2012 | OriginalPaper | Buchkapitel
Rank Reversal as a Source of Uncertainty and Manipulation in the PROMETHEE II Ranking: A First Investigation
verfasst von : Julien Roland, Yves De Smet, Céline Verly
Erschienen in: Advances in Computational Intelligence
Verlag: Springer Berlin Heidelberg
Aktivieren Sie unsere intelligente Suche, um passende Fachinhalte oder Patente zu finden.
Wählen Sie Textabschnitte aus um mit Künstlicher Intelligenz passenden Patente zu finden. powered by
Markieren Sie Textabschnitte, um KI-gestützt weitere passende Inhalte zu finden. powered by
PROMETHEE II is an aggregating procedure based on pairwise comparisons for ranking alternatives evaluated on multiple criteria. As other outranking methods, PROMETHEE II does not satisfy the assumption of independence to third alternatives. In other words, the ranks of two given alternatives may be influenced by the presence of a third one. This phenomenon, also called rank reversal, can be viewed as a source of uncertainty on the final ranking. Additionally, it raises the natural question of possible rank manipulations by adding ”well-chosen” alternatives. This problem is studied in the context of a simplified version of the PROMETHEE II method also known as the Copland score. A linear program is proposed to test whether there is a way to rank a given alternative at the first position by adding artificial ones. Simulations are used to quantify the likelihood of this possibility and to test if it can be avoided.