Skip to main content
Top
Published in: Experiments in Fluids 6/2020

01-06-2020 | Research Article

Systematic errors in mixing measurements using filtered Rayleigh scattering in supersonic flows

Authors: Vijay Gopal, Luca Maddalena

Published in: Experiments in Fluids | Issue 6/2020

Log in

Activate our intelligent search to find suitable subject content or patents.

search-config
loading …

Abstract

When performing non-reacting mixing enhancement experimental studies in supersonic flow, helium is often used as an injectant which serves as a simulant gas for hydrogen fuel. The resulting distribution of helium mole fraction in the binary mixture of air and helium can be quantified using filtered Rayleigh scattering (FRS). The FRS technique requires two independent experiments in supersonic flow, one with helium injection and the other with air injection. The helium mole fraction is retrieved under the key assumptions that the number density profiles and the extent of the Doppler shift that is associated with each of the two independent experiments at the measuring plane are identically the same. This work is centered on the analysis of the impact of a departure from the aforementioned assumptions with the aid of a reduced-order model developed for a canonical rectangular jet in supersonic flow. The results, derived from the implementation of the model, are used to identify key driving phenomena that concurrently contribute to violate the key assumptions and are compared and discussed in the light of available experimental data. Additionally, the analysis suggests that the newly developed model can be used in the design of FRS experiments by minimizing the extent of mismatch in the number density profile and thus reducing the systematic bias error associated with the mixture’s composition measurements.

Graphic abstract

Dont have a licence yet? Then find out more about our products and how to get one now:

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 102.000 Bücher
  • über 537 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Automobil + Motoren
  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Elektrotechnik + Elektronik
  • Energie + Nachhaltigkeit
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Maschinenbau + Werkstoffe
  • Versicherung + Risiko

Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Springer Professional "Technik"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Technik" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 67.000 Bücher
  • über 390 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Automobil + Motoren
  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Elektrotechnik + Elektronik
  • Energie + Nachhaltigkeit
  • Maschinenbau + Werkstoffe




 

Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Literature
go back to reference Allison PM, McManus TA, Sutton JA (2016) Quantitative fuel vapor/air mixing imaging in droplet/gas regions of an evaporating spray flow using filtered rayleigh scattering. Opt Lett 41(6):1074–1077 Allison PM, McManus TA, Sutton JA (2016) Quantitative fuel vapor/air mixing imaging in droplet/gas regions of an evaporating spray flow using filtered rayleigh scattering. Opt Lett 41(6):1074–1077
go back to reference Anderson JD, Wendt J (1995) Computational fluid dynamics, vol 206. Springer, Berlin Anderson JD, Wendt J (1995) Computational fluid dynamics, vol 206. Springer, Berlin
go back to reference Arnberg B, Britton C, Seidl W (1974) Discharge coefficient correlations for circular-arc venturi flowmeters at critical (sonic) flow. J Fluids Eng 96(2):111–123 Arnberg B, Britton C, Seidl W (1974) Discharge coefficient correlations for circular-arc venturi flowmeters at critical (sonic) flow. J Fluids Eng 96(2):111–123
go back to reference Barber MJ, Schetz JA, Roe LA (1997) Normal, sonic helium injection through a wedge-shaped orifice into supersonic flow. J Propul Power 13(2):257–263 Barber MJ, Schetz JA, Roe LA (1997) Normal, sonic helium injection through a wedge-shaped orifice into supersonic flow. J Propul Power 13(2):257–263
go back to reference Billig FS (1993) Research on supersonic combustion. J Propul Power 9(4):499–514 Billig FS (1993) Research on supersonic combustion. J Propul Power 9(4):499–514
go back to reference Boguszko M, Elliott G (2004) Measurements in fluid flows using molecular filter-based techniques. In: 42nd AIAA aerospace sciences meeting and exhibit, p 18 Boguszko M, Elliott G (2004) Measurements in fluid flows using molecular filter-based techniques. In: 42nd AIAA aerospace sciences meeting and exhibit, p 18
go back to reference Boguszko M, Elliott GS (2005) On the use of filtered rayleigh scattering for measurements in compressible flows and thermal fields. Exp Fluids 38(1):33–49 Boguszko M, Elliott GS (2005) On the use of filtered rayleigh scattering for measurements in compressible flows and thermal fields. Exp Fluids 38(1):33–49
go back to reference Boyd RW (2003) Nonlinear optics. Elsevier, New York Boyd RW (2003) Nonlinear optics. Elsevier, New York
go back to reference Charrier L, Pont G, Marie S, Brenner P, Grasso F (2017) Simulation of a supersonic coaxial he/air jet experiment with a hybrid rans/les variable turbulent schmidt number model. In: 23rd AIAA computational fluid dynamics conference, p 4280 Charrier L, Pont G, Marie S, Brenner P, Grasso F (2017) Simulation of a supersonic coaxial he/air jet experiment with a hybrid rans/les variable turbulent schmidt number model. In: 23rd AIAA computational fluid dynamics conference, p 4280
go back to reference Donaldson CD, Gray K (1966) Theoretical and experimental investigation of the compressible free mixing of two dissimilar gases. AIAA J 4(11):2017–2025 Donaldson CD, Gray K (1966) Theoretical and experimental investigation of the compressible free mixing of two dissimilar gases. AIAA J 4(11):2017–2025
go back to reference Elliot G, Boguszko M, Carter C (2001) Filtered rayleigh scattering-toward multiple property measurements. In: 39th aerospace sciences meeting and exhibit, p 301 Elliot G, Boguszko M, Carter C (2001) Filtered rayleigh scattering-toward multiple property measurements. In: 39th aerospace sciences meeting and exhibit, p 301
go back to reference Ferri A (1973) Mixing-controlled supersonic combustion. Annual Rev Fluid Mech 5(1):301–338 Ferri A (1973) Mixing-controlled supersonic combustion. Annual Rev Fluid Mech 5(1):301–338
go back to reference Forkey J, Finkelstein N, Lempert W, Miles R (1996) Demonstration and characterization of filtered rayleigh scattering for planar velocity measurements. AIAA J 34(3):442–448 Forkey J, Finkelstein N, Lempert W, Miles R (1996) Demonstration and characterization of filtered rayleigh scattering for planar velocity measurements. AIAA J 34(3):442–448
go back to reference Gatski TB, Bonnet JP (2013) Compressibility, turbulence and high speed flow. Academic Press, Cambridge Gatski TB, Bonnet JP (2013) Compressibility, turbulence and high speed flow. Academic Press, Cambridge
go back to reference Glawe D, Donbar J, Nejad A, Sekar B, Chen T, Samimy M, Driscoll J (1994) Parallel fuel injection from the base of an extended strut into supersonic flow. American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics, New York Glawe D, Donbar J, Nejad A, Sekar B, Chen T, Samimy M, Driscoll J (1994) Parallel fuel injection from the base of an extended strut into supersonic flow. American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics, New York
go back to reference Ground C, Vergine F, Maddalena L (2016) The effect of vortex merging and non-merging on the transfer of modal turbulent kinetic energy content. Exp Fluids 57(8):131MATH Ground C, Vergine F, Maddalena L (2016) The effect of vortex merging and non-merging on the transfer of modal turbulent kinetic energy content. Exp Fluids 57(8):131MATH
go back to reference Ground C, Viganó D, Maddalena L (2018a) Comparison of intrusive and non-intrusive mixture composition measurements in supersonic flow. J Propul Power 34(6):1574–1585 Ground C, Viganó D, Maddalena L (2018a) Comparison of intrusive and non-intrusive mixture composition measurements in supersonic flow. J Propul Power 34(6):1574–1585
go back to reference Ground CR, Gopal V, Maddalena L (2018b) Filtered rayleigh scattering mixing measurements of merging and non-merging streamwise vortex interactions in supersonic flow. Exp Fluids 59(4):67 Ground CR, Gopal V, Maddalena L (2018b) Filtered rayleigh scattering mixing measurements of merging and non-merging streamwise vortex interactions in supersonic flow. Exp Fluids 59(4):67
go back to reference Gutmark E, Schadow K, Yu K (1995) Mixing enhancement in supersonic free shear flows. Annual Rev Fluid Mech 27(1):375–417 Gutmark E, Schadow K, Yu K (1995) Mixing enhancement in supersonic free shear flows. Annual Rev Fluid Mech 27(1):375–417
go back to reference Hirschel EH et al (2005) Basics of aerothermodynamics. Springer, Berlin Hirschel EH et al (2005) Basics of aerothermodynamics. Springer, Berlin
go back to reference Javed A, Rajan N, Chakraborty D (2015) Behaviour of turbulent prandtl/schmidt number in compressible mixing layer. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part G J Aerosp Eng 229(7):1349–1359 Javed A, Rajan N, Chakraborty D (2015) Behaviour of turbulent prandtl/schmidt number in compressible mixing layer. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part G J Aerosp Eng 229(7):1349–1359
go back to reference Kearney S, Beresh S, Grasser T (2003) A filtered rayleigh scattering instrument for gas-phase and combustion temperature imaging. In: 41st Aerospace sciences meeting and exhibit, p 584 Kearney S, Beresh S, Grasser T (2003) A filtered rayleigh scattering instrument for gas-phase and combustion temperature imaging. In: 41st Aerospace sciences meeting and exhibit, p 584
go back to reference Kearney S, Beresh S, Grasser T, Schefer R (2004) Filtered rayleigh scattering thermometry in vortex-strained and sooting flames. In: 42nd AIAA aerospace sciences meeting and exhibit, p 1358 Kearney S, Beresh S, Grasser T, Schefer R (2004) Filtered rayleigh scattering thermometry in vortex-strained and sooting flames. In: 42nd AIAA aerospace sciences meeting and exhibit, p 1358
go back to reference Kwok F, Andrew P, Ng W, Schetz J (1991) Experimental investigation of a supersonic shear layer with slot injection of helium. AIAA J 29(9):1426–1435 Kwok F, Andrew P, Ng W, Schetz J (1991) Experimental investigation of a supersonic shear layer with slot injection of helium. AIAA J 29(9):1426–1435
go back to reference Maddalena L, Vergine F, Crisanti M (2014) Vortex dynamics studies in supersonic flow: merging of co-rotating streamwise vortices. Phys Fluids 26:046101 Maddalena L, Vergine F, Crisanti M (2014) Vortex dynamics studies in supersonic flow: merging of co-rotating streamwise vortices. Phys Fluids 26:046101
go back to reference Mcmanus TA, Monje IT, Sutton JA (2019) Experimental assessment of the tenti s6 model for combustion-relevant gases and filtered rayleigh scattering applications. Appl Phys B 125(1):13 Mcmanus TA, Monje IT, Sutton JA (2019) Experimental assessment of the tenti s6 model for combustion-relevant gases and filtered rayleigh scattering applications. Appl Phys B 125(1):13
go back to reference Miles R, Lempert W, Forkey J (1991) Instantaneous velocity fields and background suppression by filteredrayleigh scattering. In: 29th Aerospace sciences meeting, p 357 Miles R, Lempert W, Forkey J (1991) Instantaneous velocity fields and background suppression by filteredrayleigh scattering. In: 29th Aerospace sciences meeting, p 357
go back to reference Miles RB, Lempert WR, Forkey JN (2001) Laser rayleigh scattering. Measur Sci Technol 12(5):R33 Miles RB, Lempert WR, Forkey JN (2001) Laser rayleigh scattering. Measur Sci Technol 12(5):R33
go back to reference Miller M, Bowman C, Mungal M (1998) An experimental investigation of the effects of compressibility on a turbulent reacting mixing layer. J Fluid Mech 356:25–64 Miller M, Bowman C, Mungal M (1998) An experimental investigation of the effects of compressibility on a turbulent reacting mixing layer. J Fluid Mech 356:25–64
go back to reference Murakami E, Papamoschou D (2000) Mixing layer characteristics of coaxial supersonic jets. In: 6th Aeroacoustics conference and exhibit, p 2060 Murakami E, Papamoschou D (2000) Mixing layer characteristics of coaxial supersonic jets. In: 6th Aeroacoustics conference and exhibit, p 2060
go back to reference Pan X, Shneider MN, Miles RB (2004) Coherent rayleigh-brillouin scattering in molecular gases. Phys Rev A 69(3):033814 Pan X, Shneider MN, Miles RB (2004) Coherent rayleigh-brillouin scattering in molecular gases. Phys Rev A 69(3):033814
go back to reference Patel RP (1978) Effects of stream turbulence on free shear flows. Aeron Q 29(1):33–43 Patel RP (1978) Effects of stream turbulence on free shear flows. Aeron Q 29(1):33–43
go back to reference Reynolds A (1976) The variation of turbulent prandtl and schmidt numbers in wakes and jets. Int J Heat Mass Transfer 19(7):757–764 Reynolds A (1976) The variation of turbulent prandtl and schmidt numbers in wakes and jets. Int J Heat Mass Transfer 19(7):757–764
go back to reference Rudy DH, Bushnell DM (1973) A rational approach to the use of prandtl’s mixing length model in free turbulent shear flow calculations. Technical Report NASA-SP-321 Rudy DH, Bushnell DM (1973) A rational approach to the use of prandtl’s mixing length model in free turbulent shear flow calculations. Technical Report NASA-SP-321
go back to reference Schetz JA, Bowersox RD (2011) Boundary layer analysis. American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics, New York Schetz JA, Bowersox RD (2011) Boundary layer analysis. American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics, New York
go back to reference Schlichting H, Gersten K (2016) Boundary-layer theory. Springer, BerlinMATH Schlichting H, Gersten K (2016) Boundary-layer theory. Springer, BerlinMATH
go back to reference Seasholtz R, Buggele A, Seasholtz R, Buggele A (1997a) Study of injection of helium into supersonic air flow using rayleigh scattering. In: 35th Aerospace sciences meeting and exhibit, p 155 Seasholtz R, Buggele A, Seasholtz R, Buggele A (1997a) Study of injection of helium into supersonic air flow using rayleigh scattering. In: 35th Aerospace sciences meeting and exhibit, p 155
go back to reference Seasholtz RG, Buggele AE, Reeder MF (1997b) Flow measurements based on rayleigh scattering and fabry-perot interferometer. Opt Lasers Eng 27(6):543–570 Seasholtz RG, Buggele AE, Reeder MF (1997b) Flow measurements based on rayleigh scattering and fabry-perot interferometer. Opt Lasers Eng 27(6):543–570
go back to reference Seiner JM, Dash S, Kenzakowski D (2001) Historical survey on enhanced mixing in scramjet engines. J Propul Power 17(6):1273–1286 Seiner JM, Dash S, Kenzakowski D (2001) Historical survey on enhanced mixing in scramjet engines. J Propul Power 17(6):1273–1286
go back to reference Shapiro AH (1954) The dynamics and thermodynamics of compressible fluid flow (vol2). The Ronald Press Company, Technical report Shapiro AH (1954) The dynamics and thermodynamics of compressible fluid flow (vol2). The Ronald Press Company, Technical report
go back to reference Smits AJ, Dussauge JP (2006) Turbulent shear layers in supersonic flow. Springer, Berlin Smits AJ, Dussauge JP (2006) Turbulent shear layers in supersonic flow. Springer, Berlin
go back to reference Tenti G, Boley C, Desai RC (1974) On the kinetic model description of rayleigh-brillouin scattering from molecular gases. Can J Phys 52(4):285–290 Tenti G, Boley C, Desai RC (1974) On the kinetic model description of rayleigh-brillouin scattering from molecular gases. Can J Phys 52(4):285–290
go back to reference Vergine F, Maddalena L (2014) Stereoscopic particle image velocimetry measurements of supersonic, turbulent, and interacting streamwise vortices: challenges and application. Prog Aerosp Sci 66:1–16 Vergine F, Maddalena L (2014) Stereoscopic particle image velocimetry measurements of supersonic, turbulent, and interacting streamwise vortices: challenges and application. Prog Aerosp Sci 66:1–16
go back to reference Vergine F, Crisanti M, Maddalena L, Miller V, Gamba M (2014) Supersonic combustion of pylon-injected hydrogen in high-enthalpy flow with imposed vortex dynamics. AIAA J Propul Power 31:89 Vergine F, Crisanti M, Maddalena L, Miller V, Gamba M (2014) Supersonic combustion of pylon-injected hydrogen in high-enthalpy flow with imposed vortex dynamics. AIAA J Propul Power 31:89
go back to reference Vergine F, Ground C, Maddalena L (2016) Turbulent kinetic energy decay in supersonic streamwise interacting vortices. J Fluid Mech 807:353–385MathSciNetMATH Vergine F, Ground C, Maddalena L (2016) Turbulent kinetic energy decay in supersonic streamwise interacting vortices. J Fluid Mech 807:353–385MathSciNetMATH
go back to reference Xiao X, Edwards JR, Hassan HA, Culter AD (2006) Variable turbulent schmidt-number formulation for scramjet applications. AIAA J 44(3):593–599 Xiao X, Edwards JR, Hassan HA, Culter AD (2006) Variable turbulent schmidt-number formulation for scramjet applications. AIAA J 44(3):593–599
go back to reference Yip S, Nelkin M (1964) Application of a kinetic model to time-dependent density correlations in fluids. Phys Rev 135(5A):A1241MathSciNet Yip S, Nelkin M (1964) Application of a kinetic model to time-dependent density correlations in fluids. Phys Rev 135(5A):A1241MathSciNet
Metadata
Title
Systematic errors in mixing measurements using filtered Rayleigh scattering in supersonic flows
Authors
Vijay Gopal
Luca Maddalena
Publication date
01-06-2020
Publisher
Springer Berlin Heidelberg
Published in
Experiments in Fluids / Issue 6/2020
Print ISSN: 0723-4864
Electronic ISSN: 1432-1114
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00348-020-02956-0

Other articles of this Issue 6/2020

Experiments in Fluids 6/2020 Go to the issue

Premium Partners