Coke is the only raw material which remains solid even in the lowest zone of a blast furnace. The bed-permeability in the bosh zone of the blast furnace is maintained by the solid coke structure. The wetting behaviour of slags in the coke bed of the bosh region in a blast furnace plays a very important role in the process by directly influencing the free movement of the burden and furnace gas and thereby affecting the fuel consumption. Cokes of unsuitable quality will lead to lower permeability in the bosh zone and hinder the furnace operation. In this work, various industrial coke samples are treated with slags of different basicities in a drop-shape analysis facility at a high temperature similar to process conditions. The coke samples have been treated under standard CRI (Coke Reactivity Index) test conditions beforehand in order to simulate the process more closely. The results display the variations in wetting behaviour, temperature, and time for different coke and slag combinations as a function of coke properties and slag compositions. The wetting behaviour at the coke/hot metal interface has also been investigated. The results provide a better understanding of the solid-liquid interaction which takes place in the bosh region of the blast furnace.
1 Introduction
The permeability of the bosh zone of a blast furnace greatly affects its performance. Coke plays the most crucial role in maintaining bed permeability and thereby ensuring a proper gas flow through the bed. After passing through the stack, the burden materials reach the bosh zone where softening and melting are started. The major exception is coke as it still remains in the solid state. Coke is the only raw material which remains solid at the lowest zone of the blast furnace. Before reaching the bosh region, coke suffers both chemical and mechanical degradation during its descent through the stack by Boudouard reaction and simultaneous mechanical abrasion respectively. The coke becomes more porous than its original structure after being treated by reactive gases [1]. Nevertheless, the bed permeability in this zone is maintained by the solid coke structure. The coke must possess a certain size and strength for an efficient operation. Cokes of unsuitable quality will lead to a lower permeability in the bosh zone and hamper the furnace operation [2]. The viscosity of bosh slags and their tendency for static holdup in the coke bed of the bosh region in the blast furnace together play an important role in the process operation by directly influencing the free movement of both burden and furnace gas and thereby affecting the process efficiency. The impervious and viscous liquid formed by slag and molten iron does not allow the ascending gas to flow through it. Only the permeable coke layers, also known as coke-slits, distribute the gas and allow it to flow upwards [3]. Hence, the wetting property of bosh slag with coke surface directly affects the bed permeability. The current work discusses more concisely the novel laboratory scale experimental method to investigate the wetting behaviour of different slags with various industrial coke samples under attainable simulated conditions of the bosh region as shown by Bhattacharyya et al. [4]. The results depict the variation of coke quality (in terms of reactivity) and slag basicity as the main factors of different wetting situations. Novel sets of experiments have also been performed to find out the wetting phenomenon between coke and hot metal interface.
2 Background
The aim of this work is to achieve a closer process simulation under laboratory scale conditions. George et al. explain the flow mechanism of molten slag through coke channels [5] and coke packed beds [6]. These studies have been designed to find out the high temperature flow phenomena through packed beds. Husslage et al. have characterized the flow of both slag and hot metal through coke packed beds [7]. Interaction and interfacial reactions between coke analogues (pulverized and pressed coke substrates) or synthetic graphite/slag interface have been studied by various researchers in the recent past [8‐10].
Anzeige
Bhattacharyya et al. [4] have showed an effective way of using industrial coke specimens directly in the experiments instead of using synthetic graphite or coke analogues in order to remain as closely as possible to actual process conditions. As a further step, to simulate the comparable porous coke structure at the bosh zone (after solution loss reaction), the coke pieces (later to be used as substrates) were treated under standard CRI (Coke Reactivity Index) conditions as per ISO 18894. [11] These coke pieces were used as the substrates against slag beads prepared by melting in the laboratory as well as real hot metal samples from the industry.
3 Experimental Procedure
The experiments performed in the current work have been done in a number of successive steps. To make it easier to understand, the whole experimental framework can be compartmentalized into the following steps –
Step 1: Production of thin coke pieces (to be used as substrates later) from bigger lumps
Step 2: Laboratory melting and preparation of slag samples
Anzeige
Step 3: CRI treatment of coke pieces
Step 4: Drop Shape Analysis (DSA) or Sessile Drop Test (SDT) of coke/slag combinations
3.1 Step 1
Three types of industrial blast furnace cokes (C1, C2, and C3) from different origins were used. The samples for DSA tests were obtained from bigger lumps by cutting thin sections of coke using a boron carbide cutting wheel. The sections were cut parallel to one direction in order to achieve almost parallel sides of the substrate material. The thickness of the sections was maintained in the range of 2‑3 mm.
3.2 Step 2
A four component slag system consisting of CaO, MgO, Al2O3, and SiO2 were used for the purpose of the experiments. The components were varied in order to get four slags of different basicities. The exact amounts of components which correspond to actual slag compositions in the bosh region were acquired from industrial data as well as from standard literature [3]. The two component (B2) and four component (B4) basicities are calculated as follows –
B2 = (%CaO)/(%SiO2)
B4 = (%CaO+ %MgO)/(%SiO2+ %Al2O3)
The slag components are shown in Table 1. The viscosity values are calculated from Factsage 6.4 at 1600oC, which is above the liquidus temperature for all slags. A high alumina slag was also taken into consideration.
TABLE 1:
Slag properties
CaO (%)
MgO (%)
Al2O3 (%)
SiO2 (%)
B2
B4
Viscosity
(Poise)
Remarks
Slag I
39.5
11.8
10
38.7
1.02
1.05
1.362
Low Basicity
Slag II
43.2
10.4
8.3
38.1
1.13
1.15
1.214
Medium Basicity
Slag III
52.6
4.5
4.7
38.2
1.38
1.08
1.036
High Basicity
Slag IV
35
10.7
27
27.3
1.28
0.84
1.544
High Alumina
The individual oxide components were taken in fine powder form in their respective mass percentages and mixed extensively to make a homogenous mixture of fine powders. Then the powder was filled in a platinum crucible and heated up to 1700oC in a high temperature vertical tube furnace (GERO-1700). The melt was allowed to diffuse for three hours. Then the crucible was taken out at hot condition (1700oC), and the melt was immediately poured into cold water to get small glassy beads of slag. These beads were used later for DSA tests.
3.3 Step 3
As the coke lumps descend through the stack of the blast furnace, they are attacked by reactive gases. The CRI test is the globally accepted standard to find out the coke reactivity under blast furnace conditions. The CRI tests were performed at the reduction metallurgy laboratory of the Chair of Ferrous Metallurgy, Montanuniversität Leoben. For reactivity tests, a vertical tube furnace, constructed by Siemens VAI Metals Technologies, Austria, was used. The equipment and procedure for determining the reactivity and strength of the coke samples are based on the standard testing procedure of ISO 18894 (2006) [11]. The thin coke sections prepared before were placed inside the retort for the CRI test period and then taken out and further used as substrates for DSA tests. In this way, an effort has been made to simulate the porous coke structure which is similar to the coke structure in the bosh region.
3.4 Step 4
The DSA tests were performed using a high-temperature horizontal tube furnace (Manufacturer – Krüss GmbH, Model – DSA10 HT) in which the substrate along with the droplet is placed and heated at the desired temperature. The magnified image of the droplet is captured by a FALCON Image Grabber camera. The images could be processed using the Windows based software SW 21 (DSA1 v.1.80) for automated contact angle measurements using Young-Laplace curve fitting method. The furnace is shown in Fig. 1.
Fig. 1
Furnace for DSA tests
×
The following heating program was used for all coke/slag or coke/hot metal combinations. All the steps were performed in an argon (Ar 5.0) atmosphere.
15o C/min until 1200oC
10o C/ min thereafter
Holding at 1600oC for 30 min
Program Stops
Cooling in furnace to room temperature
Fig. 2 shows the preliminary steps for the tests. The coke sample together with the slag bead is placed on a protective refractory plate and then pushed into the middle of the furnace by two parallel rails. A platinum thermocouple (Type B) detects the temperature. The mass of the slag bead is always approximately 1/10th of the coke piece, i.e. if the coke piece has a mass of 1 g, the slag bead should have a mass of around 0.1 g. For hot metal (HM) samples, the mass of the HM piece is around ½ of the mass of the coke substrate.
Fig. 2
Test setup. (a) Coke sample with slag bead before entering the furnace, (b) Zoomed part of fig. (a), (c) Coke substrate and slag bead on the refractory plate
×
A representative experimental observation is shown in Fig. 3. (C1/Slag II combination) -
Fig. 3
Molten slag on coke surface at 1480oC, (b) Change of contact angle at 1593oC, (c) Slag droplet just before sinking during holding at 1600oC
×
4 Results and Discussion
The proximate analyses of the coke samples are shown in Table 2.
All the coke/slag combinations have been performed with CRI test treated coke samples. However, in order to compare, all the coke samples in untreated condition (raw coke) have also been tested with Slag I. The tests have been repeated a few times to check for acceptable reproducibility.
Every coke/slag combination provided significant observations. In all cases of the treated samples, the slag droplet infiltrates the coke substrate through the pores, sometimes even before reaching 1600oC. The descriptions of all possible phenomena are listed below. Letters in brackets represent each corresponding phenomenon.
Complete infiltration of the slag droplet in coke before reaching 1600oC (I)
The droplet remains until 1600oC and disappears during the holding time (H)
The droplet does not disappear and remains on the surface after holding and cooling from 1600oC (HF)
Strong pulsation of droplet during heating/holding (P)
Table 4 summarizes the observation for each CRI test treated coke/slag combination. Tests with untreated samples are listed separately.
TABLE 4:
Observations for different CRI treated coke/slag combination tests (Please refer to the abbreviations mentioned in 4.1)
From the matrix given in Table 4, it can be inferred that cokes with lower reactivity values show more wettability at higher temperatures than cokes with higher CRI values. In parallel, it can also be concluded that slags with low viscosity (i.e. high fluidity) show complete wetting at lower temperatures. So, given a combination of a high CRI coke along with a low viscosity slag, it will show full wetting at a much lower temperature and vice-versa. It can also be noted that, although C2 and C3 apparently exhibit the same behaviour, the spreading of the slag drop on the coke surface and sinking temperature are different in all cases.
In contrast, raw coke samples, when combined with Slag I, never showed full wetting, as shown in Table 5. The slag drop remains during the holding time and can be seen on the surface after cooling. Slag drops tested with untreated samples also show vigorous pulsation during the holding time. A possible reason could be the removal of the residual volatile matter present in the coke or gas generation by certain interfacial reactions.
TABLE 5:
Observations for untreated coke/slag combination tests (Please refer to the abbreviations mentioned in 4.1)
C1
C2
C2
Slag I
HF, P
HF, P
HF, P
The radical difference between the wetting behaviour of treated and untreated cokes occurs due to the difference of porosity in their structures. Coke is inherently a highly porous material. A typical pore and matrix microstructure of coke is shown in Fig. 4.
Fig. 4
Microstructure of coke showing distribution of large pores (Sample C3)
×
Many pores in a coke structure are long and interconnected. In one experiment, pictures acquired from the DST instrument show that a slag droplet sinks inside the coke substrate in one area and little later oozes out from another part of the coke sample (Fig. 5). Long interconnected pores inherent to the coke structure are broadened after CRI treatment and can hold some slag in the lumps.
Fig. 5
C2/Slag II combination, Temperature - approx. 1570oC, (a) The slag droplet just before sinking, (b) After approx. one minute, the tiny droplet oozing out from surface (marked with a red circle)
×
4.2 Coke/Hot Metal Experiments
The interaction between coke and hot metal is completely different from that between coke and slag. The chemical analysis of the industrial HM sample is shown in Table 6.
TABLE 6:
Hot metal composition (all values are in mass %)
C
Mn
Si
S
P
Cu
4.60
1.16
0.585
0.05
0.07
0.005
The HM sample exhibits an almost completely non-wetting behaviour with cokes. Even with the highly porous CRI-treated coke samples, it shows almost no wetting (Fig. 6).
Fig. 6
HM drop on coke substrate at 1600oC showing wetting to a very little extent
×
5 Conclusion
The current work is an attempt to demonstrate the wetting behaviour of coke with different liquid phases under the simulated conditions of the bosh zone of the blast furnace. This method uses coke pieces treated under ISO 18894 conditions as the substrate material. A comparison of the wetting behaviour between treated and untreated coke samples implies that the coke quality, especially the CRI value, is a key to predict its performance in the bosh zone. Tests with different slags demonstrate the effect of chemical composition and viscosity on the wetting process. Some ideas about the hold-up behaviour of a particular slag can be inferred from these experiments. This work also points out that hot metal does not contribute significantly to the hold-up phenomenon. This technique provides a better understanding of the interfacial phenomena in the lower zone of the blast furnace.
Open access funding provided by Montanuniversität Leoben.
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.
Die im Laufe eines Jahres in der „adhäsion“ veröffentlichten Marktübersichten helfen Anwendern verschiedenster Branchen, sich einen gezielten Überblick über Lieferantenangebote zu verschaffen.
