Skip to main content
Top
Published in: Social Indicators Research 1/2019

27-01-2018

Methodological Choices and Data Quality Issues for Official Poverty Measures: Evidences from Italy

Authors: Achille Lemmi, Donatella Grassi, Alessandra Masi, Nicoletta Pannuzi, Andrea Regoli

Published in: Social Indicators Research | Issue 1/2019

Log in

Activate our intelligent search to find suitable subject content or patents.

search-config
loading …

Abstract

The plurality of the official poverty estimates in Italy covers both absolute and relative approaches, ranges from consumption to income-based measures, follows different methodologies and uses several data sources. We can therefore expect that each measure gives a somewhat different picture of poverty, in its level as well as in its change across subgroups of the population. This paper investigates the effect of methodological choices together with the effect of different data quality aspects on the official poverty estimates. Usually, methodological issues attract much attention both in literature and empirical studies. However, the results of the sensitivity analysis suggest that more specific attention should be paid to data quality issues and to the definition of the variables. Our main conclusion is that an improvement in the quality as well as the inclusion of some items in the definition of the variable may result in large changes in poverty indicators. This finding signals that the data quality aspects have a higher impact on poverty estimates than some methodological issues.

Dont have a licence yet? Then find out more about our products and how to get one now:

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 102.000 Bücher
  • über 537 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Automobil + Motoren
  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Elektrotechnik + Elektronik
  • Energie + Nachhaltigkeit
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Maschinenbau + Werkstoffe
  • Versicherung + Risiko

Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 67.000 Bücher
  • über 340 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Versicherung + Risiko




Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Footnotes
1
The willingness to overpass the limits of this type of measures has led Eurostat to produce indicators of material deprivation (Eurostat 2012a) and the multidimensional indicator of poverty or social exclusion (Eurostat 2016). However they are still considered as marginal or complementary estimates.
 
2
Some of these items have been discussed within the Interinstitutional Working Group on Poverty Estimates established by Italian National Institute of Statistics (https://​www.​istat.​it/​it/​archivio/​189524).
 
3
Elasticity accounts for the extent to which economic needs change with household size (Förster and Mira D’Ercole 2012).
 
4
The absolute term refers to the fact that the measure is independent on the distribution of the proxy variable; however, its definition is obviously dependent on (relative to) the reference context.
 
5
For a survey of the most used poverty indices and the axioms they satisfy, see Chakravarty (2009).
 
6
It should be emphasised that the SHIW by Bank of Italy, conducted by a professional interviewer network, shows a lower response rate (53.3% in 2014) (Bank of Italy 2015) and that several European HBSs (using again professional interviewer networks) show even lower levels of coverage (in 2010, the values varied between 5% in Belgium, 42% in Denmark, 51% in UK and Sweden to over 80% in Turkey and Romania) (Eurostat 2012b).
 
7
When the sample selection steps and weighting system arrangement had to be done, the information from the tax returns was not yet available and, therefore, the fiscal income was not used as a variable for either sample stratification or post-stratification. The fiscal information became available after 1 year and, at that moment, it was linked to HBS and NHBS data by individual fiscal codes (tax identification numbers).
 
8
It follows that the use of tax information in the sampling phase (for stratification) would not be of great utility, while it could be very useful in defining substitutions; likewise, a number of constraints could be added to the final calibration to comply with the tax income classes.
 
9
It must be underlined that some people are not properly represented in tax statistics, as the population not liable for taxation due to their low levels of income and tax evaders.
 
10
This analysis has been conducted as one of the activities of the already mentioned Interinstitutional Working Group on Poverty Estimates.
 
11
The consumption expenditure is the net of extraordinary maintenance expenses, premiums paid for life insurance and annuities, mortgage rate and repay loans; the household disposable income is derived as the sum of the income from employment, property income and transfers, net of taxes and social contributions.
 
12
HBS does not allow us to properly single out the component of own consumption from the total expenditure, whereas own consumption is not collected at all by the SHIW. Therefore, the own consumption is always included in the definition from the former survey, while it is always excluded from the latter survey.
 
13
It must be noted that the monthly imputed rent for the main accommodation ranges from 531 euros in EU-Silc to 576 euros in NHBS. Nevertheless, the NHBS data also include the imputed rent from the main accommodation appurtenances (garages, basements, etc.) and also from any second house.
 
14
The coefficients of this scale are as follows: 1 for a 1 member household, 1.9 for a 2 member household, 2.7 for a 3 member household, 3.5 for a 4 member households, 4.2 for a 5 member households, 5.0 for a 6 member households and 5.7 if the members are 7 or more.
 
15
The elasticities resulted equal to 0.53 for S1, 0.67 for S2, 0.73 for S3 and 0.87 for S4 (Betti et al. 2016).
 
16
The reference method corresponds to the calculation of poverty incidence on HBS data including imputed rent and goods produced for own consumption, using the traditional approach, S2 scale and poverty line at 60% of the mean of per-capita distribution.
 
Literature
go back to reference Aaberge, R., & Brandolini, A. (2014). Multidimensional Poverty and Inequality. In A. B. Atkinson & F. Bourguignon (Eds.), Handbook of income distribution (Vol. 2A). Oxford, North-Holland: Elsevier. Aaberge, R., & Brandolini, A. (2014). Multidimensional Poverty and Inequality. In A. B. Atkinson & F. Bourguignon (Eds.), Handbook of income distribution (Vol. 2A). Oxford, North-Holland: Elsevier.
go back to reference Alkire, S., Foster, J., Seth, S., Santos, M. E., Roche, J. M., & Ballon, P. (2015). Multidimensional poverty measurement and analysis. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRef Alkire, S., Foster, J., Seth, S., Santos, M. E., Roche, J. M., & Ballon, P. (2015). Multidimensional poverty measurement and analysis. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRef
go back to reference Atkinson, A. B., & Bourguignon, F. (Eds.). (2014). Handbook of income distribution (Vol. 2A). Oxford, North-Holland: Elsevier. Atkinson, A. B., & Bourguignon, F. (Eds.). (2014). Handbook of income distribution (Vol. 2A). Oxford, North-Holland: Elsevier.
go back to reference Bavier, R. (2008). Reconciliation of income and consumption data in poverty measurement. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 27(1), 40–62.CrossRef Bavier, R. (2008). Reconciliation of income and consumption data in poverty measurement. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 27(1), 40–62.CrossRef
go back to reference Berthoud, R., Bryan, M. L., & Bardasi, E. (2004). The dynamics of deprivation: The relationship between income and material deprivation over time. Research Report no. 219. London: Department for Work and Pensions. Berthoud, R., Bryan, M. L., & Bardasi, E. (2004). The dynamics of deprivation: The relationship between income and material deprivation over time. Research Report no. 219. London: Department for Work and Pensions.
go back to reference Besharov, D. J., & Couch, K. A. (Eds.). (2012). Counting the poor: New Thinking about European poverty measures and lessons for the United States. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Besharov, D. J., & Couch, K. A. (Eds.). (2012). Counting the poor: New Thinking about European poverty measures and lessons for the United States. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
go back to reference Betti, G., Cheli, B., Lemmi, A., & Verma, V. (2006). multidimensional and longitudinal poverty: An integrated fuzzy approach. In A. Lemmi & G. Betti (Eds.), Fuzzy set approach to multidimensional poverty measurement (pp. 111–137). Berlin: Springer. Betti, G., Cheli, B., Lemmi, A., & Verma, V. (2006). multidimensional and longitudinal poverty: An integrated fuzzy approach. In A. Lemmi & G. Betti (Eds.), Fuzzy set approach to multidimensional poverty measurement (pp. 111–137). Berlin: Springer.
go back to reference Betti, G., & Lemmi, A. (Eds.). (2013). Poverty and social exclusion: New methods of analysis. London, New York: Routledge. Betti, G., & Lemmi, A. (Eds.). (2013). Poverty and social exclusion: New methods of analysis. London, New York: Routledge.
go back to reference Betti, G., Masi, A., & Regoli, A. (2016). Profili di disuguaglianza e povertà in Italia: un confronto tra stime da fonti ufficiali. Paper presented at the scientific meeting “La società italiana e le grandi crisi economiche 1929–2016, Rome, 25–26 November 2016. Betti, G., Masi, A., & Regoli, A. (2016). Profili di disuguaglianza e povertà in Italia: un confronto tra stime da fonti ufficiali. Paper presented at the scientific meeting “La società italiana e le grandi crisi economiche 1929–2016, Rome, 25–26 November 2016.
go back to reference Brandolini, A., Magri, S., & Smeeding, T. (2010). Asset-based measurement of poverty. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 29(2), 267–284.CrossRef Brandolini, A., Magri, S., & Smeeding, T. (2010). Asset-based measurement of poverty. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 29(2), 267–284.CrossRef
go back to reference Buhmann, B., Rainwater, L., Schmaus, G., & Smeedinget, T. M. (1988). Equivalence Scales, well-being, inequality, and poverty: sensitivity estimates across ten countries using the Luxembourg Income Study (LIS) database. Review of Income and Wealth, 34(2), 115–142.CrossRef Buhmann, B., Rainwater, L., Schmaus, G., & Smeedinget, T. M. (1988). Equivalence Scales, well-being, inequality, and poverty: sensitivity estimates across ten countries using the Luxembourg Income Study (LIS) database. Review of Income and Wealth, 34(2), 115–142.CrossRef
go back to reference Carbonaro, G. (1985). Nota sulle scale di equivalenza, in Commissione di indagine sulla povertà e sull’emarginazione (Ed.), Primo rapporto sulla povertà in Italia (pp. 153–159). Roma, Istituto Poligrafico e Zecca dello Stato. Carbonaro, G. (1985). Nota sulle scale di equivalenza, in Commissione di indagine sulla povertà e sull’emarginazione (Ed.), Primo rapporto sulla povertà in Italia (pp. 153–159). Roma, Istituto Poligrafico e Zecca dello Stato.
go back to reference Ceccarelli, C., & Cutillo, A. (2016). Representativeness of the 2014 NHBS and 2013 HBS samples in comparison to the universe of households residing in Italy using fiscal tax income data. Unpublished paper. Ceccarelli, C., & Cutillo, A. (2016). Representativeness of the 2014 NHBS and 2013 HBS samples in comparison to the universe of households residing in Italy using fiscal tax income data. Unpublished paper.
go back to reference Chen, S., & Ravallion, M. (2013). More relatively-poor people in a less absolutely-poor world. Review of Income and Wealth, 59(1), 1–28.CrossRef Chen, S., & Ravallion, M. (2013). More relatively-poor people in a less absolutely-poor world. Review of Income and Wealth, 59(1), 1–28.CrossRef
go back to reference Citro, C. F., & Michael, R. T. (1995). Measuring poverty: A new approach. Washington, D.C.: National Academy Press. Citro, C. F., & Michael, R. T. (1995). Measuring poverty: A new approach. Washington, D.C.: National Academy Press.
go back to reference Consolini, P., & Donatiello, G. (2013). Improvements of data quality through the combined use of survey and administrative sources and micro simulation model. In M. Jäntti, V.-M. Törmälehto, & E. Marlier (Eds.), The use of registers in the context of EU–SILC: Challenges and opportunities (pp. 125–139). Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union. Consolini, P., & Donatiello, G. (2013). Improvements of data quality through the combined use of survey and administrative sources and micro simulation model. In M. Jäntti, V.-M. Törmälehto, & E. Marlier (Eds.), The use of registers in the context of EU–SILC: Challenges and opportunities (pp. 125–139). Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.
go back to reference De Vitiis, C., Falorsi, S., Inglese, F., Masi, A., Pannuzi, N., & Russo, M. (2014). A methodological approach based on indirect sampling to survey the homeless people. Rivista di statistica ufficiale, 16(1–2), 9–30. De Vitiis, C., Falorsi, S., Inglese, F., Masi, A., Pannuzi, N., & Russo, M. (2014). A methodological approach based on indirect sampling to survey the homeless people. Rivista di statistica ufficiale, 16(1–2), 9–30.
go back to reference de Vos, K., & Garner, T. I. (1991). An evaluation of subjective poverty definitions: Comparing results from the U.S. and the Netherlands. Review of Income and Wealth, 37(3), 267–285.CrossRef de Vos, K., & Garner, T. I. (1991). An evaluation of subjective poverty definitions: Comparing results from the U.S. and the Netherlands. Review of Income and Wealth, 37(3), 267–285.CrossRef
go back to reference de Vos, K., & Zaidi, M. A. (1997). Equivalence scale sensitivity of poverty statistics for the member states of the European community. Review of Income and Wealth, 43(3), 319–333.CrossRef de Vos, K., & Zaidi, M. A. (1997). Equivalence scale sensitivity of poverty statistics for the member states of the European community. Review of Income and Wealth, 43(3), 319–333.CrossRef
go back to reference Decerf, B. (2015). A new index combining the absolute and relative aspects of income poverty: theory and application. CORE Discussion Series (2015/50), 1–27. Decerf, B. (2015). A new index combining the absolute and relative aspects of income poverty: theory and application. CORE Discussion Series (2015/50), 1–27.
go back to reference Delle Fratte, C. & Lariccia, F. (2015). The impact of Administrative data on final estimates of It-Silc income variables. Paper presented at the London EU-Silc Best Practice Workshop, 16th and 17th September 2015. Delle Fratte, C. & Lariccia, F. (2015). The impact of Administrative data on final estimates of It-Silc income variables. Paper presented at the London EU-Silc Best Practice Workshop, 16th and 17th September 2015.
go back to reference Dudel, C. (2017). Variance estimation for sensitivity analysis of poverty and inequality measures. Survey Research Methods, 11(1), 81–92. Dudel, C. (2017). Variance estimation for sensitivity analysis of poverty and inequality measures. Survey Research Methods, 11(1), 81–92.
go back to reference Ebert, U., & Moyes, P. (2017). Inequality and isoelastic equivalence scales: restrictions and implications. Social Choice and Welfare, 48(2), 295–326.CrossRef Ebert, U., & Moyes, P. (2017). Inequality and isoelastic equivalence scales: restrictions and implications. Social Choice and Welfare, 48(2), 295–326.CrossRef
go back to reference Förster, M. F., & Mira D’Ercole, M. (2012). The OECD approach to measuring income distribution and poverty. In D. J. Besharov & K. A. Couch (Eds.), Counting the poor: New thinking about european poverty measures and lessons for the United States. Oxford: Oxford Scholarship. Förster, M. F., & Mira D’Ercole, M. (2012). The OECD approach to measuring income distribution and poverty. In D. J. Besharov & K. A. Couch (Eds.), Counting the poor: New thinking about european poverty measures and lessons for the United States. Oxford: Oxford Scholarship.
go back to reference Hagenaars, A. (1987). A class of poverty indices. International Economic Review, 28(3), 583–607.CrossRef Hagenaars, A. (1987). A class of poverty indices. International Economic Review, 28(3), 583–607.CrossRef
go back to reference Hagenaars, A., de Vos, K., & Zaidi, M. A. (1994). Poverty statistics in the late 1980s: Research based on micro-data. Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities. Hagenaars, A., de Vos, K., & Zaidi, M. A. (1994). Poverty statistics in the late 1980s: Research based on micro-data. Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities.
go back to reference Haveman, R., Blank, R., Moffitt, R., Smeeding, T., & Wallace, G. (2015). The war on poverty: measurement, trends and policy. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 34(3), 593–638.CrossRef Haveman, R., Blank, R., Moffitt, R., Smeeding, T., & Wallace, G. (2015). The war on poverty: measurement, trends and policy. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 34(3), 593–638.CrossRef
go back to reference Jenkins, S. P., & Van Kerm, P. (2014). The relationship between EU indicators of persistent and current poverty. Social Indicators Research, 116(2), 611–638.CrossRef Jenkins, S. P., & Van Kerm, P. (2014). The relationship between EU indicators of persistent and current poverty. Social Indicators Research, 116(2), 611–638.CrossRef
go back to reference Kanbur, R., & Tuomala, M. (2016). Groupings and the gains from targeting. Research in Economics, 70, 53–63.CrossRef Kanbur, R., & Tuomala, M. (2016). Groupings and the gains from targeting. Research in Economics, 70, 53–63.CrossRef
go back to reference Martinez, R., & Navarro, C. (2016). Has the great recession changed the deprivation profile of low in-come groups? Evidence from Spain. Review of Public Economics, 218(3), 79–104. Martinez, R., & Navarro, C. (2016). Has the great recession changed the deprivation profile of low in-come groups? Evidence from Spain. Review of Public Economics, 218(3), 79–104.
go back to reference Marx, I., Nolan, B., & Olivera, J. (2015). The welfare state and antipoverty policy in rich countries, In A. B. Atkinson & F. Bourguignon (Eds.), Handbook of Income Distribution (Vol 2). Marx, I., Nolan, B., & Olivera, J. (2015). The welfare state and antipoverty policy in rich countries, In A. B. Atkinson & F. Bourguignon (Eds.), Handbook of Income Distribution (Vol 2).
go back to reference Meyer, B. D., & Mittag, N. (2017). Using linked survey and administrative data to better measure income: Implications for poverty, program effectiveness and holes in the safety net. Discussion paper series, no. 10943. IZA-Institute of Labor Economics. https://www.iza.org/dp10943.pdf. Meyer, B. D., & Mittag, N. (2017). Using linked survey and administrative data to better measure income: Implications for poverty, program effectiveness and holes in the safety net. Discussion paper series, no. 10943. IZA-Institute of Labor Economics. https://​www.​iza.​org/​dp10943.​pdf.
go back to reference Nelson, K. (2012). Counteracting material deprivation: The role of social assistance in Europe. Journal of European Social Policy, 22(2), 148–163.CrossRef Nelson, K. (2012). Counteracting material deprivation: The role of social assistance in Europe. Journal of European Social Policy, 22(2), 148–163.CrossRef
go back to reference Nolan, B., & Whelan, C. T. (2011). Poverty and deprivation in Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRef Nolan, B., & Whelan, C. T. (2011). Poverty and deprivation in Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRef
go back to reference Orshansky, M. (1963). Children of the poor. Social Security Bulletin, 26(7), 3–13. Orshansky, M. (1963). Children of the poor. Social Security Bulletin, 26(7), 3–13.
go back to reference Ravallion, M. (2016). The economics of poverty: History, measurement, and policy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRef Ravallion, M. (2016). The economics of poverty: History, measurement, and policy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRef
go back to reference Rowntree, B. S. (1901). Poverty: A study of town life. London: Longman. Rowntree, B. S. (1901). Poverty: A study of town life. London: Longman.
go back to reference Sen, A. K. (1976). Poverty: An ordinal approach to measurement. Econometrica, 44, 219–231.CrossRef Sen, A. K. (1976). Poverty: An ordinal approach to measurement. Econometrica, 44, 219–231.CrossRef
go back to reference Townsend, P. (1979). Poverty in the United Kingdom: A survey of household resources and standards of living. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books. Townsend, P. (1979). Poverty in the United Kingdom: A survey of household resources and standards of living. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books.
go back to reference Tran, V. Q., Alkire, S., & Klasen, S. (2015). Static and dynamic disparities between monetary and multidimensional poverty measurement: Evidence from Vietnam. In T. I. Garner & K. S. Short (Eds.), Measurement of poverty, deprivation, and economic mobility, book series: research on economic inequality, volume 23, 249–281. Bingley: Emerald Group Publishing Limited. Tran, V. Q., Alkire, S., & Klasen, S. (2015). Static and dynamic disparities between monetary and multidimensional poverty measurement: Evidence from Vietnam. In T. I. Garner & K. S. Short (Eds.), Measurement of poverty, deprivation, and economic mobility, book series: research on economic inequality, volume 23, 249–281. Bingley: Emerald Group Publishing Limited.
go back to reference UNECE. (2011). Canberra group handbook on household income statistics (2nd ed.). Geneva: UNECE. UNECE. (2011). Canberra group handbook on household income statistics (2nd ed.). Geneva: UNECE.
go back to reference Villar, A. (2017). Lectures on inequality, poverty and welfare. Lecture Notes in Economics and Mathematical Systems (Vol. 685). Berlin: Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-45562-4 Villar, A. (2017). Lectures on inequality, poverty and welfare. Lecture Notes in Economics and Mathematical Systems (Vol. 685). Berlin: Springer. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1007/​978-3-319-45562-4
go back to reference Weisbrod, B. A., & Hansen, W. L. (1968). An income-net worth approach to measuring economic welfare. American Economic Review, 58(5), 1315–1329. Weisbrod, B. A., & Hansen, W. L. (1968). An income-net worth approach to measuring economic welfare. American Economic Review, 58(5), 1315–1329.
Metadata
Title
Methodological Choices and Data Quality Issues for Official Poverty Measures: Evidences from Italy
Authors
Achille Lemmi
Donatella Grassi
Alessandra Masi
Nicoletta Pannuzi
Andrea Regoli
Publication date
27-01-2018
Publisher
Springer Netherlands
Published in
Social Indicators Research / Issue 1/2019
Print ISSN: 0303-8300
Electronic ISSN: 1573-0921
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11205-018-1841-3

Other articles of this Issue 1/2019

Social Indicators Research 1/2019 Go to the issue

Premium Partner