Skip to main content
Top

2004 | Book

Flexibility in Buyer-Seller Relationships

A Transaction Cost Economics Extension based on Real Options Analysis

Author: Ellen Roemer

Publisher: Deutscher Universitätsverlag

Book Series : Business-to-Business-Marketing

insite
SEARCH

About this book

Foreword Long-term buyer-seller relationships are a real and important phenomenon in business-to­ business markets. Since the consequences for the parties to a relationship heavily depend on the management of these relationships, research becomes increasingly intensive to explain the real phenomenon of buyer-seller relationships. On the one hand, the objective is to determine when relationships are a reasonable form of coordination in markets. On the other hand, the management of the relationship itself is in the focus of the analysis. Transaction Cost Economics (TCE) has been proven a fruitful theoretical approach explaining both research objectives. TCE provides not only insights in which situations relationships are economically reasonable but also which activities are appropriate to protect ex post benefits on both sides of the relationship from an ex ante perspective. In relation to the second research objective of the buyer-seller relationship manage­ ment, safeguarding mechanisms - protection against opportunistic behavior - were in the center of the analysis in the business-to-business relationship literature. In contrast, the flexibility to react to changing environmental conditions was largely neglected in buyer­ seller relationship management. The reason for this one-eyed perspective can be traced back to the comparative static approach as proposed by TCE comparing the efficiency of different coordination forms at one point of time. Intuitively it becomes clear that con­ tractual safeguards to limit behavioral uncertainty do not only provide advantages but also reduce the repertoire of the parties to react to future, unexpected developments.

Table of Contents

Frontmatter
Chapter 1. The Necessity of an Analysis of Flexibility in Buyer-Seller Relationships
Abstract
During the past two decades, the analysis of buyer-seller relationships has become one of the key issues in marketing research.1 An examination of the relationship marketing literature indicates that a number of research strands have contributed to the study of buyer-seller relationships. Economic theories as well as behavioral approaches serve as a foundation of the analysis of buyer-seller relationships such as Transaction Cost Economics (TCE) (e.g. Williamson 1975; Williamson 1985), agency theory (e.g. Jensen and Meckling 1976; Fama 1980), relational contracting (e.g. Macneil 1978; Macneil 1980; Macneil 1981), the resource-dependence perspective (e.g. Pfeffer and Salancik 1978), the resource-based view (e.g. Prahalad and Hamel 1990; Morgan and Hunt 1999), as well as social-exchange theory (e.g. Thibaut and Kelley 1959; Emerson 1962; Blau 1964; Homans 1974).2 Moreover, special research groups have developed their own theoretical perspectives of buyer-seller relationships such as the Industrial Marketing and Purchasing (IMP) Group which focuses on buyer-seller interaction and networks (e.g. Ford 1980; Håkansson 1982; Turnbull and Paliwoda 1986). Similarly, the Nordic school emphasizes buyer-seller interaction and services (e.g. Grönroos 1980; Grönroos 1983; Gummesson 1987).3
Ellen Roemer
Chapter 2. A Transaction Cost Economics Explanation of Buyer-Seller Relationships
Abstract
Institutions as “the rules of the game” in a society influence human behavior. They structure our everyday life, even though we often behave unconsciously in accordance with them (Hayek 1945, 528; Hayek 1973, 43). They determine how we greet friends on the street, how we drive our cars, how we buy milk, etc. Institutions provide a framework within which individuals can interact (North 1990, 3–4). “They consist of both informal constraints (sanctions, taboos, customs, traditions, and codes of conduct), and formal rules (constitutions, laws, property rights).” (North 1991, 97). An important question is how institutions function and in which way they structure human behavior.1
Ellen Roemer
Chapter 3. The Analysis of Flexibility in Buyer-Seller Relationships from a Transaction Cost Economics Perspective
Abstract
Flexibility is a very prominent subject in everyday parlance as well as in economic theory. In economic theory, an analysis of flexibility is problematic because a lot of different academic disciplines have dealt with the subject of flexibility. From this follows a variety of definitions. In this section, I therefore approach a definition of flexibility which is appropriate for the analysis of flexibility in buyer-seller relationships, I investigate the roots of the word, I explore different lines on flexibility, and I compile some definitions used in economic literature in order to extract a working definition.
Ellen Roemer
Chapter 4. Rational Flexibility in Buyer-Seller Relationships — A Real Options Approach
Abstract
The aim of this chapter is to model the value of rational flexibility in buyer-seller relationships in order to explain the trade-off in flexibility and to derive implications for the management of buyer-seller relationships in a world of behavioral and environmental uncertainty. Instead of a transaction cost minimizing calculus that is common in TCE, I propose to choose institutions that maximize the value of rational flexibility.
Ellen Roemer
Chapter 5. Real Flexibility in Buyer-Seller Relationships — An Austrian Economics Perspective
Abstract
The results of the previous chapter have been deduced under very strict assumptions, especially concerning the rationality of agents. In a real options world, economic agents are able to anticipate a complete set of future states of the world, to grasp the hold-up problem, to foresee a trade-off in (rational) flexibility, and to choose appropriate safeguards. Empirical evidence has shown, however, that agents are not necessarily as rational as depicted in most neoclassical models (Colinsk 1996, 670–672). Consequently, we have to suspect that different insights will result from an analysis of flexibility in buyer-seller relationships if we relax the assumption of rationality.
Ellen Roemer
Chapter 6. Conclusions
Abstract
In this work, I have presented two possible approaches to flexibility in buyer-seller relationships. Following the marketing research paradigm to view buyer-seller relationships as hybrid forms of governance, I have chosen the traditional TCE framework to explain the existence of buyer-seller relationships (Chapter 2). To get a deeper understanding of the TCE perspective of buyer-seller relationships, I have investigated the role of institutions in society. Institutions have an impact on the value of different options in an individual’s choice-set, although they do not exclude options from choice-sets. TCE is primarily concerned with the construction of secondary institutions. To provide a more comprehensive picture of buyer-seller relationships, relationships can be viewed as a set of fundamental and secondary institutions. Applied to real world problems, TCE is an unsatisfactory approach in some cases, especially because of its strong focus on behavioral uncertainty and its undifferentiated view of uncertainty. Environmental factors and environmental uncertainty including technological change are largely neglected in TCE.
Ellen Roemer
Backmatter
Metadata
Title
Flexibility in Buyer-Seller Relationships
Author
Ellen Roemer
Copyright Year
2004
Publisher
Deutscher Universitätsverlag
Electronic ISBN
978-3-322-81833-1
Print ISBN
978-3-8244-8195-8
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-322-81833-1