Introduction
-
Enabling a common understanding of the terminology, for example, for indexing literature, outreach and education, and delimiting the field within the generic domains of IT, scientific projects, and data standards
-
Forming a basis for facilitating the alignment and integration of data produced in citizen science projects by fostering standardisation and interoperability (being able to share information seamlessly across activities)
-
Facilitating the creation of software, database schemas, and data interchange formats for the development of new citizen science applications
-
Supporting potential project participants and other stakeholders to better understand the tasks involved in a particular citizen science project
Towards a Conceptual Model for Citizen Science
-
Information about citizen science projects
-
The people involved
-
Project outcomes, typically data and publications
Stakeholders
Methodology
Related Conceptual Models
Conceptual Models of Projects and Participants
Conceptual model | Aspects related to projects and participants that are covered by the model |
---|---|
The Funding, Research Administration and Projects Ontology (FRAPO) (doi: https://doi.org/10.13140/RG.2.2.26124.92802) (Peroni and Shotton 2018) | Administrative information related to projects (e.g. budget, project partners) |
Information related to project funding | |
Project outputs (e.g. in terms of publications and datasets) | |
The Scholarly Contributions and Roles Ontology (SCoRO) (http://www.sparontologies.net/ontologies/scoro) (Peroni and Shotton 2018) | Roles of people working together on a project (e.g. data creators/managers/curators, principal investigators) |
Contributions of project participants (e.g. intellectual contributions such as conception and design of experiments) | |
The Friend of a Friend vocabulary (FOAF) (http://www.foaf-project.org) | Interests of participants |
Information about participants (e.g. name, age, home page) | |
Relationships between participants (e.g. who knows whom) | |
The Bibliographic Ontology (FaBiO) (http://www.sparontologies.net/ontologies/fabio) (Peroni and Shotton 2012) | Project outcomes in terms of published or publishable results (e.g. scientific publications) |
The PROV Ontology (PROV-O) (http://www.w3.org/TR/prov-o/) | Provenance information about projects (e.g. which project outcomes were produced by whom, with what information and input, and via which project activities) |
Project Description Ontology (https://github.com/dr-shorthair/project-ont) | General information about projects that is independent from a specific application domain |
Conceptual Models of Project Outcomes
The Proposed Conceptual Model for Citizen Science
Project Description
-
The Project.MetadataRecord module, which captures general information about the project, including its provenance
-
The Project.Annotation module, which captures information, like tags, used for annotating project descriptions
-
The Project.Funding module, which captures project funding information
-
The Project.Infrastructure module, which captures information about project infrastructure (hardware, software, services, etc.)
-
The Project.Geography module, which captures geographical information about the project
-
The Dataset module, which captures information about project datasets
-
The Project.Participant module, which captures information about project participants and their activities within a project
Participation and Activity Description
Application in Case Studies
Instantiation of Projects
Concept | Project instantiation | Project instantiation |
---|---|---|
OpenStreetMap | Bash the Bug | |
Activity | OSM mapping event OR data capture facilitation | Assessment of antibiotic effect (a) |
ActivityAgentDependency | (a) – (u) | |
Agent | Zooniverse user (u) | |
AssociatedPublications | ||
Consortium | ||
ContactDescription | ||
ContactPoint | ||
DataCollectionMethod | On-screen digitising | Web crowdsourcing (on-screen recognition) |
Dataset | OSM change set | Antibiotics sensitivity dataset |
Description | ||
Email | ||
EndDate | ||
ExecutionPlan | Mapping campaign, HOT task | |
GeographicExtent | ||
GroupOfAgents | ||
Hardware | ||
Initiative | ||
KnowledgeItem | GIS fundamentals | |
Machine | ||
MeansOfContact | ||
Motivation | Contribute free map data | |
Name | ||
Observation | OSM feature | |
Origin | ||
OGC:Datastream | ||
OGC:Sensor | ||
Organisation | ||
OrganisationCategory | ||
Output | ||
OutputItem | Geometric primitive (point, lines) | Record (infection sample – >sensitivity to antibiotics) |
ParticipantAcknowledgment | OSM user id | Authorship recognition |
Participation | OSM contribution | |
ParticipationTask | Image classification | |
Person | OSM contributor | |
PrivacyProtectionPolicy | Terms of use in signup | |
PrivacyProtectionTechnique | Person is behind user id | Zooniverse informed consent |
Project | ||
Publication | OSM upload | |
RecruitmentMethod | Mapping event invitation, conferences, courses | |
Role | OSM mapper; OSM validator | |
Sensor | ||
Skill | Image interpretation | |
Software (as tool) | Mobile/web editors | Zooniverse classification web app |
Software (as output) | ||
SpatialAreaofInterest | ||
StartDate | ||
Status | ||
TemporalExtent | OSM mapping event duration | |
Tag | ||
Tool | OSM editor, e.g. iD, JOSM, etc. | |
Training | Online self-training, Wiki specs | 8-slide tutorial |
WebPage |
Concept | Project instantiation | Project instantiation |
---|---|---|
JRC Citizen Science Project Inventory | Participatory Toponym Handling Project | |
Activity | Toponymic data handling OR toponymic field survey | |
ActivityAgentDependency | ||
Agent | Citizens, local government, university, Badan Informasi Geospasial (BIG) | |
AssociatedPublications | ||
Consortium | ||
ContactDescription | ||
ContactPoint | ||
DataCollectionMethod | Geographic data collection: fieldwork and office treatment | |
DataSet | Toponymic files and gazetteers | |
Description | Brief description | |
Email | ||
EndDate | End year | |
ExecutionPlan | Workshops (toponymic field survey campaign), citizen science project on toponym, local government project on toponym, HOT (Indonesia) task | |
GeographicExtent | Geographical extent | West Java province |
GroupOfAgents | ||
Hardware | Tablets | |
Initiative | ||
KnowledgeItem | Toponymy | |
Machine | ||
MeansOfContact | Contact | |
Motivation | Contribute toponymic data, preserve embedded knowledge on toponyms, collect toponyms in their surrounding areas | |
Name | Name | |
Observation | Place names, coordinates, history, pronunciation | |
Origin | Source | |
OGC:Datastream | ||
OGC:Sensor | ||
Organisation | ||
OrganisationCategory | Lead organisation category; project initiator category | |
Output | Dataset (toponyms, gazetteers) | |
OutputItem | Geometric primitive (point), audio (pronunciation of toponym) | |
ParticipantAcknowledgment | Reward-based approach, incentive, capacity building opportunities | |
Participation | Local toponyms | |
ParticipationTask | Providing place name and related information | |
Person | CitSciTopon contributor, LocalGovt contributor, OSM contributor | |
PrivacyProtectionPolicy | Terms of use in signup | |
PrivacyProtectionTechnique | Person is behind user id | |
Project | Project | |
Publication | SAKTI upload | |
RecruitmentMethod | Toponymic training event invitation, Toponymic survey invitation | |
Role | Data collector; data verificator/validator | |
Sensor | ||
Skill | Interview, communication with local people | |
Software (as tool) | Mobile/web editors | |
Software (as output) | ||
SpatialAreaofInterest | Geographic coverage | |
StartDate | Start year | |
Status | Still active | |
TemporalExtent | National naming authority event programme duration | |
Tag | Primary environmental domain; primary environmental field; primary category of project | |
Tool | EpiCollect, SAKTI application, ODK and OSM OpenMapKit | |
Training | Training on toponymy, workshops, focus group discussions | |
WebPage | Website |
Concept | Project instantiation | Project instantiation |
---|---|---|
Mars in Motion | MICS Project | |
Activity | Online classification of Martian surface (a) | Online assessment of project impact (a) |
ActivityAgentDependency | (a) – (u) | (a) – (u) |
Agent | Human (u) and machine | Human (u) and machine |
AssociatedPublications | ||
Consortium | FP7 i-Mars project | Horizon 2020 Project |
ContactDescription | Project contact | Project contact |
ContactPoint | James Sprinks | Luigi Ceccaroni |
DataCollectionMethod | On-screen analysis | On-screen survey |
DataSet | ESA Mars Express HRSC Camera | MICS Impact Assessment Corpus of Knowledge |
Description | ||
Email | james.sprinks@nottingham.ac.uk | lceccaroni@earthwatch.org.uk |
EndDate | ||
ExecutionPlan | Project deliverables/timeline | Project deliverables/timeline |
GeographicExtent | ||
GroupOfAgents | ||
Hardware | N/A | N/A |
Initiative | iMars | MICS |
KnowledgeItem | Scientific concept | Project outputs |
Machine | Change detection algorithm | Impact assessment algorithm |
MeansOfContact | Email | Email |
Motivation | Contribute to understanding of Martian surface evolution | To understand the impact of their project |
Name | Jo Bloggs | Joanna Blogson |
Observation | Martian geomorphological feature | Impact measurement |
Origin | ||
OGC:Datastream | N/A | N/A |
OGC:Sensor | N/A | N/A |
Organisation | iMars project consortium | MICS project consortium |
OrganisationCategory | European FP7 Project Funded | European H2020 Project Funded |
Output | Martian geomorphological features that evolve temporally | Impact assessment |
OutputItem | Distance, speed, typology | Report |
ParticipantAcknowledgment | Authorship, acknowledgement in publication | Acknowledgement on website |
Participation | Mars in Motion contribution | MICS contribution |
ParticipationTask | To detect changes on the Martian surface, through comparison of two images | To evaluate the impact of their citizen science project |
Person | Mars in Motion participant | MICS participant |
PrivacyProtectionPolicy | Zooniverse privacy policy | MICS privacy policy |
PrivacyProtectionTechnique | Zooniverse informed consent | MICS informed consent |
Project | ||
Publication | Database of Martian feature change | Project impact assessment report |
RecruitmentMethod | Online correspondence to existing Zooniverse community | |
Role | Project participant | Project coordinator |
Sensor | ||
Skill | Image interpretation | Assessing project processes/output that have impact |
Software (as tool) | Web platform (Zooniverse) | Web platform |
Software (as output) | N/A | N/A |
SpatialAreaofInterest | ||
StartDate | ||
Status | ||
TemporalExtent | 30 years + of historical data | Unlimited |
Tag | ||
Tool | Online Zooniverse image annotation | Online survey data entry |
Training | Online training (compulsory) | Online guidance/examples |
WebPage |
-
OpenStreetMap. OpenStreetMap (OSM) is a well-known crowdsourcing project in which thousands of volunteers maintain an online map of the world. OSM has all the characteristics of participation and data handling we see in many other citizen science projects. In addition, OSM is an essential geographical reference for many citizen science projects.
-
Bash the Bug (Zooniverse). The objective of the Bash the Bug project is to improve tuberculosis diagnosis. The task of the volunteers is to accurately determine which antibiotics are effective for each of the collected tuberculosis samples. This is carried out by analysing pictures of plates showing the effects of several antibiotics on the tested sample.
-
Mars in Motion (Zooniverse). Mars in Motion was created to look for and identify geological changes on the surface of Mars over time by gathering in-depth data on the type of features that are detected. It is part of the i-Mars.eu project, which includes several European partners, and is focused on developing tools and datasets to increase the exploitation of space-based data from the US National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) and the European Space Agency (ESA) Mars mission beyond the scientific community.
-
MICS. The MICS project provides an integrated platform of metrics and instruments to measure both the costs and the benefits of citizen science. These metrics and instruments consider the impacts of citizen science on the following domains: society, governance, the economy, the environment, and science.
Deployment of the Conceptual Model
JRC Citizen Science Project Inventory
Participatory Toponym Handling Project
Roadmap for Future Research and Use
-
Develop procedures to respond to existing regulatory or legal frameworks related to citizen science, such as the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive (in Europe) and the provision of related best practices and tools.23
-
Involve the ECSA, CSA, ACSA, and the Citizen Science Global Partnership (CSGP) in the definition of an agenda for the model’s practical implementation and possibly as hosts for interoperable catalogues of citizen science projects and data. They could also provide guidelines on the use of existing solutions.
-
Include a dedicated section on ECSA, CSA, ACSA, EU-Citizen.Science, and CSGP websites to explain the conceptual model and provide introductory information.
-
Develop extensions related to more diverse outcomes, such as mathematical theorems, hardware, and policy and societal impacts.
-
Develop communication approaches to help practitioners navigate through the various standards and concepts (e.g. a ‘choose your own adventure’ approach; see also the Digital Curation Centre24 for additional ideas).