1 Introduction
2 Theoretical Background
2.1 Individual Knowledge Worker Archetypes
Dimension | Knowledge worker archetype | Supporting literature | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
9-to-5 Corporate worker | Digital Nomad | |||
Control | High organizational control | Self-organization and self-leadership | ||
Time | Fixed time schedules | Flexible; work-life blending | ||
Social Environment | Stability; social safety net | Dependency on environment; constant networking | ||
Technology | Standardized ICT use | Unconstrained technological choices | ||
Space | Fixed, immobile office space, company-owned | Fluctuating; shared (e.g. co-working spaces) or rented spaces (e.g. hotel rooms) | e.g., Ajzen and Taskin (2021) |
2.2 Identity Theory
3 Research Design
3.1 Data Collection
Expert | Age | Job | Whereabout at the time of the interview | Interview Length |
---|---|---|---|---|
E1-L1 | 32 | Online Marketing | Sweden | 1:27:17 |
E2-L1 | 34 | Consulting | Sweden | 1:27:17 |
E3-L2 | 40 | Marketing | Germany | 40:23 |
E4-L1 | 33 | Web-Design | Australia | 49:30 |
E5-L2 | 34 | Online Marketing | Germany | 55:57 |
E6-L2 | 23 | Social Media Manager | Germany | 40:41 |
E7-L1 | 25 | Finance | Ireland | 33:09 |
E8-L1 | 32 | Brand Manager | India | 29:06 |
E9-L1 | 33 | Finance | Colombia | 26:32 |
E10-L1 | 26 | Consulting | Bali | 28:03 |
E11-L1 | 24 | Finance | Bali | 26:45 |
E12-L2 | 24 | Online Marketing | Germany | 29:23 |
E13-L1 | 53 | IT-Development | Spain (Tenerife) | 50:01 |
E14-L1 | 32 | Marketing | Spain (Barcelona) | 45:03 |
3.2 Data Analysis and Coding Process
Main category | Subcategory | Statement | Summary | Expert |
---|---|---|---|---|
Investment | Job/Lifestyle Discrepancies | “…constant accessibility…” | Flexibility is good but company demands too much accessibility | E11-L1 |
Reward | Flexibility | “…a lot of freedom…” | Freedom through flexibility | E12-L2 |
4 Results
4.1 The Identity of Corporate Nomads
„So, the hierarchies are very flat; we are actually less managed rather in the sense that you are somehow a little bit steered in different directions maybe […] so that sometimes something is marked out or said yes maybe go in this or the other direction […], but actually the management interferes in almost nothing.“ (E5-L2)
“We have the core working time […] from nine to four […] in our team now I think we make it a bit flexible because there are also days where you must start later because you have […] two doctors appointments early and then, of course, I didn’t make it at nine. I think it’s good that it’s not seen quite so narrowly inside the team, and that’s important to me.” (E4-L1)
“Like I’m judged not based on the hours that I work for, based on the output of the projects that I’m working on. And so that’s like the biggest thing is that I should be available online, but I don’t have to be productive from nine to six.” (E7-L1)
“I wouldn’t want to change it. Of course, in some weeks, when there’s a bit more going on, you have a bit more stress. But you also have more relaxed weeks. And the advantage is that we have a very relaxed relationship at work, so if I have any important events in my private life or anything like that, I can always talk to my boss and get time off accordingly.” (E11-L1)
“I think that would be a bit difficult to implement in a company like this if everyone had different devices because we already use certain programs in a standardized way, and then somehow new software is introduced for everyone to use the telephone, for example, or something like that.” (E5-L2)
“Because I am a permanent employee and not a freelancer, I am very well covered, just like employees are covered, paid sick days um, I also have a company pension plan.” (E5-L2)
“I currently work 100% remotely and choose my working environment according to the weather and my mood. So, when the weather is nice, i.e., the last few days, I’ve been working 100% outside in the garden. Yes, and otherwise I work in any room where I like it, where I have my peace and it is quiet, but I’m not tied down. For example, I could sit down in a café or whatever. Exactly, I can work anywhere I have internet access.” (E3-L2)“We have a colleague who had the dream to travel through Europe with his campervan and work from anywhere. He also wanted to work only 3 days a week. That's what he proposed to us. And he is also a very good employee, [...] an A-player. Then you just have to fulfill all his wishes. We then decided at that time that he himself is responsible for making a successful project. He has now been in the van for a year.” (E14-L2)
4.2 Corporate Nomad Identity Issues
4.2.1 Issues of Investing in a Corporate Nomad Identity
“Exactly, no longer participating in the family is the worst thing. But that’s what gnaws at you a bit. My grandma and grandpa celebrated their 60th wedding anniversary recently we weren’t there either. That’s the kind of thing that gnaws at you a bit.” (E2-L1)
“Because if one of you somehow can no longer cope abroad or loses his job or whatever can happen, then you are faced with the decision of how to proceed. So, I think there can be difficulties.” (E12-L2)
“I actually think that I would have less motivation to work in the first few weeks, especially when you’re in a new place, you still want to experience a lot and do something, and you don’t want to be restricted by work. I think, therefore, the motivation first a little less. But I think, when you have found your way in your everyday life, it will come back again.” (E12-L2)
“I would say that the biggest disadvantage from my point of view is the, yes, constant accessibility, but at the same time, less contact with colleagues. Since you are working alone and if you are also alone at home, it could be that you feel lonely, and the little bit of social life is secondary.” (E10-L1)
4.2.2 Issues of Developing Self-esteem as a Corporate Nomad
“I used to think that I would have to give up work completely to be a mother.” (E7-L1)“[…] that you don't see the family. You don't just talk to your family on the phone for three or four hours. Especially when there are six people sitting on the other side, brothers and sisters with their partners and parents and grandparents. You can't have a quiet conversation there either.” (E1-L1)
“So, I’m more confident that I’ll be able to do both if I want to or if I want to work part-time or if I want to work flexibly and be able to drop my kids it’s not going to impact my career, so I think that’s been the biggest thing that I know that I won’t have to sacrifice what I’m doing to be a parent.” (E7-L1)
“Yes, I often get new tasks. Then I take time with a colleague who has already done the tasks. And we have a meeting via teams and share our screens and she then tries to familiarize me with the task. And then I still have time to work through it myself. And yes, that’s how it works for us. I actually see more of an advantage there, because I can take my time and make notes on it myself, rather than having someone sitting next to me in the office looking over my shoulder.” (E10-L1)
„I would perhaps like to have a bit more of a timeline, because it’s actually very, very flexible for us. That means my boss calls me today, says you can work later, and then I work later. And I say, so I often find it difficult to say no. So, most of the time, I jump, and maybe it would be advantageous to get a little bit more of a guideline. I´d prefer being stricter with myself and say no sometimes” (E11-L1)
4.2.3 Issues of Experiencing Rewards as a Result of a Corporate Nomad Identity
“This is a peculiar topic. We haven't actually had this problem yet, except with me. I sort of have a geo advantage now. I have my Amsterdam salary and I live in Barcelona. There the conditions are of course quite different (laughs). And if they had said they would cut my salary, I don't know if I would have stayed there. I am still the same person.” (E14-L1)
“I could imagine that other employers might actually pay more, because you also gain experience abroad and, once again, the company has greater added value through its internationality.” (E12-L2)
“If you compare it to other strict and bigger agencies, I would probably earn more but that’s just necessarily not where my priorities are.” (E5-L2)
“As I have just said, there is a weekly or every two weeks a meeting, where everyone then tells how it is going. I had for example my birthday, there was a meeting, a birthday meeting or yes, something like that is already endeavored there.” (E10-L1)
“So, I would probably never want to do a 100 percent office again in my life. If it were a model that said okay, two days, three days a week in the office and the rest of the time at home or you work or depending on how far away the office is, of course. But primarily, I would say no, if then only partially.” (E3-L2)
“I would choose remote because the flexibility is really pleasant. Especially when you’re young, you’re not bound to go to the office every day and always have this daily routine. When you’re at home and work at home, you can organize everything a bit more individually, whatever you want to do. Yes, I just like it better that I’m not tied to a certain place.” (E12-L1)
“In the office it can be very easy to get distracted like with people and chatting and all this kind of stuff so I definitely find like I’m probably more productive when I’m at home however I probably take fewer breaks so maybe it’s less stainable in the long term but I’m no I would say it’s very different. Would say in the office I’m definitely motivated but I definitely am more distracted by people.” (E7-L1)
5 Discussion
5.1 Towards a Conceptualization of the Corporate Nomad Archetype
Corporate nomads are permanent employees working location-independently by leveraging information technology. They differ from digital nomads in that they benefit from a robust social safety net and adhere to core working hours and standardized technology. They differ from 9–5 corporate workers in that they create their lifestyle and work environment according to individual preferences and democratic decisions in concert with superiors and co-workers |
5.2 Resolving Emergent Corporate Nomad Identity Issues
Identity verification outcome | Knowledge work dimension | Corporate nomad identity issues |
---|---|---|
Investment | Social/space | Social separation Spatial distance to work contacts Spatial distance to family members and other social contacts |
Space | Environmental distraction Self-responsibility to create a productive work environment outside of corporate premises | |
Time | Accessibility expectations Shifted working hours (e.g., across time zones) and missing detachment from onsite work boundaries | |
Self-esteem | Social | Holding multiple contradictory identities e.g., corporate 9–5 worker vs. digital nomad; corporate high achiever vs. stay-home parent |
Social/control | Disproportionate personal growth Developing skills and autonomy that surpass the requirement of previous work arrangement | |
Control/time | Flexibility paradox Increased freedom while feeling the urge to “do more” | |
Rewards | Control | Savings-salary gap Potential savings of the employer are not invested in corporate nomad employee |
Control/space | Point of no remote-return Non-acceptance of future onsite work arrangements by corporate nomads | |
Technology/space | Collaboration constraints Loss of informal exchange of information Gain of distraction-free work sessions |