Skip to main content

2024 | OriginalPaper | Buchkapitel

Rules of Standing and Populist Constitutionalism: The Case of the Greek Council of State

verfasst von : Dimitrios-Georgios Patsikas

Erschienen in: The People’s Constitution

Verlag: Springer Nature Switzerland

Aktivieren Sie unsere intelligente Suche, um passende Fachinhalte oder Patente zu finden.

search-config
loading …

Abstract

This chapter argues that a relaxed employment of locus standi rules in constitutional cases might enable greater citizen’s participation in creating constitutional meaning, hence promoting what can be seen as a form of populist constitutionalism. It examines recent case-law of the Greek Council of State (CoS or the Court), which approaches the locus standi rules with considerable flexibility, especially when hearing cases of major public interest. By refraining from a formalistic application of the rules of standing, the CoS gains the opportunity to address the disputed issues and decide constitutional cases on the merits. This trend is confirmed in cases brought before the Court both by individual persons as well as by interest groups and associations. Although broad standing rules entail the risk of introducing an actio popularis, the CoS seems nevertheless to favor a lenient application of the relevant rules. By enabling ordinary people to be heard before it in order to have their constitutional rights enforced, the Court lays the ground for wider popular involvement in the creation of constitutional case-law, effectively promoting what in parts of the constitutional theory literature has been termed populist (or popular) constitutionalism.

Sie haben noch keine Lizenz? Dann Informieren Sie sich jetzt über unsere Produkte:

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 102.000 Bücher
  • über 537 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Automobil + Motoren
  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Elektrotechnik + Elektronik
  • Energie + Nachhaltigkeit
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Maschinenbau + Werkstoffe
  • Versicherung + Risiko

Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 67.000 Bücher
  • über 340 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Versicherung + Risiko




Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Fußnoten
1
I understand civil society as the collective bodies and unions, as well as private individuals trying to manifest their interests within the public sphere. See Flyvbjerg (1998).
 
2
In this chapter, I borrow the term “populist constitutionalism” as defined by Tushnet (1999) and use it in parallel with the term “popular constitutionalism” as explained by Kramer (2004).
 
3
See Parker (1993), p. 573.
 
4
See, among many others, Kramer (2004) and Tushnet (2000).
 
5
The translation comes from the Hellenic Parliament’s official publication (emphasis added). Hereinafter, I am referring to the currently in force Greek Constitution of 1975, as revised in 1986, 2001, 2008 and 2019.
 
6
See Kaidatzis (2014).
 
7
Council of State, Decision 1491/2015.
 
8
See article 47, para. 1, of the Presidential Decree 18/1989 codifying statutory provisions for the Council of State. The same rules roughly apply for the intervening parties as well.
 
9
Council of State, Decision 95/2017 (plenary). See, also, Pirgakis (2017), p. 81.
 
10
Council of State, Decisions 935/2018, 1844/2019 and 218/2021.
 
11
The well-known term was, of course, coined by Bickel (1961).
 
12
See Vlachopoulos (2019).
 
13
See Moukiou (2016).
 
14
Council of State, Decision 1992/2020, para. 5. All the extracts of the Court’s decisions, referred to this chapter, are translated by the author.
 
15
Council of State, Decision 3341/2013 (plenary), para. 6 and Decision 1858/2015 (plenary), para. 5, respectively.
 
16
Council of State, Decision 2102/2019 (plenary), para. 9.
 
17
See Kaidatzis (2022) and Fotiadou (2020).
 
18
Council of State, Decision 660/2018 (plenary), para. 9, Decision 1749/2019 (plenary), para. 9 and Decision 1750/2019 (plenary), para. 8, respectively.
 
19
See Drossos (2020), pp. 35–82.
 
20
See Kaidatzis (2021), Avdikos (2020) and Tsiftsoglou (2019).
 
21
See Akrivopoulou (2014) and Dimopoulos (2013).
 
22
See Kivotidis (2018).
 
23
Council of State, Decision 3344/2013 (plenary), para. 6.
 
24
Council of State, Decision 460/2013 (plenary). See Christopoulos (2017) and Vassilakakis (2014).
 
25
See Moraitidis (2017).
 
26
Council of State, Decisions 685/2019 (plenary), 961/2020 and 1850/2020.
 
27
See Eliantonio et al. (2013), p. 56.
 
28
Council of State, Decision 668/2012 (full plenary), para. 26.
 
29
Council of State, Decision 3344/2013 (plenary), para. 6.
 
30
Council of State, Decision 3341/2013 (plenary), para. 6.
 
31
See Feldman (1992), Tushnet (1992) and Chayes (1976).
 
32
For a comprehensive analysis on the significance of constitutional dialogue between the courts, political branches and ordinary people see Bateup (2006).
 
33
See Teperoglou (2020), Andreadis and Stavrakakis (2017) and Karyotis et al. (2014).
 
34
According to the 7th World Values Survey, conducted in Greece by the Dianeosis nonprofit think-tank in cooperation with the National Center for Social Research (EKKE) between September and October 2017, more than half Greeks trust only five institutions (universities, the armed forces, the police, the Church and the judiciary), whereas the levels of trust in parliament, the government and political parties were under 15%. See Koniordos (2018).
 
35
See Kaidatzis (2022) and Blokker (2019).
 
36
See Kramer (2004), p. 92.
 
37
See Ervasti et al. (2019).
 
38
Council of State, Decisions 1902-1909/2014 (plenary) and Decisions 2179-2189/2014 (plenary). In these cases, the CoS denied grosso modo that citizens-users of public services and employees have locus standi to challenge the privatization of certain public enterprises, such as the former Athens airport, Public Gas Corporation, Hellenic Petroleum, Piraeus Port Authority etc.
 
39
See Kaidatzis (2019) and Bugarič (2017).
 
Literatur
Zurück zum Zitat Akrivopoulou C (2014) Eurozone crisis and social rights protection in the south European jurisprudence. Annuaire International Des Droits de l’ Homme, vol 7. Sakkoulas Publications, Athens-Thessaloniki, pp 3–13 Akrivopoulou C (2014) Eurozone crisis and social rights protection in the south European jurisprudence. Annuaire International Des Droits de l’ Homme, vol 7. Sakkoulas Publications, Athens-Thessaloniki, pp 3–13
Zurück zum Zitat Andreadis I, Stavrakakis Y (2017) European populist parties in government: how well are voters represented? Evidence from Greece. Swiss Polit Sci Rev 23(4):485–508CrossRef Andreadis I, Stavrakakis Y (2017) European populist parties in government: how well are voters represented? Evidence from Greece. Swiss Polit Sci Rev 23(4):485–508CrossRef
Zurück zum Zitat Avdikos G (2020) Judicial and constitutional review during the Greek sovereign debt crisis: a general overview. Eur Public Law 26(2):237–242CrossRef Avdikos G (2020) Judicial and constitutional review during the Greek sovereign debt crisis: a general overview. Eur Public Law 26(2):237–242CrossRef
Zurück zum Zitat Bateup C (2006) The dialogic promise: assessing the normative potential of theories of constitutional dialogue. Brooklyn Law Rev 71(3):1109–1180 Bateup C (2006) The dialogic promise: assessing the normative potential of theories of constitutional dialogue. Brooklyn Law Rev 71(3):1109–1180
Zurück zum Zitat Bickel A (1961) The Supreme Court, 1960 Term. Foreword: the passive virtues. Harv Law Rev 75(1):40–79CrossRef Bickel A (1961) The Supreme Court, 1960 Term. Foreword: the passive virtues. Harv Law Rev 75(1):40–79CrossRef
Zurück zum Zitat Blokker P (2019) Varieties of populist constitutionalism: the transnational dimension. German Law J 20(3):332–350CrossRef Blokker P (2019) Varieties of populist constitutionalism: the transnational dimension. German Law J 20(3):332–350CrossRef
Zurück zum Zitat Chayes A (1976) The role of the judge in public law litigation. Harv Law Rev 89(7):1281–1316CrossRef Chayes A (1976) The role of the judge in public law litigation. Harv Law Rev 89(7):1281–1316CrossRef
Zurück zum Zitat Christopoulos D (2017) An unexpected reform in the maelstrom of the crisis: Greek nationality in the times of the memoranda (2010–2015). Citizenship Stud 21(4):483–494CrossRef Christopoulos D (2017) An unexpected reform in the maelstrom of the crisis: Greek nationality in the times of the memoranda (2010–2015). Citizenship Stud 21(4):483–494CrossRef
Zurück zum Zitat Drossos Y (2020) The Flight of Icarus: European legal responses resulting from the financial crisis. Hart Publishing, OxfordCrossRef Drossos Y (2020) The Flight of Icarus: European legal responses resulting from the financial crisis. Hart Publishing, OxfordCrossRef
Zurück zum Zitat Eliantonio M et al (eds) (2013) Standing up for your right(s) in Europe: a comparative study on legal standing (Locus Standi) before the EU and Member States’ Courts. Intersentia, Cambridge Eliantonio M et al (eds) (2013) Standing up for your right(s) in Europe: a comparative study on legal standing (Locus Standi) before the EU and Member States’ Courts. Intersentia, Cambridge
Zurück zum Zitat Feldman D (1992) Public interest litigation and constitutional theory in comparative perspective. Mod Law Rev 55(1):44–72CrossRef Feldman D (1992) Public interest litigation and constitutional theory in comparative perspective. Mod Law Rev 55(1):44–72CrossRef
Zurück zum Zitat Kaidatzis A (2021) Socio-economic rights enforcement and resource allocation in times of austerity: the case of Greece 2015-2018. In: Farahat A, Arzoz X (eds) Contesting austerity – a socio-legal inquiry. Hart Publishing, Oxford, pp 275–294 Kaidatzis A (2021) Socio-economic rights enforcement and resource allocation in times of austerity: the case of Greece 2015-2018. In: Farahat A, Arzoz X (eds) Contesting austerity – a socio-legal inquiry. Hart Publishing, Oxford, pp 275–294
Zurück zum Zitat Karyotis G et al (2014) Representation and austerity politics: attitudes of Greek voters and elites compared. South Eur Soc Polit 19(4):435–456CrossRef Karyotis G et al (2014) Representation and austerity politics: attitudes of Greek voters and elites compared. South Eur Soc Polit 19(4):435–456CrossRef
Zurück zum Zitat Kivotidis D (2018) The form and content of the Greek crisis legislation. Law Crit 29(1):57–81CrossRef Kivotidis D (2018) The form and content of the Greek crisis legislation. Law Crit 29(1):57–81CrossRef
Zurück zum Zitat Kramer L (2004) The people themselves: popular constitutionalism and judicial review. Oxford University Press, OxfordCrossRef Kramer L (2004) The people themselves: popular constitutionalism and judicial review. Oxford University Press, OxfordCrossRef
Zurück zum Zitat Moraitidis M (2017) The history and interventions of the Hellenic League for Human Rights (1918-2013). In: Schmale W, Treiblmayr C (eds) Human Rights Leagues in Europe (1898-2016). Franz Steiner Verlag, Stuttgart, pp 139–156 Moraitidis M (2017) The history and interventions of the Hellenic League for Human Rights (1918-2013). In: Schmale W, Treiblmayr C (eds) Human Rights Leagues in Europe (1898-2016). Franz Steiner Verlag, Stuttgart, pp 139–156
Zurück zum Zitat Moukiou C (2016) Ennomo symferon kai Actio Popularis: i elastikotita tis ennias tou ennomou symferontos sto plaisio metavolis ton koinonikon kai ikonomikon dedomenon (Locus Standi and Actio Popularis – The flexibility of the notion of locus standi in the context of changing social and economic reality). Theoria kai Praksi Diikitikou Dikaiou (Theory and Practice of Administrative Law), pp 731–743 [in Greek] Moukiou C (2016) Ennomo symferon kai Actio Popularis: i elastikotita tis ennias tou ennomou symferontos sto plaisio metavolis ton koinonikon kai ikonomikon dedomenon (Locus Standi and Actio Popularis – The flexibility of the notion of locus standi in the context of changing social and economic reality). Theoria kai Praksi Diikitikou Dikaiou (Theory and Practice of Administrative Law), pp 731–743 [in Greek]
Zurück zum Zitat Pirgakis D (2017) To ennomo symferon sti diki enopion tou Symvouliou tis Epikratias (Legitimate interest in proceedings before the Hellenic Council of State). Nomiki Bibliothiki, Athens [in Greek] Pirgakis D (2017) To ennomo symferon sti diki enopion tou Symvouliou tis Epikratias (Legitimate interest in proceedings before the Hellenic Council of State). Nomiki Bibliothiki, Athens [in Greek]
Zurück zum Zitat Teperoglou E et al (2020) The study of political representation in Greece: towards new patterns following the economic crisis? In: Freire A et al (eds) Political representation in Southern Europe and Latin America. Routledge, London, pp 34–49CrossRef Teperoglou E et al (2020) The study of political representation in Greece: towards new patterns following the economic crisis? In: Freire A et al (eds) Political representation in Southern Europe and Latin America. Routledge, London, pp 34–49CrossRef
Zurück zum Zitat Tushnet M (1992) Public law litigation and the ambiguities of Brown. Fordham Law Rev 61(1):23–28 Tushnet M (1992) Public law litigation and the ambiguities of Brown. Fordham Law Rev 61(1):23–28
Zurück zum Zitat Tushnet M (1999) Taking the constitution away from the courts. Princeton University Press, New Jersey Tushnet M (1999) Taking the constitution away from the courts. Princeton University Press, New Jersey
Zurück zum Zitat Tushnet M (2000) Politics, national identity, and the thin constitution. Univ Richmond Law Rev 34:545–566 Tushnet M (2000) Politics, national identity, and the thin constitution. Univ Richmond Law Rev 34:545–566
Metadaten
Titel
Rules of Standing and Populist Constitutionalism: The Case of the Greek Council of State
verfasst von
Dimitrios-Georgios Patsikas
Copyright-Jahr
2024
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-71889-2_9

Premium Partner