1 Introduction
1.1 Teacher quality: context and comparability
1.2 Approaches to measurement invariance and a review of past literature
2 Methods
2.1 Data and measurement
Country | Abbreviation | N |
---|---|---|
Australia | AUS | 941 |
Bahrain | BHR | 201 |
Armenia | ARM | 210 |
Botswana | BWA | 169 |
Canada | CAN | 409 |
Chile | CHL | 173 |
Chinese Taipei | TWN | 216 |
Georgia | GEO | 188 |
Hong Kong | HGK | 175 |
Hungary | HUN | 278 |
Iran | IRN | 251 |
Ireland | IRE | 526 |
Israel | ISR | 603 |
Italy | ITA | 230 |
Japan | JPN | 231 |
Kazakstan | KAZ | 239 |
Jordan | JOR | 260 |
South Korea | KOR | 317 |
Kuwait | KWT | 191 |
Lebanon | LBN | 185 |
Lithuania | LTU | 269 |
Malaysia | MYS | 326 |
Malta | MLT | 224 |
Morocco | MOR | 373 |
Oman | OMN | 356 |
New Zealand | NWZ | 489 |
Norway | NOR | 239 |
Qatar | QAT | 250 |
Russia | RUS | 226 |
Saudi Arabia | SAU | 149 |
Singapore | SNG | 334 |
Slovenia | SLV | 467 |
South Africa | ZAF | 334 |
Sweden | SWE | 206 |
Thailand | THL | 205 |
UAE | UAE | 746 |
Turkey | TUR | 220 |
Egypt | EGY | 215 |
United States | USA | 429 |
England | ENG | 215 |
Norway 8 | NOR8 | 239 |
UAE Dubai | UAED | 267 |
UAE Abu Dhabi | UAEAD | 207 |
Canada Ontario | CANON | 217 |
Canada Quebec | CANQU | 175 |
Argentina (BA) | ARGBA | 138 |
Construct | Indicators | Coding |
---|---|---|
Job satisfaction (JS) | I am content with my profession as a teacher | 4 = “Very often” 3 = “Often” 2 = “Sometimes” 1 = “Never or almost never” |
I am satisfied with being a teacher at this school | ||
I find my work full of meaning and purpose | ||
I am enthusiastic about my job | ||
My work inspires me | ||
I am proud of the work I do | ||
I am going to continue teaching for as long as I can | ||
School emphasis on academic success (SEAS) | Teachers’ understanding of the school’s curricular goals | 5 = “Very low” 4 = “Low” 3 = “Medium” 2 = “High” 1 = “Very high” |
Teachers’ degree of success in implementing the school’s curriculum | ||
Teachers’ expectations for student achievement | ||
Teachers working together to improve student achievement | ||
Teachers’ ability to inspire students | ||
School condition and resources (SCR) | The school building needs significant repair | 4 = “Not a problem” 3 = “Minor problem” 2 = “Moderate problem” 1 = “Serious problem” |
Teachers do not have adequate workspace (for preparation, collaboration, or meeting with students) | ||
Teachers do not have adequate instructional materials and supplies | ||
The school classrooms are not cleaned often enough | ||
The school classrooms need maintenance work | ||
Teachers do not have adequate technological resources | ||
Teachers do not have adequate support for using technology | ||
Safe and orderly school (SOS) | This school is located in a safe neighborhood | 4 = “Agree a lot” 3 = “Agree a little” 2 = “Disagree a little” 1 = “Disagree a lot” |
I feel safe at this school | ||
This school’s security policies and practices are sufficient | ||
The students behave in an orderly manner | ||
The students are respectful of the teachers | ||
The students respect school property | ||
This school has clear rules about student conduct | ||
This school’s rules are enforced in a fair and consistent manner | ||
Self-efficacy (TSE) | Inspiring students to learn mathematics | 4 = “Very high” 3 = “High” 2 = “Medium” 1 = “Low” |
Showing students a variety of problem-solving strategies | ||
Providing challenging tasks for the highest achieving students | ||
Adapting my teaching to engage students’ interest | ||
Helping students appreciate the value of learning mathematics | ||
Assessing student comprehension of mathematics | ||
Improving the understanding of struggling students | ||
Making mathematics relevant to students | ||
Developing students’ higher-order thinking skills |
2.2 Alignment optimization
2.3 Analytical process
3 Results
3.1 Results from the MGCFA approach
№ of parameters | χ2 | df | χ2diff | Δdf | RMSEA | SRMR | CFI | TLI | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(90% CI) | |||||||||
Configural | 1104 | 1143.283* | 506 | .068† | .030† | .978† | .959† | ||
(.063–.073) | |||||||||
Metric | 834 | 2041.882* | 776 | 898.599 | 270 | .077 | .140 | .957† | .946 |
(.073–.081) | |||||||||
Scalar | 564 | 4411.334* | 1046 | 2369.452 | 270 | .109 | .184 | .886 | .894 |
(.105–.112) | |||||||||
School emphasis on academic success | |||||||||
Job satisfaction | |||||||||
Configural | 782 | 214.61* | 138 | .045† | .018† | .995† | .983† | ||
(.033–.056) | |||||||||
Metric | 602 | 482.951* | 318 | 268.341 | 180 | .043† | .055† | .989† | .984† |
(.035–.051) | |||||||||
Scalar | 422 | 3242.335* | 498 | 2759.384 | 180 | .142 | .148 | .815 | .829 |
(.137–.146) | |||||||||
School condition and resources | |||||||||
Configural | 1104 | 1353.168* | 506 | .078† | .040† | .968† | .939 | ||
(.073–.083) | |||||||||
Metric | 834 | 1997.683* | 776 | 644.515 | 270 | .076† | .074† | .954† | .943 |
(.072–.080) | |||||||||
Scalar | 564 | 479.880* | 1046 | 2793.197 | 270 | .114 | .119 | .859 | .870 |
(.111–.118) | |||||||||
Safe and orderly school | |||||||||
Configural | 1288 | 1732.337* | 736 | .070† | .047† | .972† | .950† | ||
(.066–.075) | |||||||||
Metric | 973 | 2819.242* | 1051 | 1086.905 | 315 | .078† | .203 | .950† | .938 |
(.075–.082) | |||||||||
Scalar | 658 | 6239.447* | 1366 | 342.205 | 315 | .114 | .302 | .861 | .869 |
(.111–.117) | |||||||||
Self-efficacy | |||||||||
Configural | 1426 | 2144.005* | 1058 | .062† | .034† | .972† | .956† | ||
(.058–.065) | |||||||||
Metric | 1066 | 2918.397* | 1418 | 774.392 | 360 | .063† | .069† | .961† | .955† |
(.059–.066) | |||||||||
Scalar | 706 | 7042.664* | 1778 | 4124.267 | 360 | .105 | .098 | .863 | .873 |
(.102–.107) |
3.2 Results from alignment optimization
3.2.1 Job satisfaction
How often do you feel the following way about being a teacher? | R2 | Item parameter estimates in the alignment optimization metric | Countries with non-invariance | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mean | Std. Deviation | Minimum | Maximum | |||||
Est. | Country | Est. | Country | |||||
Intercept | ||||||||
I am content with my profession as a teacher | .770 | − .747 | .155 | − 1.071 | TWN | − .293 | GEO | AUS. TWN. GEO. ISR. MLT. QAT. UAED |
I am satisfied with being a teacher at this school | .542 | − .748 | .316 | − 1.203 | LTU | .520 | BWA | BWA. IRE. KOR. LTU. MOR. TUR |
I find my work full of meaning and purpose | .670 | − .751 | .134 | − 1.045 | SWE | − .474 | EGY | IRE. KOR. MLT. SAU. SWE. THA. TUR. EGY |
I am enthusiastic about my job | .808 | − .751 | .087 | − .909 | ENG | − .448 | THA | ISR. THA |
My work inspires me | .870 | − .745 | .086 | − .930 | KOR | − .491 | EGY | IRE. ISR. KOR. EGY |
I am proud of the work I do | .749 | − .760 | .122 | − .944 | ITA | − .364 | HGK | MOR |
I am going to continue teaching for as long as I can | .442 | − .742 | .262 | − 1.063 | KOR | .135 | MAR | CAN. ISR. KAZ. KOR. LBN. LTU. MYS. MOR. SAU. SVN. THA. CANON. CANQU |
Loading | ||||||||
I am content with my profession as a teacher | .619 | .993 | .094 | .680 | ARGBA | 1.178 | JOR | |
I am satisfied with being a teacher at this school | .357 | .994 | .151 | .523 | IRN | 1.243 | LBN | IRN |
I find my work full of meaning and purpose | .540 | .990 | .133 | .589 | GEO | 1.207 | ARGBA | AUS. IRE. MLT. USA |
I am enthusiastic about my job | .458 | .993 | .127 | .525 | ARGBA | 1.280 | TUR | SVN. ZAF. TUR |
My work inspires me | .683 | .994 | .075 | .798 | EGY | 1.187 | QAT | |
I am proud of the work I do | .226 | .996 | .154 | .618 | CANON | 1.428 | GEO | GEO. ITA. KOR. LTU. SGP |
I am going to continue teaching for as long as I can | .315 | .995 | .157 | .377 | ARGBA | 1.378 | KWT | OMN. SVN. ARGBA |
Average invariance index | .575 | |||||||
Total non-invariance | 8.85% |
3.2.2 Teacher perception of school emphasis on academic success
How would you characterize each of the following within your school? | R2 | Item parameter estimates in the alignment optimization metric | Countries with non-invariance | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mean | Std. Deviation | Minimum | Maximum | |||||
Est. | Country | Est. | Country | |||||
Intercept | ||||||||
Teachers’ understanding of the school’s curricular goals | .720 | − .646 | .278 | − 1.432 | JPN | − .070 | RUS | JPN. MOR. RUS |
Teachers’ degree of success in implementing the school’s curriculum | .734 | − .619 | .275 | − .985 | MYS | .410 | TWN | ARM. TWN |
Teachers’ expectations for student achievement | .431 | − .683 | .442 | − 1.634 | MAR | .001 | NZL | AUS. CAN. CHL. HUN. MOR. OMN. NZL. NOR. RUS. SGP. ZAF. SWE. THA. USA. ENG. UAEAD. CANON. CANQU |
Teachers working together to improve student achievement | .708 | − .694 | .285 | − 1.473 | MAR | − .164 | KWT | CHL. TWN. ISR. JPN. MOR. SGP |
Teachers’ ability to inspire students | .718 | − .690 | .274 | − 1.472 | QAT | − .028 | GEO | ARM. GEO. HUN. ITA. JPN. KOR |
Loading | ||||||||
Teachers’ understanding of the school’s curricular goals | .630 | .984 | .131 | .717 | JOR | 1.257 | MAR | |
Teachers’ degree of success in implementing the school’s curriculum | .756 | .982 | .105 | .736 | TWN | 1.313 | JPN | |
Teachers’ expectations for student achievement | .605 | .986 | .129 | .623 | JOR | 1.163 | AUS | |
Teachers working together to improve student achievement | .636 | .989 | .116 | .766 | ITA | 1.336 | KAZ | |
Teachers’ ability to inspire students | .536 | .987 | .142 | .701 | ITA | 1.314 | ARGBA | |
Average invariance index | .647 | |||||||
Total non-invariance | 7.83% |
3.2.3 Teacher perception of school conditions and resources
In your current school, how severe is each problem? | R2 | Item parameter estimates in the alignment optimization metric | Countries with non-invariance | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mean | Std. Deviation | Minimum | Maximum | |||||
Est. | Country | Est. | Country | |||||
Intercept | ||||||||
The school building needs significant repair | .531 | − .764 | .327 | − 1.704 | SAU | .435 | RUS | AUS. KAZ. MAR. NOR. RUS. SAU |
Teachers do not have adequate workspace (e.g., for preparation, collaboration, or meeting with students) | .567 | − .770 | .303 | − 1.288 | ZAF | .004 | ISR | CHL. IRE. ISR. ITA. KOR. QAT. SVN. UAE. USA. UAED |
Teachers do not have adequate instructional materials and supplies | .791 | − .768 | .166 | − 1.126 | MYS | − .476 | UAED | SVN. UAE. UAED. UAEAD. CANQU |
The school classrooms are not cleaned often enough | .635 | − .769 | .262 | − 1.163 | ARM | .227 | MYS | AUS. KAZ. LTU. MYS. RUS. SGP. SVN. ENG |
The school classrooms need maintenance work | .821 | − .781 | .224 | − 1.108 | CANQU | .137 | RUS | IRE. RUS. SVN. USA |
Teachers do not have adequate technological resources | .888 | − .768 | .243 | − 1.245 | SWE | .123 | MAR | CHL. IRE. MAR. EGY |
Teachers do not have adequate support for using technology | .793 | − .757 | .339 | − 1.358 | GEO | .461 | BWA | BWA. GEO. JPN. KAZ. KWT. LTU. MAR. SVN. UAE. EGY |
Loading | ||||||||
The school building needs significant repair | .285 | .996 | .149 | .712 | ITA | 1.541 | JPN | |
Teachers do not have adequate workspace (e.g., for preparation, collaboration, or meeting with students) | .501 | .989 | .162 | .531 | LTU | 1.51 | JPN | LTU |
Teachers do not have adequate instructional materials and supplies | .661 | .990 | .092 | .301 | ARM | 1.133 | HUN | |
The school classrooms are not cleaned often enough | .247 | .987 | .291 | .717 | ARGBA | 1.737 | CANQU | ARM. HUN. KWT. LTU CANQU |
The school classrooms need maintenance work | .657 | .987 | .118 | .672 | ITA | 1.234 | ARM/NOR | |
Teachers do not have adequate technological resources | .696 | .987 | .109 | .784 | JPN | 1.281 | LTU | LTU |
Teachers do not have adequate support for using technology | .622 | .984 | .133 | .583 | BWA | 1.284 | ARGAB | |
Average invariance index | .621 | |||||||
Total non-invariance | 8.39% |
3.2.4 Teacher perception of safe and orderly school
Thinking about your current school. Indicate the extent to which you agree or disagree with each of the following statements. | R2 | Item parameter estimates in the alignment optimization metric | Countries with non-invariance | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mean | Std. Deviation | Minimum | Maximum | |||||
Est. | Country | Est. | Country | |||||
Intercept | ||||||||
This school is located in a safe neighborhood | .486 | − 1.151 | .554 | − 1.810 | BHR | 1.105 | ARGBA | BHR. CHL. NOR. UAE. UAED. ARGBA |
I feel safe at this school | .607 | − 1.144 | .292 | − 1.797 | SWE | .178 | BWA | ARM |
This school’s security policies and practices are sufficient | .663 | − 1.092 | .416 | − 1.543 | SWE | .982 | BWA | BWA. IRE. LTU |
The students behave in an orderly manner | .752 | − 1.037 | .231 | − 1.319 | ZAF | − .359 | KWT | ARM. ISR. KWT. LBN. LTU. OMN. NZL. NOR. THA. UAE. EGY. UAEAD |
The students are respectful of the teachers | .726 | − 1.031 | .182 | − 1.580 | BWA | − .511 | JPN | ARM. JPN. KWT. LTU |
The students respect school property | .832 | − 1.030 | .155 | − 1.420 | LBN | − .708 | NOR | LBN |
This school has clear rules about student conduct | .499 | − 1.031 | .186 | − 1.469 | RUS | − .537 | JPN | RUS |
This school’s rules are enforced in a fair and consistent manner | .369 | − 1.039 | .284 | − 1.568 | BWA | − .479 | CANQU | AUS. CAN. CHL. HUN. IRE. NZL. NOR. RUS. USA. CANQU |
Loading | ||||||||
This school is located in a safe neighborhood | .294 | .967 | .412 | .051 | ARGBA | 1.830 | TUR | KWT. MAR. OMN. QAT. UAE. TUR. UAED |
I feel safe at this school | .365 | .966 | .356 | .233 | NOR | 1.749 | JPN | TWN. ISR. ITA. JPN. KWT. MAR. OMN. NOR. ZAF. UAE. TUR. UAEAD |
This school’s security policies and practices are sufficient | .476 | .973 | .248 | .455 | ARM | 1.513 | TUR | KOR. LTU. MAR. SAU. SVN. SWE. TUR |
The students behave in an orderly manner | .734 | .988 | .102 | .774 | KWT | 1.254 | ARGBA | |
The students are respectful of the teachers | .689 | .989 | .114 | .776 | EGY | 1.531 | ARGBA | |
The students respect school property | .73 | .987 | .099 | .747 | KAZ | 1.314 | ARM | |
This school has clear rules about student conduct | .45 | .973 | .226 | .506 | RUS | 1.366 | KWT | KWT. OMN. RUS. ZAF. EGY |
This school’s rules are enforced in a fair and consistent manner | .53 | .982 | .167 | .526 | ARM | 1.243 | RUS | IRN |
Average invariance index | .575 | |||||||
Total non-invariance | 9.78% |
3.2.5 Teacher’s self-efficacy
In teaching mathematics to this class, how would you characterize your confidence in doing the following? | R2 | Item parameter estimates in the alignment optimization metric | Countries with non-invariance | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mean | Std. Deviation | Minimum | Maximum | |||||
Est. | Country | Est. | Country | |||||
Intercept | ||||||||
Inspiring students to learn mathematics | .668 | − .919 | .274 | − 1.570 | SAU | − .378 | LTN | BHR. BWA. JOR. KWT. LBN. LTU. MAR. SAU. ZAF. EGY. NOR |
Showing students a variety of problem-solving strategies | .817 | − .909 | .189 | − 1.453 | SWE | − .583 | IRN | SWE. UAE. USA |
Providing challenging tasks for the highest achieving students | .591 | − .897 | .335 | − 1.490 | NOR8 | .008 | TUR | LBN. LTU. MYS. OMN. SVN. TUR. ENG. NOR. UAED |
Adapting my teaching to engage students’ interest | .809 | − .909 | .209 | − 1.869 | JPN | − .453 | RUS | JPN. RUS |
Helping students appreciate the value of learning mathematics | .811 | − .928 | .173 | − 1.520 | JPN | − .635 | SVN | GEO. IRN. SVN |
Assessing student comprehension of mathematics | .520 | − .882 | .261 | − 1.469 | CANQU | − .248 | SAU | AUS. CAN. GEO. IRE. ISR. JOR. SAU. SWE. USA. CANQU. ARGBA |
Improving the understanding of struggling students | .161 | − .880 | .331 | − 1.474 | IRN | − .069 | EGY | AUS. CHL. IRN. JOR. KWT. MYS. MAR. OMN. TUR. EGY |
Making mathematics relevant to students | .863 | − .901 | .171 | − 1.380 | LTU | − .198 | TWN | BWA. TWN. LTU. MYS. TUR |
Developing students’ higher-order thinking skills | .897 | − .897 | .163 | − 1.392 | ARM | − .495 | RUS | ARM. OMN. RUS. SVN |
Loading | ||||||||
Inspiring students to learn mathematics | .387 | .992 | .156 | .603 | EGY | 1.319 | SWE | AUS. MAR. ZAF. SWE. EGY |
Showing students a variety of problem solving strategies | .641 | .993 | .090 | .787 | BHR | 1.231 | IRE | IRE |
Providing challenging tasks for the highest achieving students | .470 | .994 | .116 | .552 | LBN | 1.184 | ZAF | |
Adapting my teaching to engage students’ interest | .489 | .996 | .091 | .785 | KWT | 1.22 | SWE | |
Helping students appreciate the value of learning mathematics | .302 | .997 | .122 | .701 | KWT | 1.302 | HKG | IRN. KWT. MAR |
Assessing student comprehension of mathematics | .292 | .998 | .121 | .772 | IRE | 1.257 | ARM | IRE |
Improving the understanding of struggling students | .315 | .998 | .114 | .757 | TUR | 1.25 | LBN | |
Making mathematics relevant to students | .607 | .995 | .083 | .728 | LTU | 1.189 | ARGBA | LTU |
Developing students’ higher-order thinking skills | .645 | .996 | .072 | .790 | SAU | 1.196 | BWA | |
Average invariance index | .571 | |||||||
Total non-invariance | 8.58% |
3.3 Monte Carlo simulation
Monte Carlo Design | n = 500 | nrep = 100 | n = 1000 | nrep = 100 |
---|---|---|---|---|
Estimated statistics | Average | SD | Average | SD |
Job satisfaction | ||||
Factor mean | .99 | .003 | .99 | .001 |
Factor variance | .95 | .013 | .97 | .006 |
School emphasis on academic success | ||||
Factor mean | .98 | .007 | .99 | .005 |
Factor variance | .96 | .012 | .98 | .006 |
School condition and resources | ||||
Factor mean | .99 | .002 | 1.00 | .001 |
Factor variance | .97 | .008 | .98 | .004 |
Safe and orderly school | ||||
Factor mean | .99 | .003 | .99 | .088 |
Factor variance | .98 | .007 | .98 | .094 |
Teacher’s self-efficacy | ||||
Factor mean | 1.00 | .002 | 1.00 | .001 |
Factor variance | .98 | .007 | .97 | .007 |
3.4 Average estimates of intercepts and factor loadings across invariant groups
v | Nv | λ | Nλ | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Job satisfaction | ||||
I am content with my profession as a teacher | 1.259 | 39 | .423 | 46 |
I am satisfied with being a teacher at this school | 1.323 | 40 | .376 | 45 |
I find my work full of meaning and purpose | 1.157 | 38 | .395 | 42 |
I am enthusiastic about my job | 1.138 | 44 | .466 | 43 |
My work inspires me | 1.221 | 42 | .516 | 46 |
I am proud of the work I do | 1.133 | 45 | .401 | 41 |
I am going to continue teaching for as long as I can | 1.301 | 33 | .468 | 43 |
School emphasis on academic success (teachers) | ||||
Teachers’ understanding of the school’s curricular goals | 3.929 | 42 | .459 | 46 |
Teachers’ degree of success in implementing the school’s curriculum | 3.682 | 44 | .530 | 46 |
Teachers’ expectations for student achievement | 3.526 | 28 | .533 | 46 |
Teachers working together to improve student achievement | 3.646 | 40 | .589 | 46 |
Teachers’ ability to inspire students | 3.578 | 40 | .540 | 46 |
School condition and resources | ||||
The school building needs significant repair | 1.566 | 40 | .540 | 46 |
Teachers do not have adequate workspace (e.g., for preparation, collaboration, or meeting with students) | 1.384 | 36 | .611 | 45 |
Teachers do not have adequate instructional materials and supplies | 1.364 | 41 | .660 | 46 |
The school classrooms are not cleaned often enough | 1.231 | 38 | .380 | 41 |
The school classrooms need maintenance work | 1.471 | 42 | .529 | 46 |
Teachers do not have adequate technological resources | 1.516 | 42 | .609 | 45 |
Teachers do not have adequate support for using technology | 1.517 | 36 | .557 | 46 |
Safe and orderly school | ||||
This school is located in a safe neighborhood | 1.165 | 40 | .191 | 39 |
I feel safe at this school | 1.037 | 45 | .184 | 34 |
This school’s security policies and practices are sufficient | 1.166 | 43 | .213 | 39 |
The students behave in an orderly manner | 1.222 | 33 | .454 | 46 |
The students are respectful of the teachers | 1.180 | 42 | .446 | 46 |
The students respect school property | 1.427 | 45 | .457 | 46 |
This school has clear rules about student conduct | 1.165 | 45 | .271 | 41 |
This school’s rules are enforced in a fair and consistent manner | 1.211 | 35 | .331 | 45 |
Self-efficacy | ||||
Inspiring students to learn mathematics | 1.416 | 35 | .436 | 41 |
Showing students a variety of problem-solving strategies | 1.388 | 43 | .398 | 45 |
Providing challenging tasks for the highest achieving students | 1.616 | 36 | .407 | 46 |
Adapting my teaching to engage students’ interest | 1.463 | 44 | .452 | 46 |
Helping students appreciate the value of learning mathematics | 1.375 | 43 | .488 | 43 |
Assessing student comprehension of mathematics | 1.508 | 34 | .399 | 45 |
Improving the understanding of struggling students | 1.550 | 36 | .445 | 46 |
Making mathematics relevant to students | 1.483 | 41 | .493 | 45 |
Developing students’ higher-order thinking skills | 1.598 | 42 | .495 | 46 |