Skip to main content

2016 | Buch

Impact of Circular Migration on Human, Political and Civil Rights

A Global Perspective

herausgegeben von: Carlota Solé, Sonia Parella, Teresa Sordé Martí, Sonja Nita

Verlag: Springer International Publishing

Buchreihe : United Nations University Series on Regionalism

insite
SUCHEN

Über dieses Buch

This volume addresses the topic of circular migration with regard to its multiple dimensions and human, political and civil rights implications from a global perspective. It combines theoretical and empirical studies and presents different case studies illustrating circular migration patterns and policies in different world regions. Circular migration processes – understood as the back-and-forth movement of people between countries and regions- form part of the changing nature of migration movements across the world at the beginning of the 21st century. Over the past decades, international, regional and internal migration flows have shown a quantitative increase and have changed in scope, context, origin and nature. Migration projects are every time more open-ended, multi-directional and flexible and often include some type of circularity. Instead of mere “push-pull-scenarios”, people migrate for many different reasons, including personal, family, professional, academic or political ones. In the 21st century migration journeys and the reasons underlying them are multiple and more diverse than ever before.

Inhaltsverzeichnis

Frontmatter
Chapter 1. Introduction
Theoretical Aspects of Circular Migration
Abstract
Global movements and migrations have been part of human history forever. In recent decades, the global migration stock has increased more than in any other point in history, posing new questions and challenges not only concerning its political management but also regarding the persistence of global economic disparities. An element which is new are the increasing opportunities for mobility and communication that have deeply transformed the experience of those whose lives are touched by migration, including both the ones leading it or those left behind. Migratory movements are not only quantitatively more relevant but also distinct in their scope, extent, context, origin and nature. Migration projects are less unidirectional, definitive or permanent and are instead open-ended, multidirectional, and flexible. Migration is much more complex than flows of people from poor countries heading to richer countries in search of better opportunities. In this regard, South-South migration has gained importance in both academic and policy circles since most of the world migratory movements take place between countries of the global South. Furthermore, migration involves persons from diverse gender, ages, educational levels and social positions. The global economic recession has encouraged additional layers to emerge (e.g. return management, xenophobic attitudes, welfare system stability, limitations of nation-states and so on) on top of the existing panorama, all deserving closer attention. It has also put on the political and research agenda the mobility patterns within the immigrant population, as part of the strategies developed to better cope with the crisis. Yet migration studies, along with policies, have been approaching migration as a unilinear process, with a clear stated beginning and ultimate end.
Carlota Solé, Sonia Parella, Teresa Sordé Martí, Sonja Nita

Its Policy Dimension and the Ways Circular Migration Are Currently Being Promoted as a Policy Tool

Frontmatter
Chapter 2. Circular Migration Within the EU-Moldova Mobility Partnership
A Well-Rounded Approach?
Abstract
Bearing the promise of triple win for sending and receiving countries as well as migrants, circular migration has been taken up by the EU as a policy instrument to better manage migratory movements of third country nationals. Within the context of the EU-Moldova Mobility Partnership this approach has yielded only few results as both conceptual and policy ambiguity continues to exist about the meaning and rationale of circular migration. Moreover, regulated circular migration schemes have not yet been fully implemented while their shortcomings are gradually recognized by different stakeholders. The paper argues that the focus should therefore be on improving the legal framework and conditions to allow Moldovan migrants to go back and forth between their country of origin and destination. It also recommends to make more use of the Mobility Partnership as “regional approach” towards migration and to enable the conclusion of multilateral agreements between Moldova and different EU Member States.
Sonja Nita
Chapter 3. Circular Migration and the Gulf States
Abstract
In this chapter the authors assess the application of the circular migration framework to the six Gulf Cooperation Council member states of Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, Qatar, United Arab Emirates, and Oman. By some estimations, the six GCC states comprise the third largest migratory destination in the contemporary world, and for decades these states have hosted large transient migrant populations that, in some manner or another, appear to fit the definition of circular migration. Through an analysis of migration to the Gulf States this chapter provides an empirical contribution to the expanding discussion of circular migration. In this chapter the nexus between the Gulf migration system and the circular migration framework is configured around two focal points. After an overview of migration in the Gulf States, the authors first examine the policy frameworks that regulate and govern migration to the GCC. Second, using an ethnographic lens, the authors explore the experiences of the migrants at work in the region. They conclude with a discussion of the implications of promoting the circular migration framework in the region.
Zahra Babar, Andrew Gardner
Chapter 4. Mexican Immigration to the United States and the Vulnerability of Migrants and Their Circularity
Abstract
This paper deals with three parts: The first deals with a discussion on the US Mexico Border Region. The second part deals with a theoretical frame for the analysis of vulnerability of migrants as subjects of human rights. The third deals with circularity of Migration at the US Mexico Border Area. Data on the last 9 years of circularity through the US Mexico Border is presented in several tables and graphs. As section is also included on Central American Immigration and US politics of Immigration. This last part ends with a discussion on the “Dreamers”, namely, Mexican undocumented immigrants that were brought to the United States at earlier ages by their parents.
Jorge A. Bustamante
Chapter 5. Explaining the Impasse of Circular Migration in Southern Africa
From the Migrant Labour System to Deregulation
Abstract
Circular migration (CM) is not a trendy concept in Southern Africa. This is in spite of over a century of circular labour migration to the South African mining and agricultural sectors strictly regulated by bilateral agreements. In the post-apartheid period, outsourcing of the core industrial sectors (mining) and liberalisation in agriculture and services have resulted in a structural shift in labour demand. Drawing on a range of ecumenical data (recent statistics releases, interviews, and empirical research), this paper examines existing policy and management contradictions in the facilitation of regional labour movement towards South Africa. The paper sets out on a critical examination of existing statistics before turning to a review of South African policy instruments showing the use of deportation and regularisation schemes as unofficial but de facto CM mechanisms. The paper then examines regulatory frameworks for skilled migration from the region showing the barriers to facilitated movement. It then closes on an analysis of the protracted deadlock at sub-regional level. The paper finds that CM is only beginning to be considered as a policy option by Southern African policy-makers as a labour instrument. The paper concludes that South African policy-makers have protected the vested interests of the mining sector and commercial agriculture about fifteen years into the post-apartheid period and have no yet fully embraced a regional approach to labour migration.
Aurelia Segatti

Circular Migration from the Perspective of the Agency of Migrants and Its Transnational Dimension

Frontmatter
Chapter 6. Thinking Circularity and Gender Transversality in Contemporary Migration
Abstract
The issue of the circularity of migrants has been analyzed as a key aspect of the complexity of global migration. Since the 1990s the post-Fordist model has encouraged us to consider different approaches to European international migration. In the 1990s, authors such as Tarrius indicated the importance of the post-Fordist model and the emergence of circularity trends amongst Moroccans in Southern Europe. In particular he addressed territories located in Catalonia, Spain or in the South of France, in cities such as Perpignan and Marseille. This study will focus on how Moroccan migration became one of the most representative communities in this new model. It will consider the type of circularities in existence, regarding simultaneously the origin and destination of migrants, the different European locations and their insertion in intra-European borders. This chapter delves into the theoretical problems surrounding such circulations. Such problems explored through ethnography of circulation dynamics, and going more deeply into three ethnographic moments: Tangiers as a border-city, migrations from the Jebala Mountains and the insertion of Moroccan in intra-European border areas.
Natalia Ribas-Mateos
Chapter 7. Freedom Against Control: Bolivian Circular Mobility Tradition in the Spanish and International Migration Policies Context
Abstract
Although Bolivian migration has always been diverse and its patterns cannot be generalized into a single mobility model, it is possible to find a cyclical tradition in the way Bolivian families have alternated migration to different destinations with home-returning decisions throughout the time. Studying the current situation of Bolivians in Spain, this chapter focuses on a problematic hypothesis that suggests that that circular mobility tradition is facing a period of crisis and re-definition due to internal factors, which come from its own complexity (job and retirement plans, family assimilation to destiny societies, etc.), and due to external factors, especially related with “migration management” policies that avoid free circulation unless this one is controlled and harmonic to the receiving country’s needs.
Leonardo de la Torre Ávila
Chapter 8. Temporary Migration and the Shortcomings of Citizenship
The Case of Female Circular Migration from Romania to Italy
Abstract
In this chapter we analyze and discuss a specific kind of circular migration, which is oriented to return and whose rationale and goals imply that migrants do not seek, and indeed actively avoid, any sort of involvement and investment in the receiving society. We show that neither the traditional notion of national citizenship, nor the more flexible notion of post-national citizenship can accommodate the life plans and address the specific vulnerabilities of this special category of migrants. As an illustration of the phenomenology of this kind of migratory practices, and of the normative issues they raise, we refer to the case of circular migration of Romanian domestic and care workers in Italy. In order to tackle the specific needs and plans of these migrants, we suggest, we had better put aside the language of equal citizenship and of citizenship rights, and envision instead special rights meant to facilitate their unorthodox life projects.
Valeria Ottonelli, Tiziana Torresi

Circular Migration and Its Multiple Impacts on Human Development and Citizenship Rights

Frontmatter
Chapter 9. Incomplete Subjects: Circular Migration and the Life and Death Struggles of the Migrant Workers in China
Abstract
This chapter attempts to engage in the debate of circular migration in a global context by looking at the internal migration of Chinese workers from the rural to urban areas in general and the lived experience of the low and semi-skilled migrant workers at the industrial workplace, in particular at the Foxconn Technology Group. In this sense, this chapter analyzes critically the effects of circular migration in China that create adverse impacts on the lives of the rural migrants both in the sphere of production and reproduction. By putting in a class perspective in the circular migration studies, this paper hopes to enrich the debate on circular migration from a non-western perspective as well as to provide a better understanding of the lived struggles of the migrant workers from the bottom. This study focuses on the emergence of a new Chinese migrant working class who is now developed into its second generation at a time when China rapidly turns itself into a “world factory”, and facilitates an approach to the reality of migrant workers, showing that negative experiences of circular migration to its extreme may even cause suicides of the youth migrant workers.
Pun Ngai
Chapter 10. Democracy on the Move?
The Potential Link Between Circular Migration and Democratization
Abstract
This chapter argues that circular migration may contribute to transformation in areas that have so far been rarely touched upon in the debate. Besides the transfer of financial remittances and professional skills, political and (un)democratic attitudes and practices may also be diffused through temporary or circular migration. Based on a survey among 1000 Philippine return migrants from six destinations and qualitative research, this chapter shows that at an individual level, the migration experience may have a positive or negative influence on the democratic attitudes of migrants. This effect might be enforced through circular migration, because it provides the migrant with a regular “reality check” in comparing home and destination country. The findings are discussed with reference to a clearly democratic country (Japan), a clearly authoritarian state (Saudi Arabia) and the “special case” of Hong Kong. For policy makers, the case studies allow to draw a conclusion that opens up new vistas: If circular migrants should contribute to the development in their home countries, it is of utmost importance to provide them with opportunities for organizing and political participation while being abroad.
Stefan Rother
Chapter 11. From the Brain Drain to the Brain Circulation: Typology of a Romanian Brain Network
Abstract
The classical approaches on skilled migration focus on the negative effects of the phenomenon through concepts such as brain drain. Geopolitical, economic, social and technological changes occurred in the last decades allow the development of new theoretical tools that enable a better understanding of the skilled migration processes. From this perspective, the chapter aims to review the main concepts provided by the literature on skilled migration and to highlight the potential of the brain networking perspective as a theoretical and political tool. The second objective of the chapter is to present the main findings of the survey conducted in 2010 to a sample of 217 skilled Romanian immigrants that are part of the international brain network GRASP (Global Romanian Society of Young Professionals).
Alisa Petroff
Chapter 12. Circular Migration and Entrepreneurship Development in Ghana
Abstract
Migration patterns and processes across or within borders is not a new phenomenon. For so many years, a considerable amount of attention and research have been attached to the issue of loss of labour in the source country, the increase in population and its associated pressures on social amenities and available jobs on destination countries. Current policy debate has however shifted to circular migration as a mechanism that makes migration beneficial to individuals, home countries and destination countries simultaneously. In this chapter we focus on a type of “managed” circular migration in which potential migrants are selected, orientated and sent in response to job openings in a receiving-country and employed for a predetermined period of time. In countries with established experience of this system it is noted that circular migration plays an important role as a source of labour supply for labour scarce countries and also reduces the trend of illegal migration. Ghana implemented its first form of managed circular migration with Italy as a pilot programme in 2011, where 20 young men were sent to work in Italy’s agriculture sector. In this chapter we take a look at how this managed circular migration scheme can encourage entrepreneurship development in Ghana. The chapter also discusses the current policy environment and its interplay with the managed circular migration scheme and makes some policy suggestions that can make all three parties gain in this scheme.
Clement Adamba, Peter Quartey
Chapter 13. Concluding Remarks
Abstract
In this chapter, editors provide overall concluding remarks for the volume. Authors highlight until which extent the wide variety of cases presented here represent step forwards in the traditional ways we have understood migration in general, and more particularly, circular migration (CM). Three dimensions are identified as key in defining the phenomenon: CM as a process with its own dynamics, as a policy dimension composed by a mixture of normative aspirations and empirically untested hypotheses, and finally, the subjective view of individuals who are actually circulating and the actual options available to them.
Carlota Solé, Sonia Parella, Teresa Sordé Martí, Sonja Nita
Backmatter
Metadaten
Titel
Impact of Circular Migration on Human, Political and Civil Rights
herausgegeben von
Carlota Solé
Sonia Parella
Teresa Sordé Martí
Sonja Nita
Copyright-Jahr
2016
Electronic ISBN
978-3-319-28896-3
Print ISBN
978-3-319-28894-9
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-28896-3

Premium Partner