Skip to main content
Top

1999 | Book

Future Impacts of Biotechnology on Agriculture, Food Production and Food Processing

A Delphi Survey

Authors: Dr. Klaus Menrad, Prof. Dr. Demosthenes Agrafiotis, Dr. Christien M. Enzing, Prof. Dr. Louis Lemkow, Prof. Dr. Fabio Terragni

Publisher: Physica-Verlag HD

Book Series : Technology, Innovation and Policy

insite
SEARCH

About this book

Although the first Agro-Food products based on modem biotechnology (e. g. recombinant chymosin for cheese production; tomato puree based on genetically engineered tomatoes; herbicide-resistant, genetically modified soybean; insect­ resistant maize) have been introduced in the EU markets in recent years, the application of this technology is still being intensively discussed in the European Union. Recent opinion polls indicate as well that consumers' acceptance of genetically engineered food and agro-products still is relatively low (e. g. European Commission 1997, Hampel et al. 1997), at least in some member states of the EU. In contrast, representatives from politics and industry underline the necessity to apply modem biotechnology in the Agro-Food sector as well, mainly to ensure the competitiveness of EU agriculture and food industry and for employment reasons. Against this background there seems to be a need for a scientific analysis of the future impacts of modem biotechnology in the Agro-Food sector of the EU. Recent studies trying to analyse this issue (e. g. OECD 1992, Teuber 1992) usually comprise extrapolations of status-quo analyses. What has not been exploited so far in this context are systematic technology forecasting approaches which do not include only one single country, but get information on an international level. Therefore, the impacts of modem biotechnology on the Agro-Food sector in five member countries of the EU (Germany, Greece, Italy, the Netherlands, and Spain) have been analysed with the help of the Delphi methodology which represents one of the most reliable tools for technology forecasting.

Table of Contents

Frontmatter
1. Introduction
Abstract
Although the first Agro-Food products based on modem biotechnology (e. g. recombinant chymosin for cheese production; tomato puree based on genetically engineered tomatoes; herbicide-resistant, genetically modified soybean; insect-resistant maize) have been introduced in the EU markets in recent years, the application of this technology is still being intensively discussed in the European Union. Recent opinion polls indicate as well that consumers’ acceptance of genetically engineered food and agro-products still is relatively low (e. g. European Commission 1997, Hampel et al. 1997), at least in some member states of the EU. In contrast, representatives from politics and industry underline the necessity to apply modem biotechnology in the Agro-Food sector as well, mainly to ensure the competitiveness of EU agriculture and food industry and for employment reasons.
Klaus Menrad, Demosthenes Agrafiotis, Christien M. Enzing, Louis Lemkow, Fabio Terragni
2. Concept and realization
Abstract
In the Agro-Food sector of the European Union the first products based on modem biotechnology or genetic engineering have entered the market (e. g. recombinant chymosin for cheese production, tomato puree, herbicide-resistant plants). In the coming years an increasing influence of biotechnology on agriculture, food production and food processing is expected. However, the application of modern biotechnology in agriculture and the food industry is still being intensively discussed in the EU countries. One of the latest indicators in this context represent the results of the Eurobarometer survey which was conducted in 1996 (European Commission 1997), the activities accompanying the market introduction of the herbicide-resistant soybean by Monsanto in autumn 1996, as well as the intensive public debate after the birth of the cloned sheep “Dolly” in spring 1997 (Wilmut et al. 1997).
Klaus Menrad, Demosthenes Agrafiotis, Christien M. Enzing, Louis Lemkow, Fabio Terragni
3. Results in different countries
Abstract
In this chapter, an overview is given of the basic results of the Delphi survey in the participating countries, which are sorted in alphabetical order. This overview mainly follows the categories included in the questionnaire in each country. Firstly, the self-estimated degree of knowledge of the answering experts is analysed. In the following parts a general overview is given related to the estimated personal attitude and the expected time of realization of the statements included in the questionnaire. In addition, the most important influential factors relevant for the future application of modem biotechnology in the Agro-Food sector are analysed. Afterwards the importance of the visions mentioned in the statements of the questionnaire for future knowledge creation in science and technology, and competitiveness of the respective national economies, as well as the environmental situation, is described. Most of the country chapters conclude with a short discussion on how the results of this Delphi survey fit in the general situation of Agro-Food biotechnology in the respective country.
Klaus Menrad, Demosthenes Agrafiotis, Christien M. Enzing, Louis Lemkow, Fabio Terragni
4. Comparative analysis
Abstract
In this chapter common features and differences between the five countries are analysed. The presentation of the results is done according to the structure of the questionnaire. The target is to elaborate major differences between the five countries involved but not to analyse their response behaviour in detail. In order to filter out main differences concerning the personal attitude and the time of realization, a specific statistical test has been used which compares the distribution of answers between two samples. The respective statistical analysis has been carried out with the U-Test of Mann-Whitney for non-parametric data (Kähler 1995).
Klaus Menrad, Demosthenes Agrafiotis, Christien M. Enzing, Louis Lemkow, Fabio Terragni
5. Future impacts of biotechnology in the Agro-Food sector
Abstract
In this chapter the results of an in-depth analysis of selected key issues are presented. These key issues relate to the scientific and technical development of Agro-Food biotechnology as well as its future impacts on society, the economy, the environment and the health of consumers, users and employees. In order to facilitate the comparison between the results of these analyses and the results of the survey in the single countries, this chapter is structured according to the sequence of the domains in the questionnaire. Firstly, the future acceptance of modern biotechnology (5.1) as well as regulatory issues (5.2) are analysed. Afterwards, the impacts of Agro-Food biotechnology on the economy (5.3), the environment (5.4) and the health of consumers, users and employees (5.5) are discussed. This chapter concludes with a presentation of future scientific and technical trends in four selected areas of Agro-Food biotechnology and the most important prerequisites for these developments (5.6).
Klaus Menrad, Demosthenes Agrafiotis, Christien M. Enzing, Louis Lemkow, Fabio Terragni
6. Conclusions and recommendations
Abstract
In the following chapter the most important findings of the project will be combined according to the thematic fields covered in the Delphi survey. This relates to future scientific and technical developments, their impacts on the health of consumers and the environment, the future acceptance of Agro-Food biotechnology, and regulatory aspects as well as economic implications. Finally, the suitability of the applied methodology is discussed. Based on these results, recommendations on how to use the obtained results for politics, industry and other social actors are worked out.
Klaus Menrad, Demosthenes Agrafiotis, Christien M. Enzing, Louis Lemkow, Fabio Terragni
7. Summary
Abstract
Although the first Agro-Food products based on modern biotechnology have entered the EU markets, the application of this technology is still being intensively discussed in the European Union. Recent opinion polls indicate as well that consumers’ acceptance of genetically engineered food and agro-products is still relatively low, at least in some member states of the EU. By contrast, representatives from politics and industry underline the necessity to apply modem biotechnology in the Agro-Food sector as well, mainly to ensure the competitiveness of the EU agriculture and food industry and for employment reasons.
Klaus Menrad, Demosthenes Agrafiotis, Christien M. Enzing, Louis Lemkow, Fabio Terragni
8. Literature
Klaus Menrad, Demosthenes Agrafiotis, Christien M. Enzing, Louis Lemkow, Fabio Terragni
Backmatter
Metadata
Title
Future Impacts of Biotechnology on Agriculture, Food Production and Food Processing
Authors
Dr. Klaus Menrad
Prof. Dr. Demosthenes Agrafiotis
Dr. Christien M. Enzing
Prof. Dr. Louis Lemkow
Prof. Dr. Fabio Terragni
Copyright Year
1999
Publisher
Physica-Verlag HD
Electronic ISBN
978-3-642-52474-5
Print ISBN
978-3-7908-1215-2
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-52474-5