Skip to main content
Top

Hint

Swipe to navigate through the articles of this issue

Published in: Journal of Economics and Finance 4/2020

22-01-2020

Financial market risk and macroeconomic stability variables: dynamic interactions and feedback effects

Authors: Agnieszka M. Chomicz-Grabowska, Lucjan T. Orlowski

Published in: Journal of Economics and Finance | Issue 4/2020

Login to get access
share
SHARE

Abstract

This study investigates dynamic interactions and feedback effects between financial market risk proxied by VIX and key macroeconomic stability variables that include the rate of unemployment, headline inflation and market-based inflation expectations reflected by the breakeven inflation. We argue that market risk should play a stronger role in macroeconomic modeling and forecasting than it has been recognized thus far in the literature. We employ vector autoregression with impulse response functions, as well as two-state Markov switching tests to examine these interactions on the longest available US monthly data. The empirical tests show that the association between market risk and macroeconomic fundamentals is predominantly neutral at normal, predictable economic conditions. It becomes very pronounced at times of financial distress, in the environment of elevated market risk coupled with uncertain expectations for macroeconomic variables. Shocks in VIX have a longer impact on macroeconomic stability than that generally claimed in the prior literature. The Markov switching tests for CPI and breakeven inflation indicate that households and businesses are concerned primarily about episodes of increasing inflation, while bond market participants worry mainly about declining inflation and deflation.
Footnotes
1
See for instance Thorbecke 1997; Cunningham et al. 2010; Söderlind 2011; Christensen and Gillan 2012; Fleckenstein et al. 2017; Orlowski and Soper 2019.
 
2
In consistency with Fleckenstein et al. (2017), Andreasen et al. (2018) and D’Amico et al. (2018), we recognize that BEI does not only reflect real-time inflation expectations. It also contains a liquidity premium of TIPS. They all provide evidence that the liquidity premium of TIPS is sizeable and countercyclical, as investors anticipating economic recovery and higher inflation buy and hold TIPS reducing their availability for trading. Because of their weaker market liquidity, the prices of TIPS are then penalized with a discount known as a liquidity premium that reflects the present value of expected future trading costs as well as compensation for being forced to sell the bond at a discount. Such forced selling increases TIPS yields and complicates inflation expectations inferred from BEI.
 
3
The Augmented Dickey Fuller unit root tests indicate stationarity of all tested variables at their levels, except for the CPI inflation. The estimated ADF τ-statistics are: −4.27 for VIX, −2.98 for the unemployment rate, −2.84 for CPI year-on-year inflation rate, −4.04 for 5-year BEI and − 3.94 for 10-year BEI. The McKinnon critical values at 5% are between −2.87 and − 2.88 for the examined sample periods.
 
Literature
go back to reference Andreasen MM, Christensen JHE, Riddell S (2018) The TIPS liquidity premium. Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco – working paper 2017-11 Andreasen MM, Christensen JHE, Riddell S (2018) The TIPS liquidity premium. Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco – working paper 2017-11
go back to reference Christensen J, Gillan J (2012) Do Fed TIPS purchases affect market liquidity? Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco – economic letter no. 2012-07 Christensen J, Gillan J (2012) Do Fed TIPS purchases affect market liquidity? Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco – economic letter no. 2012-07
go back to reference Cunningham R, Desroches B, Santor E (2010) Inflation expectations and the conduct of monetary policy: a review of recent evidence and experience. Bank of Canada Review, Spring pp:13–25 Cunningham R, Desroches B, Santor E (2010) Inflation expectations and the conduct of monetary policy: a review of recent evidence and experience. Bank of Canada Review, Spring pp:13–25
go back to reference D’Amico S, Kim DH, Wei M (2018) Tips from TIPS: the informational content of Treasury inflation-protected security prices. J Financ Quant Anal 53(1):395–436 CrossRef D’Amico S, Kim DH, Wei M (2018) Tips from TIPS: the informational content of Treasury inflation-protected security prices. J Financ Quant Anal 53(1):395–436 CrossRef
go back to reference Fleckenstein M, Longstaff FA, Lustig H (2017) Deflation risk. Rev Financ Stud 30(8):2719–2760 CrossRef Fleckenstein M, Longstaff FA, Lustig H (2017) Deflation risk. Rev Financ Stud 30(8):2719–2760 CrossRef
go back to reference Fleming MJ, Krishnan N (2012) The microstructure of the TIPS market. Federal Reserve Bank of New York – Economic Policy Review 18(1):27–45 Fleming MJ, Krishnan N (2012) The microstructure of the TIPS market. Federal Reserve Bank of New York – Economic Policy Review 18(1):27–45
go back to reference Güler MH, Keles G, Polat T (2017) An empirical decomposition of the liquidity premium in breakeven inflation rates. Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance 63(1):185–192 CrossRef Güler MH, Keles G, Polat T (2017) An empirical decomposition of the liquidity premium in breakeven inflation rates. Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance 63(1):185–192 CrossRef
go back to reference Kim D, Walsh C, Wei M (2019) Tips from TIPS: update and discussion. The Federal Reserve Board of Governors – Fed Notes Kim D, Walsh C, Wei M (2019) Tips from TIPS: update and discussion. The Federal Reserve Board of Governors – Fed Notes
go back to reference Lütkepohl H, Netšunajev A (2018) The relation between monetary policy and the stock market in Europe. DIW Berlin – discussion paper no. 1729 Lütkepohl H, Netšunajev A (2018) The relation between monetary policy and the stock market in Europe. DIW Berlin – discussion paper no. 1729
go back to reference Netšunajev A, Winkelmann L (2014) Inflation expectations spillovers between the United States and euro area. Free University Berlin – SFB 649 discussion paper no. 23 Netšunajev A, Winkelmann L (2014) Inflation expectations spillovers between the United States and euro area. Free University Berlin – SFB 649 discussion paper no. 23
go back to reference Orlowski LT (2012) Financial crisis and extreme market risks: evidence from Europe. Rev Financ Econ 21(3):120–130 CrossRef Orlowski LT (2012) Financial crisis and extreme market risks: evidence from Europe. Rev Financ Econ 21(3):120–130 CrossRef
go back to reference Orlowski LT, Soper C (2019) Market risk and market-implied inflation expectations. International Review of Financial Analysis 66, No. 101389 Orlowski LT, Soper C (2019) Market risk and market-implied inflation expectations. International Review of Financial Analysis 66, No. 101389
go back to reference Putnam BH, Norland E, Arasu KT (2018) Economics gone astray. World Scientific Publishing, Hackensack Putnam BH, Norland E, Arasu KT (2018) Economics gone astray. World Scientific Publishing, Hackensack
go back to reference Söderlind P (2011) Inflation risk premia and survey evidence on macroeconomic uncertainty. Int J Cent Bank 7(2):113–133 Söderlind P (2011) Inflation risk premia and survey evidence on macroeconomic uncertainty. Int J Cent Bank 7(2):113–133
go back to reference Stillwagon JR (2018) TIPS and the VIX: spillovers from financial panic to breakeven inflation in an automated nonlinear modeling framework. Oxf Bull Econ Stat 80(2):218–235 CrossRef Stillwagon JR (2018) TIPS and the VIX: spillovers from financial panic to breakeven inflation in an automated nonlinear modeling framework. Oxf Bull Econ Stat 80(2):218–235 CrossRef
go back to reference Strohsal T, Winkelmann L (2015) Assessing the anchoring of inflation expectations. J Int Money Financ 50(1):33–48 CrossRef Strohsal T, Winkelmann L (2015) Assessing the anchoring of inflation expectations. J Int Money Financ 50(1):33–48 CrossRef
go back to reference Thorbecke W (1997) On the stock market and monetary policy. J Financ 52(2):635–654 CrossRef Thorbecke W (1997) On the stock market and monetary policy. J Financ 52(2):635–654 CrossRef
go back to reference Zeng Z (2013) New tips from TIPS: identifying inflation expectations and the risk premia of breakeven inflation. Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance 53(2):125–139 CrossRef Zeng Z (2013) New tips from TIPS: identifying inflation expectations and the risk premia of breakeven inflation. Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance 53(2):125–139 CrossRef
Metadata
Title
Financial market risk and macroeconomic stability variables: dynamic interactions and feedback effects
Authors
Agnieszka M. Chomicz-Grabowska
Lucjan T. Orlowski
Publication date
22-01-2020
Publisher
Springer US
Published in
Journal of Economics and Finance / Issue 4/2020
Print ISSN: 1055-0925
Electronic ISSN: 1938-9744
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12197-020-09505-9

Other articles of this Issue 4/2020

Journal of Economics and Finance 4/2020 Go to the issue

Premium Partner