Evaluation of the Possibility to Obtain Nanostructured Bainite in High-Carbon and High-Silicon 9XC Bearing Steel

Bhadeshia and Edmonds (Ref 1) were the first to introduce methods for designing steels with high mechanical properties that are characterized by a microstructure consisting of nanometric-scale bainitic ferrite laths and austenite with film-like morphology. To obtain nanostructured bainite (NB), the heat treatment included low-temperature long-term annealing is performed (Ref 2-6). The chemical composition of steel is also an important factor in designing nanobainitic steel. Elements such as carbon, silicon and manganese significantly enhance the austenite mechanical stability (Ref 7). Sufficient amount of Si (more than 1.5 wt.%) retards the precipitation of carbides into bainite plates (Ref 4, 8-10). The nanobainitic steels exhibit high tensile strength (over 2000 MPa), ductility (up to 14%) and fracture toughness (40 MPa m^1/2) (Ref 3, 9, 11-13). Besides, steel after isothermal heat treatment is less prone to quench cracking and generation of undesirable tensile residual stresses at the surface (Ref 10, 13). Due to the high mechanical properties, NB steels are widely used in industrial areas and applied in roller bearings (Ref 2, 11, 14), ballistic shields (Ref 15) and railways (Ref 12, 14). Moreover, in 2009 one of the largest rolling bearing companies established a technical center in cooperation with Cambridge University where the nanostructured bainite discoverer works (Ref 11). This fact and numerous researches demonstrate a step toward the industrialization of these microstructures (Ref 16).

In the last few years, research of nanostructured bainite in bearing steels has developed significantly. Zhang et al. (Ref 17) developed a method of producing a NB structure in the surface layer of carburized steel. Hereby, higher wear resistance and a higher fatigue life for rolling contact were obtained (Ref 18). Due to these properties, this technique is suitable for the production of the bearing (Ref 6, 11). However, the vast majority of research still concerns only specially designed chemical compositions (Ref 10, 19, 20), and only a small amount of commercially available bearing steels (Ref 4, 13, 21, 22). The present paper aims to study the microstructure and of 9XC grade (according to GOST standard) bearing steel subjected to two different isothermal heat treatments, to examine the possibility of obtaining a nanostructured bainite. The obtaining of NB with high mechanical properties in commercially available bearing steel makes the possibility to easier use this material for industrial production. The chemical compositions of the other bearing steels with a microstructure of nanostructured bainite were compared as given in Table 1 with the studied bearing 9XC steel.

In this work was analyzed low-temperature isothermal heat treatment aimed at achieving high properties that are important for bearing steels (hardness, abrasive resistance, contact fatigue). Maximization of these mechanical properties can be achieved by low-temperature bainitic transformation and microstructure consisting of nanometric-scale baintic ferrite laths and austenite with dominant film-like morphology (Ref 12, 23-25). For this reason, an isothermal heat treatment was designed in the temperature range of 250-300 °C.

Prior austenite grain size impacts the mechanical properties of nanobainite (NB) (Ref 31) by direct influence on the kinetics of transformation (Ref 32) and hence the resulting microstructure (Ref 30, 33). Revealed prior austenite grains after austenitization in tested temperature exhibited stable growth, and no abnormal grains were found (Fig. 2). The histogram of the grain size was characterized by a normal distribution (Fig. 2b). Due to the higher tolerance to outliers, the median better represents the actual grain size than the average value. For this reason, both mean, standard deviation and the median were compared (Table 5). In simplified terms, the \(\frac{1}{2}\) interquartile range value was considered to be a spread. Thus, it was determined that the grain diameter for the austenitization tested conditions was 14.5 ± 4.1 μm. The obtained result indicates that at 950 °C the prior austenite grain boundaries are stable and do not exhibit any anomalies. The average grain diameter corresponds approximately to No. 9 according to ASM 112.

The results of hardness measurements are presented in Table 6. For sample B-250-120, the hardness was 630.0 ± 4.4 HV1, which can be estimated to 57 HRC. In contrast, sample B-300-72 had a much lower level of hardness, which was 517.3 ± 1.1 HV1 (approximately 50 HRC). It was also found that the average value of B-250-120 sample with 95% confidence is within the range of [617.8; 642.2], while B-300-72 sample in the range of [514.2; 520.5]. Thus, the difference between the samples is significant and exceeds 100 HV. To explain the difference in hardness, a detailed microstructure analysis was carried out in the following sections.

The microstructure of both samples consists of bainitic ferrite laths and retained austenite. The bainitic ferrite packets exhibited different orientations in the area of prior austenite grains (Fig. 3). The width of the bainitic ferrite packets was smaller for the B-250-1200 sample (Fig. 3a) compared to the B-300-72 sample (Fig. 3b). However, it should be highlighted that this does not allow to determine the width of the bainitic ferrite laths, which are located in the single packet. A clear difference was found in the content of austenite with blocky morphology. Based on the light microscopy photomicrographs of the B-250-120 sample, it was determined that austenite with blocky morphology did not occur (Fig. 3a). On the other hand, for the B-300-72 sample, the content of blocky austenite is relatively high, and the dimensions of the austenite islands are relatively large (Fig. 3b). Due to the nanometric scale of austenite with film-like morphology, its presence cannot be determined based on light microscopy.

Identification using the SEM method allowed the revealing of ferrite lath morphology inside bainite packets (Fig. 4). It was found that for both samples, refined bainitic ferrite laths occurred in the area of the packets. On the other hand, this method also does not allow the assessment of the microstructure refinement, because the dimensions of austenite with film-like morphology may exceed the resolution limit of the used scanning electron microscope. A significant difference was also found in the term of content and size of blocky austenite. In the case of the B-250-120 sample, locally blocky austenite occurred and was characterized by small dimensions (Fig. 4b). On the other hand, the identified blocky austenite in case of the B-300-72 sample was found in a higher content and formed islands of relatively large dimensions (usually about 1-3 μm) (Fig. 4d).

The TEM investigations and the SAED method were used to assess the microstructure refinement and identification of austenite with film-like morphology. The microstructure of both samples consisted of bainitic ferrite laths and film-like austenite (Fig. 5). The austenite with film-like morphology was distributed between the bainitic ferrite laths. To estimate the refinement of bainitic ferrite laths and film-like austenite, bright-field image photomicrographs were selected and the widths of laths were measured. Representative TEM photomicrographs are shown in Fig. 6. It was found that the B-250-120 sample was characterized by smaller dimensions of microstructure components. The width of bainitic ferrite laths mainly was in the range of 60-130 nm, while the width of film-like austenite was in the range of 30-40 nm. It can be stated that the obtained microstructure generally meets the requirements for nanostructure (dimensions below 100 nm). The presence of bainitic ferrite laths with a width exceeding 100 nm was also identified, but laths with lower widths (below 100 nm) predominated. However, the B-300-72 sample was characterized by the coarser microstructure components. The width of bainitic ferrite laths was in the range of 120-150 nm, and in the range of 30-110 nm for film-like austenite. Thus, the temperature of the isothermal heat treatment affected the width of the bainitic ferrite laths as well as the austenite with film-like morphology.

Crystallographic orientations between ferrite and austenite in steels are described by four main relationships (OR): Bain OR (Ref 34), Kurdjumov–Sachs (K-S) OR (Ref 35), Greninger–Troiano (G–T) OR (Ref 36) and Nishiyama–Wassermann (N–W) OR (Ref 37). The most common crystalline orientation relationships (OR) between the face-centered cubic (fcc) and body-centered cubic (bcc) structures are by Nishiyama–Wassermann (N–W) and Kurdjumov–Sachs (K-S) (Ref 38). In nanobainitic steel, the orientations between bainitic ferrite and retained austenite are similar to that between the N–W and K-S orientations, which is confirmed in Ref 39. There is an assumption that the close-packed plane {110} of the bainitic ferrite is parallel to the {111} plane of the austenite, meaning that propagation of the bainite sheaves has specific orientations with the parent phase (austenite) (Ref 40). There are 24 variants in the K-S relationship and 12 variants in the N–W relationship between bainitic ferrite and austenite (Ref 41, 42). It was found that the orientation between bainitic ferrite and austenite in the case of B-250-120 sample was approximately consistent with N–W OR: \(\left[ {0\bar{1}1]_{\alpha } \parallel } \right[\bar{1}\bar{1}2]_{\gamma } , {\text{and}} \left( {011} \right)_{\alpha } \parallel \left( {111} \right)_{\gamma } - {\text{variant V}}3\) (Fig. 7c) and in the case of the B-300-72 sample was approximately consistent with K-S OR: \(\left[ {01\bar{1}]_{\gamma } \parallel } \right[\bar{1}1\bar{1}]_{\alpha } {\text{and}} \left( {111} \right)_{\gamma } \parallel \left( {110} \right)_{\alpha } - {\text{variant}} {\text{V}}4\) (Fig. 8c). Therefore, the obtained microstructures consisted of ferrite and austenite films, which confirms the received of the nanostructured bainite. Besides, cementite precipitations inside bainitic ferrite with nanometric dimensions were locally found for both samples (Fig. 7a and 8a). Thus, the amount of silicon in 9XC steel was sufficient to retard the cementite precipitation from austenite and limited the cementite precipitation from the bainitic ferrite.

Silicon retards the carbide precipitation in the process during the isothermal annealing and hereby increases carbon content in retained austenite, which enhances the austenite stability. According to Zhao et al. (Ref 10), high Si content leads to the increase in retained austenite fraction and causes a carbide-free bainitic microstructure in annealed samples. In the tested 9XC steel with 1.54% Si content, nanostructured bainite with limited content of cementite was obtained, which confirms the impact of silicon content on the microstructure morphology.

The relatively fine prior austenite grains were obtained (median form grain diameter: 14.5 ± 4.1 μm). The refinement of the austenite grain structure accelerates the bainitic transformation rate (Ref 31) and enhances ferrite formation due to the presence of more nucleation sites (Ref 43), thereby increasing mechanical properties of nanobainitic structure (Ref 31).

Based on experimental results, 9XC steel annealed at a lower temperature (250 °C) has slightly lower dimensions of structure components (bainitic ferrite and austenite) and mostly fulfills the requirement of nanostructure (dimensions below 100 nm). Sample annealed at a higher temperature (300 °C) consists of a higher fraction of retained austenite with blocky morphology and slightly higher dimensions of bainitic ferrite laths compared to lower temperature of annealing (250 °C). With the increase in blocky retained austenite, the microstructure becomes more coarse. The volume fraction of blocky austenite and thickness of filmy austenite increased with an increase in annealing temperature, which is also confirmed in research (Ref 44). This is well known that the ultimate tensile strength of nanobainitic steels depends on the thickness of bainitic laths (Ref 45). The sample in which the nanostructured bainite was obtained is characterized by much higher hardness parameters (57 HRC) than the sample containing slightly coarser bainitic ferrite laths (50 HRC). Compared to other bearing nanobainitic steels, the obtained results had a comparable level of hardness (Table 7). It should be noted that the highest hardness was obtained for isothermal treatment performed below 250 °C, which indicates that it is possible to increase the hardness of 9XC steel by reducing the temperature of isothermal heat treatment. On the other hand, the results obtained for the B-250-120 sample are satisfactory due to the relatively high hardness, relatively short isothermal treatment time and the obtained microstructure.

There are two types of retained austenite morphology: film-type and blocky-type. Retained austenite with film-like morphology has higher stability compared with a blocky morphology due to higher carbon content and dislocation density (Ref 31, 46). Filmy austenite is characterized by nanometric size of films width in the range of 15-100 nm (Ref 45). The less mechanical stable austenite will easier transform into martensite under stress (Ref 6, 19). Based on results, both types of retained austenite were identified in the microstructures. Sample annealed at lower temperatures had a lower content of austenite with blocky morphology. According to Zhang et al. (Ref 18), the film-like austenite between the ferrite prevents cracks from nucleating and extending. Therefore, the aim was also to minimize the content of unstable blocky austenite, thereby increasing mechanical properties such as hardness, impact toughness (Ref 47) of the nanobainitic steels. On the other hand, mechanically unstabilized retained austenite improves ductility and total elongation (Ref 48). Thus, a low fraction of blocky retained austenite in B-250-120 sample is preferred.

Obtaining nanostructured bainite in commercially available steel means the possibility of its applicability in industrial areas. However, further research should be focused on isothermal treatment in a low-temperature range (even below 250 °C) to maximize the mechanical properties. The tested steel contains a relatively small amount of Mn and Cr, which reduces hardenability but accelerates the bainitic transformation (Ref 16). After quenching in the designed cooling medium to isothermal temperature (liquid tin bath), bainitic structure without transformation diffusion-type products was obtained, which confirms the sufficient hardenability of this steel. The acceleration of bainitic transformation time also leads to lower costs, which is significant in the context of industrial application. This requires specifying the end time of the bainitic transformation. However, the precise determination of the end of the bainitic transformation is complex and subjective (Ref 49), which may cause contradictions and require further investigations. Besides, performing the treatment proposed in (Ref 50) could increase the hardness and mechanical and thermal stability of the microstructure. Thus, the tested steel can find its applications for bearings after improving heat treatment parameters and microstructure.

In this research, the evaluation of the possibility to obtain nanostructured bainite in the commercial grade of steel (9XC according to GOST) was determined. The following conclusions were formulated from the performed investigations::