Skip to main content
Top

2020 | OriginalPaper | Chapter

Evolving Narratives of Political Contestation and Geopolitical Rivalry in the Persian Gulf

Author : Kristian Coates Ulrichsen

Published in: Political Narratives in the Middle East and North Africa

Publisher: Springer International Publishing

Activate our intelligent search to find suitable subject content or patents.

search-config
loading …

Abstract

This chapter examines the interplay of hegemonic competition in the Persian Gulf between Saudi Arabia and Iran alongside the intra-Arab Gulf crises that have erupted since 2011. Regional rivalries between Saudi Arabia and Iran acquired a potent geopolitical dimension following the fall of the Shah in 1979. Whereas Iranian foreign policies moderated after the death of Ayatollah Khomeini in 1989, the narratives framed during the 1980s were hard to dislodge, even during the thaw in cross-waterway relations that occurred in the 1990s. The legacy of years of mutual mistrust became clear after the spread of the Arab uprisings in 2011. Both the Arab Gulf States’ responses to the so-called Arab Spring and the bitter disputes between the trio opposing Qatar illustrate how political narratives continue to polarise the Persian Gulf, albeit in subtly different ways.

Dont have a licence yet? Then find out more about our products and how to get one now:

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 102.000 Bücher
  • über 537 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Automobil + Motoren
  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Elektrotechnik + Elektronik
  • Energie + Nachhaltigkeit
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Maschinenbau + Werkstoffe
  • Versicherung + Risiko

Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 67.000 Bücher
  • über 340 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Versicherung + Risiko




Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Footnotes
1
Quoted in Nawaf Obaidi, ‘Stepping into Iraq: Saudi Arabia will Protect Sunnis if the US Leaves,’ Washington Post, November 29, 2006.
 
2
The author’s participation in a Bahrain-focused event at the Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) in March 2012.
 
Literature
go back to reference Agence France-Presse (2008) Defector accuses Iran of running sleeper cells in Gulf, September 16 Agence France-Presse (2008) Defector accuses Iran of running sleeper cells in Gulf, September 16
go back to reference Agence France-Presse (2012) Islamists Plot against Gulf, says Dubai Police Chief, March 25 Agence France-Presse (2012) Islamists Plot against Gulf, says Dubai Police Chief, March 25
go back to reference Al Jazeera (2018) Saudi Arabia women “arrested” in ongoing crackdown on activists, June 10 Al Jazeera (2018) Saudi Arabia women “arrested” in ongoing crackdown on activists, June 10
go back to reference Al-Hasan HT (2011) The role of Iran in the Failed Coup of 1981: the IFLB in Bahrain. Middle East J 65(4):603–617 Al-Hasan HT (2011) The role of Iran in the Failed Coup of 1981: the IFLB in Bahrain. Middle East J 65(4):603–617
go back to reference Al-Shayeji A (1997) Dangerous perceptions: Gulf views of the U.S. role in the region. Middle East Policy 5(1) Al-Shayeji A (1997) Dangerous perceptions: Gulf views of the U.S. role in the region. Middle East Policy 5(1)
go back to reference Alvandi R (2010) Muhammad Reza Pahlavi and the Bahrain question, 1968–1970. Br J Middle East Stud 37(2):159–177 Alvandi R (2010) Muhammad Reza Pahlavi and the Bahrain question, 1968–1970. Br J Middle East Stud 37(2):159–177
go back to reference Amnesty (2017) Gulf crisis: six months on, families still bearing brunt of Qatar political dispute, December 14 Amnesty (2017) Gulf crisis: six months on, families still bearing brunt of Qatar political dispute, December 14
go back to reference Asia Times (2006) Saudi Shi’ites: new light on an old divide. Interview by Mahan Abedin, October 26 Asia Times (2006) Saudi Shi’ites: new light on an old divide. Interview by Mahan Abedin, October 26
go back to reference Assiri A-R (1990) Kuwait’s foreign policy: city-state in world politics. Westview, Boulder Assiri A-R (1990) Kuwait’s foreign policy: city-state in world politics. Westview, Boulder
go back to reference Associated Press (2018) The princes, the president, and the fortune seekers, May 21 Associated Press (2018) The princes, the president, and the fortune seekers, May 21
go back to reference Baskan B (2012) The police chief and the Sheikh. Washington Rev Turk Eurasian Aff, April Baskan B (2012) The police chief and the Sheikh. Washington Rev Turk Eurasian Aff, April
go back to reference Bianco C, Stansfield G (2018) The intra-GCC crises: mapping GCC fragmentation after 2011. Int Aff 94(3):613–635 Bianco C, Stansfield G (2018) The intra-GCC crises: mapping GCC fragmentation after 2011. Int Aff 94(3):613–635
go back to reference Boghardt LP (2006) Kuwait amid war, peace, and revolution: 1979-91 and new challenges. Palgrave Macmillan, BasingstokeCrossRef Boghardt LP (2006) Kuwait amid war, peace, and revolution: 1979-91 and new challenges. Palgrave Macmillan, BasingstokeCrossRef
go back to reference Brew G (2015) “Our most dependable allies”: Iraq, Saudi Arabia, and the Eisenhower Doctrine, 1956-1958. Mediterr Q 26(4):89–109 Brew G (2015) “Our most dependable allies”: Iraq, Saudi Arabia, and the Eisenhower Doctrine, 1956-1958. Mediterr Q 26(4):89–109
go back to reference Buzan B (2008) Will the “global war on terrorism” be the new cold war. Int Aff 82(6):1101–1118 Buzan B (2008) Will the “global war on terrorism” be the new cold war. Int Aff 82(6):1101–1118
go back to reference Buzan B, Waever O, de Wilde J (1998) Security: a new framework for analysis. Lynne Rienner, Boulder Buzan B, Waever O, de Wilde J (1998) Security: a new framework for analysis. Lynne Rienner, Boulder
go back to reference Coates Ulrichsen K (2011a) Bahrain: evolution or revolution? Open Democr, March 1 Coates Ulrichsen K (2011a) Bahrain: evolution or revolution? Open Democr, March 1
go back to reference Coates Ulrichsen K (2011b) Gulf states: studious silence falls on Arab Spring. Open Democr, April 25 Coates Ulrichsen K (2011b) Gulf states: studious silence falls on Arab Spring. Open Democr, April 25
go back to reference Coates Ulrichsen K (2013) GCC-Iraq relations. In: Spencer C, Kinninmont J, Sirri O (eds) Iraq ten years on. Chatham House, London Coates Ulrichsen K (2013) GCC-Iraq relations. In: Spencer C, Kinninmont J, Sirri O (eds) Iraq ten years on. Chatham House, London
go back to reference Coates Ulrichsen K (2015) Why have the Gulf states intervened militarily in Yemen? Houston Chronicle, March 27 Coates Ulrichsen K (2015) Why have the Gulf states intervened militarily in Yemen? Houston Chronicle, March 27
go back to reference Coates Ulrichsen K (2017) Qatar: the Gulf’s problem child. Atlantic, June 5 Coates Ulrichsen K (2017) Qatar: the Gulf’s problem child. Atlantic, June 5
go back to reference Coates Ulrichsen K (2018) The Gulf Impasse’s one-year anniversary and the changing regional dynamics. Gulf Int Forum, May 30 Coates Ulrichsen K (2018) The Gulf Impasse’s one-year anniversary and the changing regional dynamics. Gulf Int Forum, May 30
go back to reference Davidson C (2006) The United Arab Emirates: a study in survival. Lynne Rienner, London Davidson C (2006) The United Arab Emirates: a study in survival. Lynne Rienner, London
go back to reference Davidson C (2008) Dubai: the vulnerability of success. Hurst, London Davidson C (2008) Dubai: the vulnerability of success. Hurst, London
go back to reference Dawn (2007) Attack on Iran: Kuwait won’t allow US to use its territory, June 12 Dawn (2007) Attack on Iran: Kuwait won’t allow US to use its territory, June 12
go back to reference Diwan K (2013) The politics of transgression in Kuwait. Foreign Policy, April 19 Diwan K (2013) The politics of transgression in Kuwait. Foreign Policy, April 19
go back to reference Entessar N (2017) A regional great game? Iran-Saudi relations in flux. In: Coates Ulrichsen K (ed) The changing security dynamics of the Persian Gulf. Hurst, London Entessar N (2017) A regional great game? Iran-Saudi relations in flux. In: Coates Ulrichsen K (ed) The changing security dynamics of the Persian Gulf. Hurst, London
go back to reference Furtig H (2007) Conflict and cooperation in the Persian Gulf: the interregional order and US policy. Middle East J 61(4):627–640 Furtig H (2007) Conflict and cooperation in the Persian Gulf: the interregional order and US policy. Middle East J 61(4):627–640
go back to reference Gaiser A (2017) A narrative identity approach to Islamic Sectarianism. In: Postel NHD (ed) Sectarianization: mapping the new identity politics of the Middle East. Hurst, London Gaiser A (2017) A narrative identity approach to Islamic Sectarianism. In: Postel NHD (ed) Sectarianization: mapping the new identity politics of the Middle East. Hurst, London
go back to reference Gulf States Newsletter (2011) Militant threat adds to pressures on Kuwait and Iraq over Mubarak Port Project. Gulf States Newsl 35(907):8–9 Gulf States Newsletter (2011) Militant threat adds to pressures on Kuwait and Iraq over Mubarak Port Project. Gulf States Newsl 35(907):8–9
go back to reference Gulf States Newsletter (2013) Qaradawi’s comments spark spat between UAE and Egypt. Gulf States Newsl 36(920):4 Gulf States Newsletter (2013) Qaradawi’s comments spark spat between UAE and Egypt. Gulf States Newsl 36(920):4
go back to reference Gulf Times (2008) Iran dismisses sleeper cell ‘lies’, September 17 Gulf Times (2008) Iran dismisses sleeper cell ‘lies’, September 17
go back to reference Gulf Times (2017) Qatar sympathizers to face fine, jail, June 7 Gulf Times (2017) Qatar sympathizers to face fine, jail, June 7
go back to reference Haddad F (2011) Sectarianism in Iraq: antagonistic visions of unity. Hurst, London Haddad F (2011) Sectarianism in Iraq: antagonistic visions of unity. Hurst, London
go back to reference Halliday F (2005) The Middle East in international relations: power, politics and ideology. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRef Halliday F (2005) The Middle East in international relations: power, politics and ideology. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRef
go back to reference Hardy R (2008) Ambivalent ally: Saudi Arabia and the ‘war on terror’. In: Al-Rasheed M (ed) Kingdom without borders: Saudi Arabia’s political, religious and media frontiers. Hurst, London Hardy R (2008) Ambivalent ally: Saudi Arabia and the ‘war on terror’. In: Al-Rasheed M (ed) Kingdom without borders: Saudi Arabia’s political, religious and media frontiers. Hurst, London
go back to reference Hashemi N, Postel D (eds) (2017) Sectarianization: mapping the new politics of the Middle East. Hurst, London Hashemi N, Postel D (eds) (2017) Sectarianization: mapping the new politics of the Middle East. Hurst, London
go back to reference Hiro D (2018) Cold war in the Islamic world: Saudi Arabia, Iran and the struggle for supremacy. Hurst, London Hiro D (2018) Cold war in the Islamic world: Saudi Arabia, Iran and the struggle for supremacy. Hurst, London
go back to reference Jones TC (2006) Rebellion on the Saudi periphery: modernization, marginalization, and the Shi’a uprising of 1979. Int J Middle East Stud 38(2):213–233 Jones TC (2006) Rebellion on the Saudi periphery: modernization, marginalization, and the Shi’a uprising of 1979. Int J Middle East Stud 38(2):213–233
go back to reference Jones J, Ridout N (2015) A history of modern Oman. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRef Jones J, Ridout N (2015) A history of modern Oman. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRef
go back to reference Katzman K (2008) Iran’s activities and influence in Iraq. Congressional Research Service Report for Congress, Washington, DC Katzman K (2008) Iran’s activities and influence in Iraq. Congressional Research Service Report for Congress, Washington, DC
go back to reference Kechichian J (2007) Can conservative Arab monarchies endure a fourth war in the Persian Gulf? Middle East J 61(2):283–306 Kechichian J (2007) Can conservative Arab monarchies endure a fourth war in the Persian Gulf? Middle East J 61(2):283–306
go back to reference Khaleej Times (2008) US wants Gulf States to impose curbs on Iran, December 14 Khaleej Times (2008) US wants Gulf States to impose curbs on Iran, December 14
go back to reference Kuwait Times (2012) Muslim brotherhood plans to take over Kuwait by 2013: Khalfan, April 18 Kuwait Times (2012) Muslim brotherhood plans to take over Kuwait by 2013: Khalfan, April 18
go back to reference Kwarten L (2009) Why the Saudi Shiites won’t rise up easily. A Conflicts Forum Monograph, Beirut Kwarten L (2009) Why the Saudi Shiites won’t rise up easily. A Conflicts Forum Monograph, Beirut
go back to reference Louer L (2008) Transnational Shia politics: religious and political networks in the Gulf. Hurst, London Louer L (2008) Transnational Shia politics: religious and political networks in the Gulf. Hurst, London
go back to reference Louer L (2012) Shiism and politics in the Middle East. Columbia University Press, New York Louer L (2012) Shiism and politics in the Middle East. Columbia University Press, New York
go back to reference Matthiesen T (2012) A “Saudi Spring”? The Shi’a protest movement in the Eastern Province 2011–2012. Middle East J 66(4):628–659 Matthiesen T (2012) A “Saudi Spring”? The Shi’a protest movement in the Eastern Province 2011–2012. Middle East J 66(4):628–659
go back to reference Matthiesen T (2015) The other Saudis: Shiism, dissent and sectarianism. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Matthiesen T (2015) The other Saudis: Shiism, dissent and sectarianism. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
go back to reference Mazur K (2009) The “Shia Crescent” and Arab State Legitimacy. SAIS Rev Int Aff 29(2):21–22 Mazur K (2009) The “Shia Crescent” and Arab State Legitimacy. SAIS Rev Int Aff 29(2):21–22
go back to reference Meyer K, Rizzo H, Ali Y (2007) Changed political attitudes: the case of Kuwait. Int Sociol 22(3):289–324 Meyer K, Rizzo H, Ali Y (2007) Changed political attitudes: the case of Kuwait. Int Sociol 22(3):289–324
go back to reference Miller R (2016) Desert kingdoms to global powers: the rise of the Arab Gulf. Yale University Press, New Haven Miller R (2016) Desert kingdoms to global powers: the rise of the Arab Gulf. Yale University Press, New Haven
go back to reference Mühlberger W (2017) Qatar Engulfed: tactical steps raise stakes in protracted crisis. Finnish Institute of International Affairs Comment Paper 18/2017, September Mühlberger W (2017) Qatar Engulfed: tactical steps raise stakes in protracted crisis. Finnish Institute of International Affairs Comment Paper 18/2017, September
go back to reference National Geographic (2003) Qatar: revolution from the top down, March issue National Geographic (2003) Qatar: revolution from the top down, March issue
go back to reference New York Times (2006) Tide of Arab opinion turns to support for Hezbollah, July 28 New York Times (2006) Tide of Arab opinion turns to support for Hezbollah, July 28
go back to reference New York Times (2007) Saudi king condemns US occupation of Iraq, March 28 New York Times (2007) Saudi king condemns US occupation of Iraq, March 28
go back to reference New York Times (2018) How 2 Gulf monarchies sought to influence the White House, March 21 New York Times (2018) How 2 Gulf monarchies sought to influence the White House, March 21
go back to reference Nonneman G (2004) The Gulf States and the Iran-Iraq War: pattern shifts and continuities. In: Potter L, Sick G (eds) Iran, Iraq, and the legacies of war. Palgrave Macmillan, New York Nonneman G (2004) The Gulf States and the Iran-Iraq War: pattern shifts and continuities. In: Potter L, Sick G (eds) Iran, Iraq, and the legacies of war. Palgrave Macmillan, New York
go back to reference Reuters (2010) “Cut off head of snake” Saudis told US on Iran, November 28 Reuters (2010) “Cut off head of snake” Saudis told US on Iran, November 28
go back to reference Sager A (2008) The GCC states and the situation in Iraq. Gulf Research Centre, Dubai Sager A (2008) The GCC states and the situation in Iraq. Gulf Research Centre, Dubai
go back to reference Schwarz B (2007) America’s struggle against the Wahhabi/Neo-Salafi movement. Orbis 51(1):107–128 Schwarz B (2007) America’s struggle against the Wahhabi/Neo-Salafi movement. Orbis 51(1):107–128
go back to reference Stephens M (2017) The Arab cold war redux: the foreign policy of the Gulf cooperation council states since 2011. The Century Foundation, February 28 Stephens M (2017) The Arab cold war redux: the foreign policy of the Gulf cooperation council states since 2011. The Century Foundation, February 28
go back to reference The Guardian (2010) US Embassy cables: Qatar Prime Minister: “Iranians Lie to Us”, November 28 The Guardian (2010) US Embassy cables: Qatar Prime Minister: “Iranians Lie to Us”, November 28
go back to reference The National (2014) UAE recalls envoy from Qatar over “interference”, March 5 The National (2014) UAE recalls envoy from Qatar over “interference”, March 5
go back to reference The National (2017) Qatar should stop funding terrorism, says leading opposition figure, June 3 The National (2017) Qatar should stop funding terrorism, says leading opposition figure, June 3
go back to reference Times of Israel (2012) Qatar: we won’t allow attack on Iran from our soil, March 28 Times of Israel (2012) Qatar: we won’t allow attack on Iran from our soil, March 28
go back to reference Tripp C (2002) The foreign policy of Iraq. In: Hinnebusch R, Ehteshami A (eds) The foreign policies of Middle East States. Lynne Rienner, London Tripp C (2002) The foreign policy of Iraq. In: Hinnebusch R, Ehteshami A (eds) The foreign policies of Middle East States. Lynne Rienner, London
go back to reference Visser R (2007) ‘Basra, the reluctant seat of ‘Shiastan’. Middle East Rep 242 37(1):23 Visser R (2007) ‘Basra, the reluctant seat of ‘Shiastan’. Middle East Rep 242 37(1):23
go back to reference Wall Street Journal (2018) Push to execute Saudi clerics rattles kingdom’s power structures, September 16 Wall Street Journal (2018) Push to execute Saudi clerics rattles kingdom’s power structures, September 16
go back to reference Washington Post (2006) Stepping into Iraq: Saudi Arabia will protect Sunnis if the US leaves, November 29 Washington Post (2006) Stepping into Iraq: Saudi Arabia will protect Sunnis if the US leaves, November 29
go back to reference Washington Post (2018) A plague of Twitter bots is roiling the Middle East, June 5 Washington Post (2018) A plague of Twitter bots is roiling the Middle East, June 5
go back to reference Washington Times (2011) No Iranian role found in Bahrain unrest, November 23 Washington Times (2011) No Iranian role found in Bahrain unrest, November 23
go back to reference World Tribune (2008) Senior Iran official predicts imminent demise of Gulf State royals, August 15 World Tribune (2008) Senior Iran official predicts imminent demise of Gulf State royals, August 15
go back to reference Yamani M (2006) Arcs and crescents. World Today 62(12):7–8 Yamani M (2006) Arcs and crescents. World Today 62(12):7–8
Metadata
Title
Evolving Narratives of Political Contestation and Geopolitical Rivalry in the Persian Gulf
Author
Kristian Coates Ulrichsen
Copyright Year
2020
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-35217-2_5