Skip to main content

2023 | Buch

The Political Economy of Green Bonds in Emerging Markets

South Africa's Faltering Transition

insite
SUCHEN

Über dieses Buch

Funding low-carbon transitions to address climate change is one of the major challenges of our time. Green bonds have emerged as a powerful tool to enlist institutional investors’ wealth for these transitions. But despite exponential growth in many parts of the world, the green bond market in South Africa has been stalling. This book project grapples with this puzzle. Firstly, it debunks some of the promises underpinning green bond markets and traces the manifold practices undergirding its promotion. Secondly, it identifies some barriers prohibiting the expansion of green bonds in emerging markets and zooms in on the depoliticizing tendencies a transition premised on financial innovation produces. Thirdly, this work discloses the idiosyncratic political economic challenges of a fossil-based economy in transition and shines a light on the competing elements of a ‘green’ and a ‘just’ transition. It argues that the limited uptake of green bonds can best be explained by the instrument’s inability to adequately incorporate the various demands levied on South Africa’s contested transition trajectory. In so doing, this book contributes important new qualitative insights into green bond markets-in-the-making and extends political economic scholarship on finance-led transition endeavors in emerging markets.

Chapters 3 and 6 is available open access under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License via link.springer.com.

Inhaltsverzeichnis

Frontmatter
Chapter 1. Green Bonds and the Long Way to Paris
Abstract
How do you fund low-carbon transitions in emerging economies? This chapter describes the challenges around funding responses to climate change and the various shortcomings in closing the investment gap. It, then, introduces green bonds as a purported capital market solution witnessing astounding growth rates across global markets. By noting the dearth of green bond issuances in emerging markets outside China, this introduction sets the scene for the South African case and, thus, into the political economy of green bonds in fossil-based emerging markets.
Manuel Neumann
Chapter 2. What Do We Already Know About Green Bonds? A Literature Review
Abstract
This chapter traces the emergence of green bonds as a concept and reviews the academic literature dealing with this financial innovation. It clusters the literature into marketeers, reformists, and critics of this nascent instrument and draws out their contributions towards our understanding of green bonds. In a second step, this chapter identifies some of the gaps in the literature that this book seeks to fill.
Manuel Neumann

Open Access

Chapter 3. Towards New Approaches of Understanding the Greening of Capital Markets
Abstract
This chapter combines different approaches to capture the discursive, financial(ized), and political-economic aspects of efforts to green capital markets. To understand the stalling uptake of green bonds, it introduces Cultural Political Economy (CPE), financialization, and Transition Studies as useful approaches to foreground discursive elements in nascent market promotion, the repositioning of the financial sector as a main driver in low-carbon transitions under the so-called Wall Street Consensus, and the political economic bottlenecks a fossil-based economy like South Africa faces.
Manuel Neumann
Chapter 4. The Political Economy of Greening South Africa’s Capital Markets
Abstract
This chapter outlines historical factors that contributed to South Africa’s current capital market setup. It develops four overarching political economic themes relevant for the discussion: Tracing the emergence of the Johannesburg Stock exchange and its deep ties to the mining industry, it initially proposes that the persistence of the so-called Minerals-Energy Complex affects green alternatives. By portraying the presidents Thabo Mbeki, Jacob Zuma, and Cyril Ramaphosa in more detail, this chapter further delineates the legitimacy and capacity crisis of the governing African National Congress, which inhibits its ability to drive the transition. Thirdly, the uneven and unequal aftermath of the financial crisis is briefly sketched out to make the case for emboldened financial markets in South Africa. Lastly, other crisis moments like the energy crisis or the unemployment exacerbated under the Covid-19 pandemic are presented to argue that climate change governance faces significant competition from other developmental policy priorities.
Manuel Neumann
Chapter 5. A Stalling Green Bond Take-Off
Abstract
Why have green bonds not taken off in South Africa? This chapter elaborates on the findings of my empirical research and touches on different compounding factors that inhibit the uptake of green bonds in the country. I structured the findings into seven complementary pillars: First, the general promises of green bonds are assessed against South Africa’s background as an emerging (green bond) market. Second, green bond success stories are analyzed before the instruments ‘simple’ setup is evaluated. In a next step, controversial bond issuances fanning concerns of greenwashing at the global level will be juxtaposed with ongoing deliberations of a national green finance taxonomy. In a fifth step, I dwell on the peculiarities of the capital markets in South Africa and discuss its bottlenecks. I then revisit the rifts between a green and a just transition and, at last, illustrate new arenas of redistributive struggles de-risked spaces have (unintentionally) created.
Manuel Neumann

Open Access

Chapter 6. The Limits of Green Finance in Fossil-Based Emerging Economies—Lessons Beyond South Africa
Abstract
What do the findings imply? In this chapter, I situate the seven empirical findings developed in the previous chapter within the theoretical debates around Cultural Political Economy, financialization, and Transition Studies. After grounding these findings and demonstrating their significance for debates on finance-driven transition endeavors, I zoom out into the wider implications of green bond diffusion in South Africa and beyond. In the end, I discuss potential remedies to the shortcomings of green bonds and point out avenues for further research.
Manuel Neumann
Backmatter
Metadaten
Titel
The Political Economy of Green Bonds in Emerging Markets
verfasst von
Manuel Neumann
Copyright-Jahr
2023
Electronic ISBN
978-3-031-30502-3
Print ISBN
978-3-031-30501-6
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-30502-3

Premium Partner