. 5.
 
12
Packer and Ehrlich (1972), p. 38.
 
13
Dubin (1998), p. 1465.
 
14
Council on Legal Education for Professional Responsibility (1969), p. 2.
 
15
Packer and Ehrlich (1972), p. 38.
 
16
Center for the Study of Applied Legal Education (2015), p. 7.
 
17
Aiken and Wizner (2004), p. 998.
 
18
Kotkin (1989), p. 191.
 
19
Id. at pp. 191–192.
 
20
Dubin (1998), p. 1466.
 
21
See Center for the Study of Applied Legal Education (2015).
 
22
Contrast this with law school clinics in Palestine, where the absence of other sources of legal assistance means law clinics feel obligated to have a more generalist practice. Qafisheh (2015), p.119.
 
23
Joy (2004), p. 822.
 
24
In Chile, several law school clinics were created in response to teacher and student demand during the early 1970s, when a progressive government was in power and social consciousness was rising in that country. See generally Wilson (2001).
 
25
Rekosh (2008), p. 87. See Ogilvy (2012) for a partial list.
 
26
Wilson (2004), p. 426.
 
27
Dowdle (2000), p. S56.
 
28
Wilson (2004), p. 429.
 
29
Hamoudi (2005), p. 112.
 
30
Bloch (2008), p. 129.
 
31
Rekosh (2008), p. 86.
 
32
Wilson (2015), pp 198–200.
 
33
Dowdle (2000), p. S72.
 
34
Abramson (2006), p. 324.
 
35
Dowdle (2000), p. S72.
 
36
Chen (2015), pp. 79–80.
 
37
See generally Lo (2006).
 
38
Id. fn. 10.
 
39
See Chang (2010) for a history of public interest law in Taiwan after martial law. More recently, when student demonstrators were arrested in large numbers after occupying the Legislative Yuan in 2013 as part of the Sunflower Movement, lawyers used a Facebook group to coordinate representation for detainees and advice and support to other protestors. Interview with Chou Yu-Shiou (2015).
 
40
See Regulations Governing Pre-service Training for Attorneys.
 
41
See Martinez (2012), pp. 360–363.
 
42
Interviews with Chen Yu-Fan, Chou Yu-Shiou, Lin Hsinyi, Lin Shih-fang, and Echo Lin (2015).
 
43
For a more expansive discussion of these structural impediments to developing Taiwanese clinical legal education, see generally Martinez (2012).
 
44
This is actually somewhat high compared to historical pass rates, which have often been much lower. In several years the passing applicants numbered in the single digits. See Lo (2006), pp. 66–67.
 
45
Id. at p. 53. “[Undergraduate students’] limited social and work experiences have been a source of struggle for many students in understanding…the abstract concepts of justice and fairness.” Pamela Phan makes this same argument about the ability of undergraduate law students in China to engage in the reflective aspect of clinical legal education. Phan (2005), p. 126.
 
46
See the Code of Civil Procedure §68 “Only an attorney may act as an advocate, except where the presiding judge permits a person who is not an attorney to act as an advocate” and the Code of Criminal Procedure §29, “A defense attorney shall be a lawyer, provided that if permission is obtained from the presiding judge at trial, a person who is not a lawyer may be retained as a defense attorney.”
 
47
Government employees in Taiwan, including most law professors, may not be attorneys. See Attorney Regulation Act, Art. 31.
 
48
See National Chengchi University College of Law (2016).
 
49
The National Chengchi University program was briefly mandatory, but the requirement was apparently dropped due to lack of enthusiasm on the part of law students who were not particularly public service minded. See Chen (2015), p. 81.
 
50
See Martinez (2012) and Chen (2015), pp. 81–84.
 
51
The only serious limitation encountered was, as expected, some hesitance on the part of judges and lawyers to allow law students to argue on behalf of their clients in court, and prosecutors, who refused to meet with the students.
 
52
Interview with Lo Shih-Shiang (2016).
 
Literatur
Zurück zum Zitat Abramson K (2006) Paradigms in the cultivation of China’s future legal elite: a case study of legal education in Western China. Asian Pac Law Policy J 7:302–384 Abramson K (2006) Paradigms in the cultivation of China’s future legal elite: a case study of legal education in Western China. Asian Pac Law Policy J 7:302–384
Zurück zum Zitat Aiken J, Wizner S (2004) Teaching and doing: the role of law school clinics in enhancing access to justice. Fordham Law J 73:997–1011 Aiken J, Wizner S (2004) Teaching and doing: the role of law school clinics in enhancing access to justice. Fordham Law J 73:997–1011
Zurück zum Zitat Bloch FS (2008) Access to justice and the global clinical movement. J Law Policy 28:111–139 Bloch FS (2008) Access to justice and the global clinical movement. J Law Policy 28:111–139
Zurück zum Zitat Chang W-C (2010) Public interest litigation in Taiwan: strategy for law and policy changes in the course of democratization. In: Yap PJ, Lau H (eds) Public interest litigation in Asia. Routledge, New York, pp 136–160 Chang W-C (2010) Public interest litigation in Taiwan: strategy for law and policy changes in the course of democratization. In: Yap PJ, Lau H (eds) Public interest litigation in Asia. Routledge, New York, pp 136–160
Zurück zum Zitat Chen TC (2015) Clinical education in Taiwanese law schools. In: Sarker S (ed) Clinical legal education in Asia: accessing justice for the underprivileged. Palgrave Macmillan, New York, pp 75–90CrossRef Chen TC (2015) Clinical education in Taiwanese law schools. In: Sarker S (ed) Clinical legal education in Asia: accessing justice for the underprivileged. Palgrave Macmillan, New York, pp 75–90CrossRef
Zurück zum Zitat Council on Legal Education for Professional Responsibility (1969) Clinical legal education in the law school curriculum. Council on Legal Education for Professional Responsibility, New York Council on Legal Education for Professional Responsibility (1969) Clinical legal education in the law school curriculum. Council on Legal Education for Professional Responsibility, New York
Zurück zum Zitat Dowdle MW (2000) Preserving indigenous paradigms in an age of globalization: pragmatic strategies for the development of clinical legal aid in China. Fordham Int Law J 24:S56–S82 Dowdle MW (2000) Preserving indigenous paradigms in an age of globalization: pragmatic strategies for the development of clinical legal aid in China. Fordham Int Law J 24:S56–S82
Zurück zum Zitat Dubin J (1998) Clinical design for social justice imperatives. SMU Law Rev 51:1461–1507 Dubin J (1998) Clinical design for social justice imperatives. SMU Law Rev 51:1461–1507
Zurück zum Zitat Hamoudi H (2005) Toward a rule of law society in Iraq: introducing clinical legal education into Iraqi Law Schools. Berkeley J Int Law 23:112–137 Hamoudi H (2005) Toward a rule of law society in Iraq: introducing clinical legal education into Iraqi Law Schools. Berkeley J Int Law 23:112–137
Zurück zum Zitat Joy PA (2004) The ethics of law school clinic students as student-lawyers. South Texas Law J 45:815–842 Joy PA (2004) The ethics of law school clinic students as student-lawyers. South Texas Law J 45:815–842
Zurück zum Zitat Kotkin MJ (1989) Reconsidering role assumption in clinical education. New Mexico Law Rev 19:185–202 Kotkin MJ (1989) Reconsidering role assumption in clinical education. New Mexico Law Rev 19:185–202
Zurück zum Zitat Lo C-f (2006) Driving an ox cart to catch up with the space shuttle: the need for and prospects of legal education reform in Taiwan. Wis Int Law J 24:41–84 Lo C-f (2006) Driving an ox cart to catch up with the space shuttle: the need for and prospects of legal education reform in Taiwan. Wis Int Law J 24:41–84
Zurück zum Zitat Martinez S (2012) Law clinics in Taiwan: can clinical legal education succeed in this civil law jurisdiction with an undergraduate legal education system? NTU Law Rev 7:343–384 Martinez S (2012) Law clinics in Taiwan: can clinical legal education succeed in this civil law jurisdiction with an undergraduate legal education system? NTU Law Rev 7:343–384
Zurück zum Zitat Packer HL, Ehrlich T (1972) New directions in legal education. McGraw Hill, New York Packer HL, Ehrlich T (1972) New directions in legal education. McGraw Hill, New York
Zurück zum Zitat Phan PN (2005) Clinical legal education in China: in pursuit of a culture of law and a mission of social justice. Yale Hum Rights Dev Law J 8:117–152 Phan PN (2005) Clinical legal education in China: in pursuit of a culture of law and a mission of social justice. Yale Hum Rights Dev Law J 8:117–152
Zurück zum Zitat Qafisheh M (2015) Clinical legal education in Palestine: a clinical case under military occupation. In: Sarker S (ed) Clinical legal education in Asia: accessing justice for the underprivileged. Palgrave Macmillan, New York, pp 113–136CrossRef Qafisheh M (2015) Clinical legal education in Palestine: a clinical case under military occupation. In: Sarker S (ed) Clinical legal education in Asia: accessing justice for the underprivileged. Palgrave Macmillan, New York, pp 113–136CrossRef
Zurück zum Zitat Rekosh E (2008) Constructing public interest law: transnational collaboration and exchange in Central and Eastern Europe. UCLA J Int Law Foreign Aff 13:55–95 Rekosh E (2008) Constructing public interest law: transnational collaboration and exchange in Central and Eastern Europe. UCLA J Int Law Foreign Aff 13:55–95
Zurück zum Zitat Sandefur R, Selbin J (2009) The clinic effect. Clin Law Rev 16:57–107 Sandefur R, Selbin J (2009) The clinic effect. Clin Law Rev 16:57–107
Zurück zum Zitat Wilson R (2001) Three law school clinics in Chile, 1970–2000: innovation, resistance and conformity in the Global South. Clin Law Rev 8:515–582 Wilson R (2001) Three law school clinics in Chile, 1970–2000: innovation, resistance and conformity in the Global South. Clin Law Rev 8:515–582
Zurück zum Zitat Wilson R (2004) Training for justice: the global reach of clinical legal education. Penn State Int Law Rev 22:421–431 Wilson R (2004) Training for justice: the global reach of clinical legal education. Penn State Int Law Rev 22:421–431
Zurück zum Zitat Wilson M (2015) Legal clinical education in Japan: a work in progress. In: Sarker S (ed) Clinical legal education in Asia: accessing justice for the underprivileged. Palgrave Macmillan, New York, pp 195–213CrossRef Wilson M (2015) Legal clinical education in Japan: a work in progress. In: Sarker S (ed) Clinical legal education in Asia: accessing justice for the underprivileged. Palgrave Macmillan, New York, pp 195–213CrossRef
Zurück zum Zitat Wortham L (2006) Aiding clinical education abroad: what can be gained and the learning curve on how to do so effectively. Clin Law Rev 12:615–686 Wortham L (2006) Aiding clinical education abroad: what can be gained and the learning curve on how to do so effectively. Clin Law Rev 12:615–686
Metadaten
Titel
Reinventing Clinical Legal Education: Taiwanese Adaptation of an American Model
verfasst von
Serge A. Martinez
Copyright-Jahr
2016
Verlag
Springer Singapore
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-1995-1_28