Skip to main content
Top
Published in: Economic Change and Restructuring 6/2023

25-10-2023

Cyclical variation of fiscal multipliers in Caucasus and Central Asia economies: an empirical evidence

Authors: Syed Sadaqat Ali Shah, Muhammad Asim Afridi

Published in: Economic Change and Restructuring | Issue 6/2023

Log in

Activate our intelligent search to find suitable subject content or patents.

search-config
loading …

Abstract

This study estimates fiscal multipliers and assesses fiscal policy effectiveness in the Caucasus and Central Asia economies over the medium-term. Using (Jordà, Am Econ Rev 95:161–182, 2005) local projection model, the study finds that fiscal multipliers are indeed state-dependent and that fiscal policy is more effective and has stronger effects during recession than expansion. The study indicates that the timing and type of fiscal shock matter in assessing the effects on output growth. Also, the study finds that although fiscal sustainability holds during recession, it is not the case in oil importing Caucasus and Central Asia economies as a rise in public debt ratio in fact deteriorates fiscal balance of these economies by approximately 0.001–1.6 percent. The study shows that fiscal shocks during recessions heterogeneously affect output growth at different horizons. While the study finds that fiscal balance tends to effective during recession, a timely fiscal intervention across the Caucasus and Central Asia with an optimal mix of government consumption and investment needs to be policy priority in order to stimulate the output growth during the economic downturn.

Dont have a licence yet? Then find out more about our products and how to get one now:

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 102.000 Bücher
  • über 537 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Automobil + Motoren
  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Elektrotechnik + Elektronik
  • Energie + Nachhaltigkeit
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Maschinenbau + Werkstoffe
  • Versicherung + Risiko

Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 67.000 Bücher
  • über 340 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Versicherung + Risiko




Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Footnotes
1
DSGE models show that fiscal policy has stimulative effects in times of zero nominal interest rate constraints (see, Hall 2009; Eggertsson 2011).
 
2
From the World Economic Outlook eight economies form CCA region. Due to unavailability of data in case of Turkmenistan, we only have data on seven CCA economies; Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyz Republic, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan.
 
3
The study’s argument about the medium-term is based on past research of Dell’Erba et al., (2018) and Alichi et al., (2021). Dell’Erba et al., (2018) estimate fiscal multipliers over the 5-year horizon (or 20 quarterly forecast horizons) whereas Alichi et al., (2021) reports fiscal multipliers in the medium-term framework. Contrarily, we estimate 4- year forecast horizon (or 16 quarterly forecast horizons) across the CCA economies due to unavailability of long timeseries data.
 
4
Although local projection model is widely used in the empirical studies for estimating state-dependent effects of fiscal variables, the model has also attracted criticism. For details see Kilian and Kim (2011); Goncalves et al. (2022)
 
5
For details on exogeneity of fiscal shock variables, see Auerbach and Gorodnichenko (2013) and Alloza (2017).
 
6
Although the results are discussed in the medium-term perspective, the long-term fiscal multipliers (H = 8) are also estimated. The results, however, are available upon request.
 
7
Since the study aims to estimate fiscal multipliers over the medium-term, only multipliers for the four-year horizon are reported.
 
8
One exception here is the argument in the previous literature regarding the sign on tax multipliers. The past literature indicates that ignoring the sign and interpreting the tax multipliers in absolute terms, means that tax measures are more effective during expansionary times (Ramey 2019). The study does not go in that discussion because most of the estimates in the expansionary times are statistically insignificant.
 
Literature
go back to reference Abdih Y, Lopez-Murphy P, Roitman A, Sahay R (2010) The cyclicality of fiscal policy in the middle east and central Asia: is the current crisis different?. IMF Working Papers, (No. WP/10/68) Abdih Y, Lopez-Murphy P, Roitman A, Sahay R (2010) The cyclicality of fiscal policy in the middle east and central Asia: is the current crisis different?. IMF Working Papers, (No. WP/10/68)
go back to reference Abiad A, Almansour A, Furceri D, Granados CM, Topalova P (2014) Is it time for an infrastructure push? The macroeconomic effects of public investment. World Economic Outlook, pp.75–114 Abiad A, Almansour A, Furceri D, Granados CM, Topalova P (2014) Is it time for an infrastructure push? The macroeconomic effects of public investment. World Economic Outlook, pp.75–114
go back to reference Afonso A, Jalles JT (2017) Fiscal episodes and market power. Open Econ Rev 28:233–250CrossRef Afonso A, Jalles JT (2017) Fiscal episodes and market power. Open Econ Rev 28:233–250CrossRef
go back to reference Afonso A, Leal FS (2019) Fiscal multipliers in the Eurozone: an SVAR analysis. Appl Econ 51(51):5577–5593CrossRef Afonso A, Leal FS (2019) Fiscal multipliers in the Eurozone: an SVAR analysis. Appl Econ 51(51):5577–5593CrossRef
go back to reference Afonso A, Alves J, Jalles JT (2022) The (non-) Keynesian effects of fiscal austerity: New evidence from a large sample. Econ Syst 46(2):100981CrossRef Afonso A, Alves J, Jalles JT (2022) The (non-) Keynesian effects of fiscal austerity: New evidence from a large sample. Econ Syst 46(2):100981CrossRef
go back to reference Alichi A, Shibata I, Tanyeri K (2021) Fiscal policy multipliers in small states. Economía 21(2):69–114CrossRef Alichi A, Shibata I, Tanyeri K (2021) Fiscal policy multipliers in small states. Economía 21(2):69–114CrossRef
go back to reference Alinaghi N, Reed WR (2021) Taxes and economic growth in OECD countries: a meta-analysis. Public Finance Rev 49(1):3–40CrossRef Alinaghi N, Reed WR (2021) Taxes and economic growth in OECD countries: a meta-analysis. Public Finance Rev 49(1):3–40CrossRef
go back to reference Alloza M (2017). Is fiscal policy more effective in uncertain times or during recessions? (No. 1730). Banco de España Alloza M (2017). Is fiscal policy more effective in uncertain times or during recessions? (No. 1730). Banco de España
go back to reference Auerbach AJ, Gorodnichenko Y (2012) Fiscal multipliers in recession and expansion, in fiscal policy after the financial crisis. Natl Bureau Econ Res 63–98 Auerbach AJ, Gorodnichenko Y (2012) Fiscal multipliers in recession and expansion, in fiscal policy after the financial crisis. Natl Bureau Econ Res 63–98
go back to reference Auerbach AJ, Gorodnichenko Y (2013) Output spillovers from fiscal policy. Am Econ Rev 103(3):141–146CrossRef Auerbach AJ, Gorodnichenko Y (2013) Output spillovers from fiscal policy. Am Econ Rev 103(3):141–146CrossRef
go back to reference Bachmann R, Sims ER (2012) Confidence and the transmission of government spending shocks. J Monet Econ 59(3):235–249CrossRef Bachmann R, Sims ER (2012) Confidence and the transmission of government spending shocks. J Monet Econ 59(3):235–249CrossRef
go back to reference Barnichon R, Debortoli D, Matthes C (2022) Understanding the size of the government spending multiplier: it’s in the sign. Rev Econ Stud 89(1):87–117CrossRef Barnichon R, Debortoli D, Matthes C (2022) Understanding the size of the government spending multiplier: it’s in the sign. Rev Econ Stud 89(1):87–117CrossRef
go back to reference Barro RJ (1979) On the determination of the public debt. J Polit Econ, 87(5, Part 1):940–971 Barro RJ (1979) On the determination of the public debt. J Polit Econ, 87(5, Part 1):940–971
go back to reference Batini N, Callegari G, Melina G (2012). Successful Austerity in the United States, Europe and Japan (No. 2012/190). International Monetary Fund Batini N, Callegari G, Melina G (2012). Successful Austerity in the United States, Europe and Japan (No. 2012/190). International Monetary Fund
go back to reference Batini N, Eyraud L, Weber A, Forni L (2014) Fiscal Multipliers: Size, Determinants, and Use in Macroeconomic Projections (No. 2014/004). Int Monetary Fund Batini N, Eyraud L, Weber A, Forni L (2014) Fiscal Multipliers: Size, Determinants, and Use in Macroeconomic Projections (No. 2014/004). Int Monetary Fund
go back to reference Baum A, Koester GB (2011). The impact of fiscal policy on economic activity over the business cycle-evidence from a threshold VAR analysis (No. 2011, 03). Discussion Paper Series 1 Baum A, Koester GB (2011). The impact of fiscal policy on economic activity over the business cycle-evidence from a threshold VAR analysis (No. 2011, 03). Discussion Paper Series 1
go back to reference Baum A, Poplawski-Ribeiro M, Weber A (2012) Fiscal multipliers and the state of the economy. In: IMF Working Papers, 12(286), p 1 Baum A, Poplawski-Ribeiro M, Weber A (2012) Fiscal multipliers and the state of the economy. In: IMF Working Papers, 12(286), p 1
go back to reference Beetsma R, Giuliodori M, Klaassen F (2006) Trade spill-overs of fiscal policy in the European Union: a panel analysis. Econ Policy 21(48):640–687CrossRef Beetsma R, Giuliodori M, Klaassen F (2006) Trade spill-overs of fiscal policy in the European Union: a panel analysis. Econ Policy 21(48):640–687CrossRef
go back to reference Bernheim BD (1989) A neoclassical perspective on budget deficits. J Econ Perspect 3(2):55–72CrossRef Bernheim BD (1989) A neoclassical perspective on budget deficits. J Econ Perspect 3(2):55–72CrossRef
go back to reference Blanchard OJ, Leigh D (2014) Learning about fiscal multipliers from growth forecast errors. IMF Econ Rev 62(2):179–212CrossRef Blanchard OJ, Leigh D (2014) Learning about fiscal multipliers from growth forecast errors. IMF Econ Rev 62(2):179–212CrossRef
go back to reference Bredemeier C, Juessen F, Schabert A (2022) Why are fiscal multipliers moderate even under monetary accommodation? Eur Econ Rev 141:103970CrossRef Bredemeier C, Juessen F, Schabert A (2022) Why are fiscal multipliers moderate even under monetary accommodation? Eur Econ Rev 141:103970CrossRef
go back to reference Caldara D, Kamps C (2017) The analytics of SVARs: a unified framework to measure fiscal multipliers. Rev Econ Stud 84(3):1015–1040CrossRef Caldara D, Kamps C (2017) The analytics of SVARs: a unified framework to measure fiscal multipliers. Rev Econ Stud 84(3):1015–1040CrossRef
go back to reference Calderón C, Schmidt-Hebbel K (2008) The choice of fiscal regimes in the world (No. 487). Central Bank of Chile Calderón C, Schmidt-Hebbel K (2008) The choice of fiscal regimes in the world (No. 487). Central Bank of Chile
go back to reference Cavallari L, Romano S (2017) Fiscal policy in Europe: the importance of making it predictable. Econ Model 60:81–97CrossRef Cavallari L, Romano S (2017) Fiscal policy in Europe: the importance of making it predictable. Econ Model 60:81–97CrossRef
go back to reference Çebi C, Özdemir KA (2021) Cyclical variation of the fiscal multiplier in Turkey. Emerg Mark Financ Trade 57(2):495–509CrossRef Çebi C, Özdemir KA (2021) Cyclical variation of the fiscal multiplier in Turkey. Emerg Mark Financ Trade 57(2):495–509CrossRef
go back to reference Christiano L, Eichenbaum M, Rebelo S (2011) When is the government spending multiplier large? J Polit Econ 119(1):78–121CrossRef Christiano L, Eichenbaum M, Rebelo S (2011) When is the government spending multiplier large? J Polit Econ 119(1):78–121CrossRef
go back to reference Cloyne J, Jorda O, Taylor A (2020) Decomposing the Fiscal Multiplier (No. 14544). CEPR Discussion Papers Cloyne J, Jorda O, Taylor A (2020) Decomposing the Fiscal Multiplier (No. 14544). CEPR Discussion Papers
go back to reference Corsetti G, Meier A, Müller GJ (2012) What determines government spending multipliers? Econ Policy 27(72):521–565CrossRef Corsetti G, Meier A, Müller GJ (2012) What determines government spending multipliers? Econ Policy 27(72):521–565CrossRef
go back to reference Dell’Erba S, Koloskova K, Poplawski-Ribeiro M (2018) Medium-term fiscal multipliers during protracted economic contractions. J Macroecon 56:35–52CrossRef Dell’Erba S, Koloskova K, Poplawski-Ribeiro M (2018) Medium-term fiscal multipliers during protracted economic contractions. J Macroecon 56:35–52CrossRef
go back to reference Dime R, Ginting E, Zhuang J (2021) Estimating fiscal multipliers in selected Asian economies (No. 638). ADB Economics Working Paper Series Dime R, Ginting E, Zhuang J (2021) Estimating fiscal multipliers in selected Asian economies (No. 638). ADB Economics Working Paper Series
go back to reference Eggertsson GB (2011) What fiscal policy is effective at zero interest rates? NBER Macroecon Annu 25(1):59–112CrossRef Eggertsson GB (2011) What fiscal policy is effective at zero interest rates? NBER Macroecon Annu 25(1):59–112CrossRef
go back to reference Elkhdari M, Souissi M, Jewell A, Dauphin JF (2018) Empirical estimation of fiscal multipliers in MENA oil-exporting countries with an application to Algeria. In: IMF Working Papers, 2018(124) Elkhdari M, Souissi M, Jewell A, Dauphin JF (2018) Empirical estimation of fiscal multipliers in MENA oil-exporting countries with an application to Algeria. In: IMF Working Papers, 2018(124)
go back to reference Gobbin N, Van Aarle B (2001) Fiscal adjustments and their effects during the transition to the EMU. Public Choice 109(3–4):269–299CrossRef Gobbin N, Van Aarle B (2001) Fiscal adjustments and their effects during the transition to the EMU. Public Choice 109(3–4):269–299CrossRef
go back to reference Goncalves S, Herrera AM, Kilian L, Pesavento E (2022) When do state-dependent local projections work? (No. 17265). CEPR Discussion Papers Goncalves S, Herrera AM, Kilian L, Pesavento E (2022) When do state-dependent local projections work? (No. 17265). CEPR Discussion Papers
go back to reference Hall RE (2009) By how much does GDP rise if the government buys more output?. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 40(2 (Fall)), pp 183–249 Hall RE (2009) By how much does GDP rise if the government buys more output?. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 40(2 (Fall)), pp 183–249
go back to reference Horvath R, Kaszab L, Marsal A, Rabitsch K (2020) Determinants of fiscal multipliers revisited. J Macroecon 63:103162CrossRef Horvath R, Kaszab L, Marsal A, Rabitsch K (2020) Determinants of fiscal multipliers revisited. J Macroecon 63:103162CrossRef
go back to reference Hory MP (2016) Fiscal multipliers in emerging market economies: can we learn something from advanced economies? Int Econ 146:59–84CrossRef Hory MP (2016) Fiscal multipliers in emerging market economies: can we learn something from advanced economies? Int Econ 146:59–84CrossRef
go back to reference Huidrom R, Kose MA, Lim JJ, Ohnsorge FL (2020) Why do fiscal multipliers depend on fiscal Positions? J Monet Econ 114:109–125CrossRef Huidrom R, Kose MA, Lim JJ, Ohnsorge FL (2020) Why do fiscal multipliers depend on fiscal Positions? J Monet Econ 114:109–125CrossRef
go back to reference Huidrom R, Kose A, Lim J, Ohnsorge F (2016) ‘Do Fiscal Multipliers Depend on Fiscal Positions?’ World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 7724. Washington: World Bank Huidrom R, Kose A, Lim J, Ohnsorge F (2016) ‘Do Fiscal Multipliers Depend on Fiscal Positions?’ World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 7724. Washington: World Bank
go back to reference Ilzetzki E, Mendoza EG, Végh CA (2013) How big (small?) are fiscal multipliers? J Monet Econ 60(2):239–254CrossRef Ilzetzki E, Mendoza EG, Végh CA (2013) How big (small?) are fiscal multipliers? J Monet Econ 60(2):239–254CrossRef
go back to reference Inoue A, Wang Y (2022) Local Projections in Unstable Environments: How Effective is Fiscal Policy? (No. 17134). CEPR Discussion Papers Inoue A, Wang Y (2022) Local Projections in Unstable Environments: How Effective is Fiscal Policy? (No. 17134). CEPR Discussion Papers
go back to reference Jha S, Mallick SK, Park D, Quising PF (2014) Effectiveness of countercyclical fiscal policy: evidence from developing Asia. J Macroecon 40:82–98CrossRef Jha S, Mallick SK, Park D, Quising PF (2014) Effectiveness of countercyclical fiscal policy: evidence from developing Asia. J Macroecon 40:82–98CrossRef
go back to reference Jordà Ò (2005) Estimation and inference of impulse responses by local projections. Am Econ Rev 95(1):161–182CrossRef Jordà Ò (2005) Estimation and inference of impulse responses by local projections. Am Econ Rev 95(1):161–182CrossRef
go back to reference Kilian L, Kim YJ (2011) How reliable are local projection estimators of impulse responses? Rev Econ Stat 93(4):1460–1466CrossRef Kilian L, Kim YJ (2011) How reliable are local projection estimators of impulse responses? Rev Econ Stat 93(4):1460–1466CrossRef
go back to reference Kraay A (2012) How large is the government spending multiplier? Evidence from World Bank lending. Q J Econ 127(2):829–887CrossRef Kraay A (2012) How large is the government spending multiplier? Evidence from World Bank lending. Q J Econ 127(2):829–887CrossRef
go back to reference Kraay A (2014) Government spending multipliers in developing countries: evidence from lending by official creditors. Am Econ J Macroecon 6(4):170–208CrossRef Kraay A (2014) Government spending multipliers in developing countries: evidence from lending by official creditors. Am Econ J Macroecon 6(4):170–208CrossRef
go back to reference Merrino S. (2021) State-dependent fiscal multipliers and financial dynamics: An impulse response analysis by local projections for South Africa (No. 2021/77). WIDER Working Paper Merrino S. (2021) State-dependent fiscal multipliers and financial dynamics: An impulse response analysis by local projections for South Africa (No. 2021/77). WIDER Working Paper
go back to reference Nakata T (2016) Optimal fiscal and monetary policy with occasionally binding zero bound constraints. J Econ Dyn Control 73:220–240CrossRef Nakata T (2016) Optimal fiscal and monetary policy with occasionally binding zero bound constraints. J Econ Dyn Control 73:220–240CrossRef
go back to reference Ojeda-Joya JN, Guzman OE (2019) The size of fiscal multipliers and the stance of monetary policy in developing economies. Contemp Econ Policy 37(4):621–640CrossRef Ojeda-Joya JN, Guzman OE (2019) The size of fiscal multipliers and the stance of monetary policy in developing economies. Contemp Econ Policy 37(4):621–640CrossRef
go back to reference Owyang MT, Ramey VA, Zubairy S (2013) Are government spending multipliers greater during periods of slack? Evidence from twentieth-century historical data. Am Econ Rev 103(3):129–134CrossRef Owyang MT, Ramey VA, Zubairy S (2013) Are government spending multipliers greater during periods of slack? Evidence from twentieth-century historical data. Am Econ Rev 103(3):129–134CrossRef
go back to reference Ramey VA (2016) Macroeconomic shocks and their propagation. Handb Macroecon 2:71–162CrossRef Ramey VA (2016) Macroeconomic shocks and their propagation. Handb Macroecon 2:71–162CrossRef
go back to reference Ramey VA (2019) Ten years after the financial crisis: What have we learned from the renaissance in fiscal research? J Econ Perspect 33(2):89–114CrossRef Ramey VA (2019) Ten years after the financial crisis: What have we learned from the renaissance in fiscal research? J Econ Perspect 33(2):89–114CrossRef
go back to reference Ramey VA, Zubairy S (2018) Government spending multipliers in good times and in bad: evidence from US historical data. J Polit Econ 126(2):850–901CrossRef Ramey VA, Zubairy S (2018) Government spending multipliers in good times and in bad: evidence from US historical data. J Polit Econ 126(2):850–901CrossRef
go back to reference Shen W, Yang SCS (2018) Downward nominal wage rigidity and state-dependent government spending multipliers. J Monet Econ 98:11–26CrossRef Shen W, Yang SCS (2018) Downward nominal wage rigidity and state-dependent government spending multipliers. J Monet Econ 98:11–26CrossRef
go back to reference Sheremirov V, Spirovska S (2022) Fiscal multipliers in advanced and developing countries: evidence from military spending. J Public Econ 208:104631CrossRef Sheremirov V, Spirovska S (2022) Fiscal multipliers in advanced and developing countries: evidence from military spending. J Public Econ 208:104631CrossRef
go back to reference Tagkalakis A (2008) The effects of fiscal policy on consumption in recessions and expansions. J Public Econ 92(5–6):1486–1508CrossRef Tagkalakis A (2008) The effects of fiscal policy on consumption in recessions and expansions. J Public Econ 92(5–6):1486–1508CrossRef
go back to reference Vagliasindi M, Gorgulu N (2021) What have we learned about the effectiveness of infrastructure investment as a fiscal stimulus? A Literature Review. Policy Research Working Paper Series, 9796 Vagliasindi M, Gorgulu N (2021) What have we learned about the effectiveness of infrastructure investment as a fiscal stimulus? A Literature Review. Policy Research Working Paper Series, 9796
go back to reference Veld J (2016) Public investment stimulus in surplus countries and their euro area spillovers. European Commission Economic Brief, 16 Veld J (2016) Public investment stimulus in surplus countries and their euro area spillovers. European Commission Economic Brief, 16
go back to reference Whalen CJ, Reichling F (2015) The fiscal multiplier and economic policy analysis in the United States. Contemp Econ Policy 33(4):735–746CrossRef Whalen CJ, Reichling F (2015) The fiscal multiplier and economic policy analysis in the United States. Contemp Econ Policy 33(4):735–746CrossRef
go back to reference Yang W, Fidrmuc J, Ghosh S (2015) Macroeconomic effects of fiscal adjustment: a tale of two approaches. J Int Money Financ 57:31–60CrossRef Yang W, Fidrmuc J, Ghosh S (2015) Macroeconomic effects of fiscal adjustment: a tale of two approaches. J Int Money Financ 57:31–60CrossRef
go back to reference Yormirzoev M (2022) Economic growth and productivity performance in Central Asia. Comp Econ Stud 64(3):520–539CrossRef Yormirzoev M (2022) Economic growth and productivity performance in Central Asia. Comp Econ Stud 64(3):520–539CrossRef
Metadata
Title
Cyclical variation of fiscal multipliers in Caucasus and Central Asia economies: an empirical evidence
Authors
Syed Sadaqat Ali Shah
Muhammad Asim Afridi
Publication date
25-10-2023
Publisher
Springer US
Published in
Economic Change and Restructuring / Issue 6/2023
Print ISSN: 1573-9414
Electronic ISSN: 1574-0277
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10644-023-09566-w

Other articles of this Issue 6/2023

Economic Change and Restructuring 6/2023 Go to the issue

Premium Partner