Skip to main content
Top

2012 | Book

They Play, You Pay

Why Taxpayers Build Ballparks, Stadiums, and Arenas for Billionaire Owners and Millionaire Players

insite
SEARCH

About this book

They Play, You Pay is a detailed, sometimes irreverent look at a political conundrum: despite evidence that publicly funded ballparks, stadiums, and arenas do not generate net economic growth, governments keep on taxing sales, restaurant patrons, renters of automobiles, and hotel visitors in order to build ever more elaborate cathedrals of professional sport—often in order to satisfy an owner who has threatened to move his team to greener, more subsidy‑happy, pastures. This book is a sweeping survey of the literature in the field, the history of such subsidies, the politics of stadium construction and franchise movement, and the prospects for a re‑priva­ti­zation of ballpark and stadium financing. It ties together disparate strands in a fascinating story, examining the often colorful cases through which governments became involved in sports. These range from the well‑known to the obscure—from Yankee Stadium and the Astrodome to the Brooklyn Dodgers’ move to Los Angeles (to a privately built ballpark constructed upon land that had been seized via eminent domain from a mostly Mexican‑American population) to such arrant giveaways as Cowboys Stadium. It examines alternatives that might lessen the pressure for public subsidies, whether the Green Bay Packers model (in which the team’s owners are local stockholders) or via league expan­sions. It also takes a look at little-known, yet significant, episodes such as President Theodore Roosevelt’s intervention in the collegiate football crisis of 1905—a move that indirectly put the federal government on the side of such basic rule changes as the legalization of the forward pass.

They Play, You Play is a fresh look at a political and economic puzzle: how it came to be that Joe and Jane Sixpack in the Bronx and Dallas subsidize the Steinbrenners and Jerry Joneses of professional sport.

Table of Contents

Frontmatter
Chapter 1. Introduction
Abstract
If there is one economic truth upon which almost every practitioner of the art or science of economics agrees, it is that publicly financed ballparks, stadiums, and arenas built by taxpayers for professional baseball, football, basketball, and hockey teams are not good investments. We will explore the reasons why in the pages that follow, but one curious fact intrudes itself on any discussion of this matter: Joe Q. Public, instead of being outraged by these rip-offs, is of two minds when it comes to state subvention of professional sports.
James T. Bennett
Chapter 2. Politics Takes the Field
Abstract
Although taxpayer-funded ballparks and stadiums are the focus of this analysis, we start with several backstories which illustrate the ways in which government—even the federal government—became involved in sport. After all, hotel taxes to finance football coliseums did not just spring full blown from the brows of greedy owners and their enablers in a hundred local Chambers of Commerce. Government intervention in matters of play grew over time. If the Founding Fathers did not exactly contemplate a role for the federal city in games played with balls and bats, later politicians, whose motivations ran from simple fandom to the cynical pursuit of the pork barrel, entered the field wielding legislation, appropriations, and sometimes threats. And who better to headline our first episode than that apostle of the vigorous outdoor life, President Theodore Roosevelt?
James T. Bennett
Chapter 3. Parks and Stadiums Until 1960
Abstract
Before they were ballparks, they were “baseball grounds,” and since people seem naturally to be drawn to watching sports played at a high level of skill, those who sponsored the game soon got the idea of fencing off the grounds “for the sole purpose of keeping freeloaders from viewing the game,” as Michael Benson writes in his encyclopedic Ballparks of North America (1989).1
James T. Bennett
Chapter 4. Parks and Stadiums Since 1960
Abstract
The 1960s began in baseball with a New Frontier of its own: expansion franchises were awarded in 1961 to Los Angeles (the Angels) and Washington, DC (a new Senators team to replace the Minnesota-departed one) and in 1962 to New York (the Mets) and Houston (the Colt .45s, later the Astros). So there were four new teams, but only one was placed in a major-league-less city.
James T. Bennett
Chapter 5. If You Build It, Prosperity Will Not Come: What the Studies Say
Abstract
Okay, so we’ve heard the case histories. What about academic studies of the question? Is there a consensus?
James T. Bennett
Backmatter
Metadata
Title
They Play, You Pay
Author
James T. Bennett
Copyright Year
2012
Publisher
Springer New York
Electronic ISBN
978-1-4614-3332-3
Print ISBN
978-1-4614-3331-6
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4614-3332-3