BaTiO3, Ba2NiTi5O13 and their Na-doped analogues were successfully synthesized via sol–gel and calcination methods. The surface properties of the prepared catalysts were characterized by scanning electron microscopy and nitrogen adsorption–desorption analysis while the basicity was determined by benzoic acid titration. The catalytic activity of the Ba-based catalysts was verified in transesterification of palm cooking oil with methanol. The optimization study was conducted by varying the oil:methanol ratio, catalyst loading, reaction temperature and duration. The highest methyl ester (ME) yield was ~95% for 5 wt/v% Na-Ba2NiTi5O13 at a methanol to oil ratio of 12:1 at 150 °C for 2 h.
Introduction
Biodiesel has attracted interest as a promising energy source to substitute the drastically depleted fossil fuels in recent decades [1]. The main content in biodiesel is fatty acid methyl ester (FAME), which is an environmentally friendly fuel with clean burn, easily made, biodegradable, non-toxic and free of sulfur and aromatic compounds [2]. Transesterification reaction is the most common method to convert vegetable oils or animal fat into FAMEs using methanol in the presence of suitable catalyst. Generally, heterogeneous catalysts are preferred over homogenous catalysts as it provides advantages such as simple separation process, good reusability and saponification prevention [3, 4].
Metal oxides have been extensively studied as heterogeneous base catalysts in transesterification. The presence of Mδ+–O δ− ion pairs in these oxides produces basic sites that are believed to be actively involved in the transesterification reaction [5]. Several attempts have been employed to further improve their catalytic properties and stability, such as doping [6, 7], immobilizing or supporting [8] and mixed oxide systems [9, 10]. For example, Mukenga et al. [8] have shown that the oil conversion for TiO2 supported ZnO is higher than unsupported ZnO catalyst. Mar and Somsook [6] showed that the catalytic activity and stability of CaO catalyst can be enhanced by doping with KCl. Lee et al. [9] also proved that the binary MgO–ZnO catalyst exhibits superior physicochemical properties as compared to MgO or ZnO catalysts.
Anzeige
Barium oxide catalysts were reported to exhibit superior catalytic performance in transesterification. The catalytic reactivity of BaO is higher than CaO, SrO and MgO due to its high basicity [11‐16]. The catalytic properties of BaO supported on Al2O3 [17], SiO2 [18] and SrO(Al2O3) [19] towards the transesterification reaction have also been studied. The reactivity of the supported BaO catalysts can be related to its dispersion on the support, surface composition and surface properties. Thus far, the study on barium-based binary or tertiary oxides in transesterification is rarely reported. The only two recent studies were conducted by Sherstyuk et al. [20, 21]. They successfully prepared Ba–Al–O (viz. BaAl13.2O20.8 and BaAl12O19) and Ba–La–O (viz. BaLa2O4/La2O3 and Ba0.04La1.96O3) binary systems via precipitation and calcination method and demonstrated their application in the transesterification of rapeseed oil. The stability of Ba–Al–O is higher than Ba–La–O binary catalysts and the conversion of rapeseed oil over Ba–Al–O can achieve ~100% at optimum conditions.
Recently, we have successfully synthesized BaTiO3, Na-doped BaTiO3 [22] and Ba2NiTi5O13 [23] particles via sol–gel and calcination method. As the continuation of the work, herewith, we report their catalytic study in the transesterification of palm cooking oil. The Na-doped Ba2NiTi5O13 was also prepared for comparison purposes. The surface properties of un-doped and doped oxides are studied via SEM, BET and benzoic acid titration. The influence of sodium dopant on the surface properties, as well as the catalytic performance is also reported in this study.
Materials and methods
Materials
All materials were used as purchased. Titanium tetraisopropoxide (Ti(OPri)4, 99.999%, Fluka), barium hydroxide monohydrate (Ba(OH)2.H2O, ≥98%, Fluka), nickel acetate tetrahydrate (Ni(CH3COO)2.4H2O, ≥99.0%, Fluka), sodium hydroxide (NaOH, ≥99.99%, JT Baker), sodium carbonate (NaCO3, ≥99.5%, R&M), methanol (CH3OH; ≥98%, R&M Chemicals), isopropanol ((CH3)2CHOH, ≥99.7%, R&M Chemicals), n-hexane (C6H14, ≥99%, QRëC), benzoic acid (C6H5COOH, ≥99.5%, Sigma Aldrich) and acetic acid (CH3COOH, ≥99.8%, Systerm) were analytical grade. Palm cooking oil (Delima Oil Products Sdn. Bhd) was obtained commercially.
Preparation of catalysts
In general, the catalysts were prepared via sol–gel method followed by calcination. Detailed description on the preparation of BaTiO3, Na-doped BaTiO3 and Ba2NiTi5O13 has been reported elsewhere [22, 23].
Anzeige
BaTiO3 and sodium doped BaTiO3 (Na-BaTiO3)
As much as 399.7 mg of Ba(OH)2.H2O was dissolved in 40 mL of distilled water heated in an oil bath at 50 °C. Then, 8 mL of 0.044 M of Ti(OPri)4 in isopropanol (molar ratio of Ba:Ti = 6:1) was then added. The mixture was stirred for 2 h under reflux. The product (in gel form) was separated via centrifugation and washed with distilled water. The BaTiO3 catalyst was obtained by calcination of the gel at 900 °C for an hour. The 0.5 mol% sodium doped derivatives was similarly prepared. However, the stipulated NaCO3 was added to Ba(OH)2.H2O before the addition of Ti(OPri)4. The obtained gel was then calcined at 900 °C for 5 h.
Ba2NiTi5O13 and sodium doped Ba2NiTi5O13 (Na-Ba2NiTi5O13)
Typically, the Ba2NiTi5O13 was synthesized via two-steps. As much as 5 × 10−3 mol of Ni(CH3COO)2.4H2O was dissolved in a mixture of isopropanol/acetic acid. Then, 1.5 mL of 3.33 M Ti(OPri)4 was added (at a mole ratio of Ni:Ti = 1:1). The mixture was stirred at room temperature for 24 h until an olive green solution was formed. As much as 50 mL of distilled water was then added before subjecting to partial freeze-drying process. The obtained product (as-prepared NiTiO3 gel) was used in the subsequent step.
In a separate flask, 799.4 mg of Ba(OH)2.H2O was dissolved in 80 mL of distilled water and mixed with 32 mL of 3.0 M NaOH. The whole system was heated at 50 °C while stirring to ensure the total dissolution. Then, 652.8 mg of the as-prepared gel obtained previously was added. This was followed by the addition of 16 mL of 0.044 M Ti(OPri)4 in isopropanol. The mole ratio of Ba:Ni:Ti was fixed at 1:1:1.2. The mixture was stirred for another 8 h. The product (in gel form) was separated via centrifugation and washed with distilled water. The Ba2NiTi5O13 catalyst was obtained by the calcination of gel product at 900 °C for 8 h. The sodium doped derivatives (viz. 0.5 mol% Na) were similarly prepared. However, the stipulated NaCO3 was added before addition of Ti(OPri)4 in the second step. The obtained gel product was then calcined at 900 °C for 5 h.
Characterizations
The surface structures and average size of the catalysts were determined by scanning electron microscope (SEM) equipped with electron energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) performed on a Leica Cambridge Stereoscan S360 operating at 15 kV. The surface area and porosity of the catalysts were examined using a Micromeritics ASAP 2000. Samples were degassed at 160 °C prior to isotherm analysis. Branauer–Emmett–Teller (BET) isotherm was performed by adsorption of nitrogen at −196 °C. The surface area was then calculated using BET equation. The basicity analyses of the respective catalysts were determined by benzoic acid titration using the following indicators: bromothymol blue (H− = 7.2), phenolphthalein (H− = 8.2–9.8), 2,4-dinitroaniline (H− = 15.0) and 4-nitroaniline (H− = 18.4) [24, 25].
Transesterification reaction
Transesterification reaction was carried out by heating a mixture of palm cooking oil, methanol and the as-prepared catalyst in an autoclave at the desired temperature and duration. The BaTiO3 catalyst was employed to study the reaction optimization for the series of catalysts investigated. The four parameters: reaction temperatures (80–180 °C), duration (0.5–6.0 h), ratios of oil to methanol (1:3–1:15 v/v) and catalyst loading (0.5–10.0 wt/v% referred to the initial palm oil volume) were investigated to determine the optimum reaction conditions.
After the transesterification reaction, the mixture was allowed to cool down before separating the methyl ester (ME) by centrifugation. The products were weighed and analyzed using an Agilent 7890A gas chromatography (GC) fitted with a flame ionization detector (FID). The % of ME yield was calculated using the following equation [26]:
The typical morphological structures of un-doped and doped oxides are depicted in Fig. 1. All the samples show porous aggregates which were made up of distinct particles. These particles are mostly nearly spherical to cube in shape. The average particle size of the prepared BaTiO3 and Ba2NiTi5O13 are 140.0 ± 31.0 and 89.4 ± 32.2 nm, respectively. These values increased to 240.0 ± 68.0 and 125.1 ± 30.5 nm for the respective oxides upon Na doping. The surface areas and pore sizes of the samples were characterized by BET analysis and are presented in Table 1. The prepared BaTiO3 and Ba2NiTi5O13 exhibited a surface area of about 3.0 and 3.8 m2 g−1, respectively. Na doping decreased the surface area (and therefore the pore size) of the oxides. For instance, the respective surface area for Na-BaTiO3 and Na-Ba2NiTi5O13 was 2.6 and 2.8 m2 g−1.
Fig. 1
Typical SEM micrographs of a BaTiO3, b Na-BaTiO3, c Ba2NiTi5O13 and d Na-Ba2NiTi5O13
Table 1
Surface characteristics of various barium-containing catalysts
Catalyst
Surface area (m2 g−1)
Pore size (nm)
Particle size (nm)
BaTiO3
3.0
30.5
140.0 ± 31.0
Na-BaTiO3
2.6
21.7
240.0 ± 68.0
Ba2NiTi5O13
3.8
39.5
89.4 ± 32.2
Na-Ba2NiTi5O13
2.8
30.8
125.1 ± 30.5
×
Several studies [27, 28] have shown that doping constrains the growth of oxide particles and thus smaller particles with higher surface area are obtained. However, this study shows otherwise, i.e., increment in the average particle size and a decrement in surface area and pore size upon Na doping. This may be attributed to the formation of a dense layer of Na secondary phase on the oxides and plugged the pores. XRD analyses (not shown) have confirmed the formation of Na1.7Ba0.45Ti5.85O13 and NaBa2NiTi5O13 on the respective outermost surface of the BaTiO3 and Ba2NiTi5O13 [22, 23].
As seen in Table 2, BaTiO3 and Ba2NiTi5O13 exert a total basicity of 0.540 and 0.618 mmol g−1, respectively. Most of the basic sites of these oxides are in the range of 7.2 < H− < 8.2 (weaker basic sites). It covers ~54% of the total basic sites. The total basicity of the oxides increased almost twofold upon Na doping. This was 1.062 and 1.336 mmol g−1 for Na-BaTiO3 and Na-Ba2NiTi5O13, respectively. The percentage of medium basic sites in Na-Ba2NiTi5O13 is higher as compared to Na-BaTiO3. The Na-BaTiO3 possess 13.0% while Na-Ba2NiTi5O13 offers 20.4% basic sites in the range of 15.0 < H− < 18.4.
Table 2
Basicity of various oxides and their Na-doped counterparts
Catalyst
Basicity (mmol g−1)
Total basicity (mmol g−1)
H− = 7.2
H− = 8.2–9.8
H− = 15.0
H− = 18.4
BaTiO3
0.29
0.15
0.10
0
0.540
Na-BaTiO3
0.74
0.19
0.14
0
1.062
Ba2NiTi5O13
0.33
0.17
0.12
0
0.618
Na-Ba2NiTi5O13
0.90
0.16
0.27
0
1.336
Optimization of transesterification
The catalytic activities of BaTiO3 at various reaction parameters were compared to obtain the optimum reaction conditions. As seen in Table 3, the percentage of ME yield increases with the increase in the ratio of oil:methanol up to 1:12 (v/v), and thereafter ME yield decreases. For instance, the ME yield for the oil:methanol ratio of 1:3 (v/v) is 82.3%. This increases to 86.5 and 88.1% upon further increase in the oil:methanol volume ratio to 1:9 (v/v) and 1:12 (v/v) correspondingly. Further increase in the content of methanol to 1:15 (v/v) caused the ME yield to drop to 78.8%.
Table 3
Methyl ester conversion of the BaTiO3 catalyst at various conditions
Parameters
% ME yield
Ratio of oil:CH3OH (v/v)
Temperature (°C)
Duration (h)
Catalyst loading (wt/v%)
1:3
150
2.0
5.0
82.3
1:6
150
2.0
5.0
86.4
1:9
150
2.0
5.0
86.5
1:12
150
2.0
5.0
88.1
1:15
150
2.0
5.0
78.8
1:12
150
2.0
0.5
78.2
1:12
150
2.0
1.0
84.4
1:12
150
2.0
2.0
84.5
1:12
150
2.0
10.0
88.8
1:12
150
0.5
5.0
74.8
1:12
150
1.0
5.0
79.5
1:12
150
3.0
5.0
90.8
1:12
150
4.0
5.0
91.3
1:12
150
5.0
5.0
92.0
1:12
150
6.0
5.0
92.1
1:12
80
2.0
5.0
76.0
1:12
100
2.0
5.0
80.8
1:12
120
2.0
5.0
82.3
1:12
180
2.0
5.0
88.2
Palm oil transesterification is a reversible reaction (Eq. 2). Hence, forward reaction is favored in an excess amount of methanol, i.e., from 1:3 to 1:12 (v/v) oil:methanol. However, at high methanol ratio (in the 1:15 (v/v) oil to methanol), the dilution effect becomes prominent. This caused a reduction in reaction rate, hence a lower ME yield is obtained [29]. In addition, large amount of methanol can also promote the solubility of glycerol in the oil and can cause difficulty in the separation of glycerol [30]. Therefore, the ratio of oil to methanol of 1:12 (v/v) is chosen for this transesterification study.
The catalyst loading is another factor that affects the ME yield. Typically, increasing the loading amount of catalysts may provide more catalytic sites for reactants to dock on. In this study, it is observed that the % of ME yield increases gradually from 0.5 to 10 wt/v% catalyst loading. The ME yield was 78.2, 84.5, 88.1 and 88.8% for the 0.5, 2.0, 5.0 and 10.0 wt/v% BaTiO3 loading, respectively. The % yield for the 5 and 10 wt/v% catalyst is similar. Accordingly, the 5 wt/v% catalyst was chosen as the optimum amount for further studies.
An increment of ME yield from 76.0 to 88.1% is achieved via increasing the reaction temperature from 80 to 150 °C. Beyond 150 °C, the ME yield is constant. Generally, increasing temperature helps in homogenizing the reactants, making them more readily to react [31]. Hence, this may assist the transesterification to reach equilibrium faster, and thus affects the % of ME yield for transesterification.
As shown in Table 3, the % of ME yield increases from 74.8 to 88.1% when increasing the time duration from 0.5 to 2 h. After that, the reaction yield is more or less constant (~90–92%). Hence, it is envisaged that 2 h is sufficient to complete the reaction.
Transesterification of palm cooking oil
As shown in Table 2, BaTiO3 demonstrated 88% of ME yield. Ba2NiTi5O13 gave a higher ME value of 91% as compared to BaTiO3. These values increased 2–6% upon doping 0.5 wt% Na into the respective oxide catalysts. The catalytic activity of barium-containing catalysts follows the trend of decreasing order of Na-Ba2NiTi5O13 > Ba2NiTi5O13 > Na-BaTiO3 > BaTiO3.
In general, the catalytic properties are influenced by particle size, surface area, as well as the active sites of a catalyst. Small sized catalyst with high surface area and active sites will give rise to high catalytic performance. In this study, however, the sizes and surface areas seem to contribute to only minor extent towards transesterification. Instead, the catalytic performance of the series of un-doped and doped barium-containing titanate catalysts is believed to be closely related to their basic sites. For instance, the Na-Ba2NiTi5O13 which the highest amount of medium basic sites displayed the highest catalytic activity. However, the Na-BaTiO3 with the smallest average particle size gave lower catalytic activity even though it offers the highest surface area among the series. A similar finding was reported by Nascimento et al. [32]. As previously mentioned [22, 23], a dense layer of Na secondary phase was formed onto the surface of barium-containing titanate catalysts in the Na-doped system. There are 50% more basic sites located on these Na secondary phase as compared to un-doped system. These sites are actively involved in the adsorption of methanol in which the O–H bonds of the methanol readily break into methoxides and proton [33]. The methoxides formed then reacted with the triglyceride to yield methyl esters and glycerols. The proposed mechanism is depicted in Fig. 2.
Fig. 2
Proposed mechanism for the beneficial effect of adding Na onto the barium-containing titanate catalysts
×
Table 4 also shows a comparison of catalytic activity between this work and other barium-containing catalyst systems. As can be seen, the ME yield (88–95%) obtained in this work are comparable to the previous reported values. The highest ME yield achieved in the literature was 100% for the Ba0.04La1.96O3 catalyst using rapeseed oil as the feed stock. Nevertheless, higher catalyst loading and temperature, as well as a longer reaction time were needed as compared to this study.
Table 4
Comparison of catalytic performance of various barium-containing catalysts in the literature
BaTiO3, Ba2NiTi5O13 and their Na-doped analogues were successfully synthesized via sol–gel and calcination method. The prepared BaTiO3 and Ba2NiTi5O13 exert porous aggregated structure with specific surface area of 3–4 m2 g−1. They displayed a total basicity of 0.5–0.6 mmol g−1 with ~81% of weak basic sites. Doping these oxides with Na increased their total basicity (i.e., to 1.1–1.3 mmol g−1) but decreased their surface area and pore size. This may be attributed to the formation of a dense layer of Na secondary phase on the oxides that plugged the pores. The optimum conditions for the transesterification were obtained with 5 wt/v% catalysts loading at oil to methanol ratio of 1:12 (v/v) and at 150 °C for 2 h. Both un-doped and doped BaTiO3 and Ba2NiTi5O13 showed good catalytic activity towards the transesterification of palm cooking oil with more than 85% conversion. The catalytic activity of barium-containing titanate catalysts follows the trend of decreasing order of Na-Ba2NiTi5O13 > Ba2NiTi5O13 > Na-BaTiO3 > BaTiO3. The catalytic performance of these series of un-doped and doped barium-containing catalysts is believed to be closely related to their surface basic sites but not the total surface area.
Acknowledgements
The authors wish to thank the Universiti Sains Malaysia for the financial support in the form of Grant: RU 1001/PKIMIA/811311.
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.
